Posts: 76
Threads: 0
Joined: Jul 2013
And I agree, if Sister Mary isn't showing up tomorrow as well she get modkilled anyhow, if not I know that I will be voting for her if she can't provide reasons for her absence and for the points I made earlier.
Kate the Waif
I made the rundown on her posts earlier and I'm not convinced by what I found, especially coupled with the angry comment about how her level of contribution can be considered lurker.
Posts: 76
Threads: 0
Joined: Jul 2013
(July 24th, 2013, 13:27)Fat Rose Wrote: Unofficial Tally
Sister Mary (5) - Know-Nothing Jon, Muriel the Slow, Half-Nose Harry, Bert the Bard, Young Will
Muriel the Slow (5) - Sir Percival, Rob the Filch, Short Richard, Kate the Waif, Agnes the Orphan
Kate the Waif (4) - Widow Edith, Doctor Saul, Lady Elizabeth, Fat Rose
Not voting: Scarlet John, Sister Mary
--------
Scarlet John (8) - Bert the Bard, Fat Rose, Know-Nothing Jon, Muriel the Slow, Half-Nose Harry, Young Will, Kate the Waif, Lady Elizabeth
Lady Elizabeth (6) - Scarlet John, Widow Edith, Doctor Saul, Agnes the Orphan, Short Richard, Sir Percival
Not voting: Sister Mary, Rob the Filch
Posts: 23
Threads: 0
Joined: Jul 2013
Might as well vote.
Muriel because her attacks on me are bad, her attacks on other players day 1 were bad, and her "look how townish I am for saying we shouldn't argue about meta" routine was bad.
At least fatty explained her case that she thinks I was faking the quit even if it's rubbish. Hint: I don't know why he would have done this as town, therefore he's scum is sub-newbie level reasoning. You have to have a case why someone would have done something as scum. If I was scum I could easily have cleared suspicion on myself by just posting more than the lurkers. Don't have a motive to draw attention to myself by faking a quit.
Posts: 75
Threads: 0
Joined: Jul 2013
I would rather lynch Mary today and have more info for tomorrow's lynch. If Mary flips scum we won't have to lynch Muriel. We gave lurkers a pass on day one, that's enough. Also I don't like the idea of doing a half-guessing lynch today, flip two villagers, and then having to spend day three lynching Mary because she shows up with a vote and a weak post.
Posts: 23
Threads: 0
Joined: Jul 2013
How would Mary flipping scum clear Muriel exactly?
Posts: 76
Threads: 0
Joined: Jul 2013
(July 24th, 2013, 13:42)Scarlet John Wrote: Might as well vote.
Muriel because her attacks on me are bad, her attacks on other players day 1 were bad, and her "look how townish I am for saying we shouldn't argue about meta" routine was bad.
At least fatty explained her case that she thinks I was faking the quit even if it's rubbish. Hint: I don't know why he would have done this as town, therefore he's scum is sub-newbie level reasoning. You have to have a case why someone would have done something as scum. If I was scum I could easily have cleared suspicion on myself by just posting more than the lurkers. Don't have a motive to draw attention to myself by faking a quit.
I disagree (and I take the fatty as insult, tyvm). Apart from that you put words in my mouth that I never said, I also think it is untrue that one needs a case why someone would do something as scum. I don't have the same information scum has, so as a fact I CAN'T always explain why scum does what they do. But I can act and vote to lynch someone if the way he acts is scummy for me. For example if he states he has no time but still shows thorough knowledge of the thread, therefore actually did invest the time into it. Exactly that time that he claimed he did not have. That's why I voted for you.
Also posting more than the lurkers isn't as easy for scum as you make it out to be either, we had enough scum that failed doing exactly that and delivered themselves because they posted. So there is a perfectly valid reason to try and stay down, especially if it buys you time till endgame. Because at that point if we don't have reads on everyone, chances are very high we will lose.
Posts: 76
Threads: 0
Joined: Jul 2013
(July 24th, 2013, 13:45)Bert The Bard Wrote: I would rather lynch Mary today and have more info for tomorrow's lynch. If Mary flips scum we won't have to lynch Muriel. We gave lurkers a pass on day one, that's enough. Also I don't like the idea of doing a half-guessing lynch today, flip two villagers, and then having to spend day three lynching Mary because she shows up with a vote and a weak post.
Fair enough. And as I still am pretty certain that Muriel is village, I would have switched anyway (yes, I am that certain on her). Therefore
Sister Mary
Posts: 76
Threads: 0
Joined: Jul 2013
Unofficial Tally
Sister Mary (6) - Know-Nothing Jon, Muriel the Slow, Half-Nose Harry, Bert the Bard, Young Will, Fat Rose
Muriel the Slow (6) - Sir Percival, Rob the Filch, Short Richard, Kate the Waif, Agnes the Orphan, Scarlet John
Kate the Waif (3) - Widow Edith, Doctor Saul, Lady Elizabeth
Not voting: Sister Mary
--------
Scarlet John (8) - Bert the Bard, Fat Rose, Know-Nothing Jon, Muriel the Slow, Half-Nose Harry, Young Will, Kate the Waif, Lady Elizabeth
Lady Elizabeth (6) - Scarlet John, Widow Edith, Doctor Saul, Agnes the Orphan, Short Richard, Sir Percival
Not voting: Sister Mary, Rob the Filch
Posts: 119
Threads: 0
Joined: Jul 2013
(July 24th, 2013, 13:45)Bert The Bard Wrote: I would rather lynch Mary today and have more info for tomorrow's lynch. If Mary flips scum we won't have to lynch Muriel. We gave lurkers a pass on day one, that's enough. Also I don't like the idea of doing a half-guessing lynch today, flip two villagers, and then having to spend day three lynching Mary because she shows up with a vote and a weak post.
I have the same question as john. Why would scum mary heavily hint that Muriel is town?
Posts: 23
Threads: 0
Joined: Jul 2013
I only actually read from page 30 on and checked in here twice a day. By the normal standards of these games, that's way below the level of contribution expected.. Wouldn't even have done that if people hadn't made me feel bad about quitting.
|
