WW 44: Battlestar Galactica

[Winston Hughes]

It was a pre-planned joke Winston. It wasn't about shutting you down, it was about waiting for the punchline.

This is an annoyingly plausible response.

You can keep the scumpoint for using a pre-planned joke, though, because that's something I never do as town.

[Jabbz]

It was a pre-planned joke Winston. It wasn't about shutting you down, it was about waiting for the punchline.

This is an annoyingly plausible response.

You can keep the scumpoint for using a pre-planned joke, though, because that's something I never do as town.

Did ya miss the part in the next post where I said I know I'm not funny? :P If I don't try preplanned crap they come out worse than that by far :/ Still, I'll wear your scum point with pride. I think it was you who said last game you were shooting for scummy enough to not get killed, towny enough to not get lynched. There are worse places to be.

[Winston Hughes]

I'll say this for Jabbz, if scum he's grasped that trying to Zack his way out of my suspicions is a non-starter, and instead is using reasonable explanation of his thought-processes, which is far more effective.

Town point cancels out the scumpoint and I'm back at nulls-all-round.

[Winston Hughes]

Lewwyn and Adrien have the fewest credits for exposure so far.

[Dp101]

I should probably, you know, actually vote based off of my previous poe that I have established. AdrienIer

[Jabbz]

After an EXHAUSTING re-read of the ENTIRE thread, I noted a few points I missed or wanted to hit on.

Hi everyone! Gazglum, I appreciate your fine memory but I must also cling to tradition, in my case the time-honed strategy of "everyone who votes me is mafia".

This strikes me as somewhat towny. Dp does have, from what I remember, a bit of a predilection for omgus votes, His response to it later also felt genuine, and un-pressured to me.

Yeah, I played one of his games with him a few weeks back. It was a shit show, host called it because two people were horribly at each others throats. Hopefully he won't bring that here. I think novice is trying to make sure he has someone voting against him later so he can point to it for a fake clear. Scummy as heck IMO.

I third the question - scummy as heck?

Also the first part is unfair to Winston (what has he got to do with it?) but obviously you still have bad feelings about that game so we don't have to talk about it.

I don't know why you'd think it's even a possibility that I  might 'bring that here'.

Did you think I was somehow responsible for the nastiness in that game?

To clear it up, no I don't think Winston would bring that here, he was pretty awesome last game, and polite to a fault. It was only part of the setup for my joke. TBH my feelings for the last game are mostly irritation, but they were mitigated by an apology by the individual in question, so meh. Everyone else there was very nice, though their method of 90 gazillion posts instead of 2-3 good ones got old quick :P

[Jabbz]

I mean, if I were to have an ulteriour motive as scum for my initial PS it would probably be to appear solvey and to draw a vote which I could then paint in a suspicious light and OMGUS on. Much like I'm tempted to do now as town.

Previewing, wow, that's a helluva mindmelding crosspost with Winston.

What is this in response to novice? Is it just an addition to your stuff a few posts up?

[Lewwyn]

Yeah, I played one of his games with him a few weeks back. It was a shit show, host called it because two people were horribly at each others throats. Hopefully he won't bring that here. I think novice is trying to make sure he has someone voting against him later so he can point to it for a fake clear. Scummy as heck IMO.

I missed whatever happened, but Winston ahs never really been aggressive or nasty as far as I know.  Is this the joke?

Also are you refering to novice wanting a vote from a scumbuddy or just a vote in general to say "look people have suspected me?"

Haven't finished reading the thread yet.

[Lewwyn]

He was town on my TotalWar game but he acted scummy as all frak.

What exactly are you talking about?

Ah, thank you for the question. I must have conflated you with Zack.

Oh.

[Lewwyn]

Two things. Firstly, I have a townread on both Novice and Winston since I think a mindmeld of that level within the same minute can only ever come from town, and a minor townread on Gaz for responding positively to someone nitpicking his post a bit. If you include me as town, that means that (assuming my reads are correct, which they rarely are) 4/7 of the players are town from my perspective, which means that within the last 3 (lew, adrien, Jabbz) there are the entire scum team. I don't think I am as right as this post might suggest, but I am at least confident.

Secondly, there are 7 players. If we assume the traditional D1 mislynch goes off, then the doctor fails in their duty, we are left with 3 town and 2 mafia, putting us at lylo on D2. This has the potential to be a very quick game if town are not at the top of their game.

Wait.  A mindmeld of what level? I swear I'm not being obtuse, but I really don't see the correlation.  

I also don't see any reason why a "mindmeld" would clear two independently acting people. What? Scum and town both posting at the same time could achieve the same effect.

I swear my head is spinning.

BBL have to give exams.