WW26: The Masquerade [Game Thread]

[Widow Edith]

Part 2 those I have no problem to lynch

Sister Mary: There are scummier targets out there but keeping silent (and so avoid any slipups) is not pro-town either. We had a player before who as wolf used the "No-Time"excuse effectively.

Rob the Filch: He tries to contribute but as soon he got suspected he broke off any communication and stormed out uttering insults. Also his play has done a turn to the worse. On D1 I thought him more of a villager. Today less so. I'm wary of people who start pro-town but get scummier each day (I call it the pling-syndrome of wolves).

Small Richard: One of the low-contributors. In his big post today he first sides with Harry (who calls Scarlet scum ) but then turns around and votes Elizabeth because he has no strong feeling. I don't like that I don't like it at all.

@ Scarlet John
Why would you be assumed to be faking if you post something? If the village is pushing people for not contributing, and then they contribute, I don't see how that leads to them being automatically lynched for faking it. The whole point of pushing someone for not posting is to get them to post so we can get a read on them. If you come off as scummy then yes people may stay on you, but it's a fallacious argument to say that you will be lynched just for posting. You're creating a fabricated no-win situation you say you're in and it seems incredibly scummy.

Agree with Harry here.

.....

Elizabeth, since I'm not feeling any particularly strong conviction on either of them.

Kate the Waif: 3tries to make the correct vote and all in all 4 posts with no content. Looks like a lurkywolf who tries to up his postcount to avoid closer inspection to me.

[Muriel The Slow]

I would like to point out that Doctor Saul has been really quiet since the first day. That does put some weight on the theory that someone presented, that he forgave me so easily because he wanted the fight to end so he wouldn't be highlighted, and the following switch back to voting me after the smoke had cleared. He's been flying under the radar ever since.

[Kate The Waif]

Kate the Waif: 3tries to make the correct vote and all in all 4 posts with no content. Looks like a lurkywolf who tries to up his postcount to avoid closer inspection to me.

Seriously? Have you even looked at my posts? First, that would be a very stupid way to bump my post count becuase of the attention that any mistake draws, even one as stupid as that. I' been posting reasoned and backed up arguments, and if my level if contribution is considered lurking, then honestly, I think that something is very wrong here.

You are looking very scummy to me with all this mudslinging and reaching for argument, Edith, though not yet enough for me to vote for you over Muriel.

[The Narrator]

*Doctor Saul in brackets because Fat Rose can't find that vote but it was in the official tally

That looks like a mistake from Doctor Saul's messed up vote for "Sister Anne" earlier, that should be removed.

[Doctor Saul]

To all villagers whoever you might be: Don't make cases without checking the facts. When you make a case against someone, give us the reasons behind your claims. When you vote, give us the reasons behind your vote. There has just been so much of this fuckery going on that it can't be just the wolves doing it. If you are a villager doing it, please stop, it makes it harder to catch the wolves.

This is funny coming from you. Of course, I made a stupid mistake today already, trying to push a dead person to post more...

I do not know why The Narrator has me down as voting for Sister Mary, because I never did. I haven't voted for anybody since making that stupid mistake where I voted for Simple Anne. I know Bert thought it was funny, I just wish I could say I did it on purpose as a joke. It was pure And I was embarrassed for making such a stupid mistake after; sorry that this made me not want to contribute.

Bert, I was happier when I thought you and Will were masons, or neighborized or something along those lines. But instead you seem to be saying you are some kind of passive seer? I have a hard time believing that. Well, I suppose Will could have an ability where can confirm he is a villager to any person at night - that would be a little better.

I do not like Kate the Waif's reversal onto Muriel at the beginning of the day. If anything I think people should have been going the opposite direction at the start of the day. Now, Agnes voting for Muriel just now makes sense because Muriel loves to dig her own whole and then call people stupid when they accuse her. Instead Kate jumped on Muriel from the start of the day and stayed on her all day despite the activity that has gone on. It seems the opposite of what someone following the situation would react to.

x-post with Will. Oh, that explains things. Also with the Narrator. Well, mistake found I guess.

[Sir Percival]

i have knightly duties i must attend to and will not be around for lynch. please lynch muriel, she is a toxic influence on town and any good points made by her are drowned in hypocrisy and misrepresentation of the posts of others.

[Fat Rose]

Seriously? Have you even looked at my posts? First, that would be a very stupid way to bump my post count becuase of the attention that any mistake draws, even one as stupid as that. I' been posting reasoned and backed up arguments, and if my level if contribution is considered lurking, then honestly, I think that something is very wrong here.

You are looking very scummy to me with all this mudslinging and reaching for argument, Edith, though not yet enough for me to vote for you over Muriel.

Um, Kate you have 11 posts.

1. Telling us you have a surname
2. Responding to a joke
3. Vote for Jon, because he is "furthering the name-finding nonsense"; kinda clearance of Percival because he is to antagonistic
4. Coming in after the lynch and blaming everyone for "the late run on Friar Andrew"
5. Telling us that you have no time and leaving the post half-finished because you had to go
6. Expanding on last post and your suspicions of Muriel
7. Explaining that you were first angry but now not so much about the duel.
8. Voting
9. Reply to someone who accused you of first deciding to lynch Muriel and then searching for reasons by stating

I mean, even from the beginning she was promoting a patently false assumption regarding last names.

10. Vote
11. Being annoyed at Edith, quoted above

And that's it. Stating boldly "and if my level if contribution is considered lurking, then honestly, I think that something is very wrong here" seems kinda odd with that 'amount' of content.

[Muriel The Slow]

And that's it. Stating boldly "and if my level if contribution is considered lurking, then honestly, I think that something is very wrong here" seems kinda odd with that 'amount' of content.

Maybe she's busy in the wolf thread and forgot that she hasn't really posted much here despite being heavily involved in the game. That would be a hilarious slip

i have knightly duties i must attend to and will not be around for lynch. please lynch muriel, she is a toxic influence on town and any good points made by her are drowned in hypocrisy and misrepresentation of the posts of others.

May I remind you that the aim of the game is to lynch wolves.

[Half-Nose Harry]

On phone through deadline so nothing too fancy. Kate spending one of her very few posts to say how having very few posts isn't lurking is ridiculous.

[Kate The Waif]

What more do you want from me? I work 10.5 hour days with no computer access (i wasnt expecting this when i signed ip, if that matters). I'm on my cell at lunch right now. I think that Muriel is very scummy, I'm not 100% sure what is going on elsewhere. I already posted my opinion on the Scarelt John and LE situation: I'm not a huge fan of LE's play overall, but her duel is not as bad a decision as I thought at first and I think strongly that she is a villager. I am less sure about SJ, so I vote for him to die in the duel.