WW 45: Lurkey Lurking

[Dp101]

My play this game was terrible and I feel terrible, I was not lying when I said that I felt completely disconnected to the flow of the game. I just could not fake reads, or make reads, or do anything of worth, or post. I feel so bad for my scumbuddy, and I do not deserve to win this game.

Don't feel too bad, you got Jabbz killed in a horrible way. That's better than average for first-time scum.

Not first time, I survived to the end and won in WW43, my first game. My game has just taken a complete nosedive recently.

[Dp101]

Oh also, predictions on the last scum?

[MJW (ya that one)]

Oh also, predictions on the last scum?

Anyone who's not Rowain because he seems really angry for the town sucking (Jabbz) which would not make sense if he were wolf and his silly accidental meta-clear post against GM Q.

Haven't been reading the thread but I pretty sure that it isn't Adrein because he mentioned two other players defending you. I don't think you would feel too bad for scumbuddie if he mercilessly attacked you. He obviously isn't referring to himself.

So that leaves Gazglum and Psillycyber. If I were playing in this situation they would both be same. I would just want to lynch both of them. If I had to guess now I would pick Psillycyber for crashing and burning in the post-count and being a bit too nice (especially considering what Rowain did).

[MJW (ya that one)]

As it is we have 2 shots to find 1 scum.
from my PoV I have to decide if a) scum Adrien tried to bus DP real hard on D1 because he saw DP as walking dead already. and b) did scum Adrien put himself up on D2 with the idea with Lewwyn vs Rowain I can risk it and later use it as proof for my innocence.
But I must I find this rather unlikely compared to the chances of glum & Psilly being the missing scum. So with Adrien rather town it is either Gazglum or Psilly in which case I vote one of them tomorrow and if he turns out town then the other on D5.

This is what I just said.

[MJW (ya that one)]

I just remembered I was Q died in that good example game...

Anyway Psilly just broke the 'no voting at night rule' flagrantly. He doesn't seem the type of person to do that so I'd guess he just didn't read Q's post which is quite wolfish because villagers tend to care what Mr. GM says...so my odds on the last wolf:

Psilly=60%
Gazglum=30%
Adrien=9%
Rowain=1%

If I were playing I would vote Gaz this day because Psilly would be a total doormat on the final day.

[MJW (ya that one)]

Oh, so the wolf has to choose who's not on the chopping block. If he's smart he would pick Rowain for this because he's unlynchable and my plans would be the same.

People get meta-cleared, legit-cleared and become obvTown all the time. The real issue is the wolfs cannot just NK such players.

I like your new title dp.

Fake Edit: not worth own post but I'll sum why I don't like Psilly from least to most.
--Probably not reading Q's post.
--Crashing and burning in post count.
--Being 'too nice', usually I wouldn't put so much weight on it but Rowain's actions make it obvious that Psilly isn't in the villager bubble.

[Qgqqqqq]

Uhh, not voting at night isn't a rule. That was me phoneposting trying to get them to not post between EoD and the flip.

As scum, where do you nominate yourself? I think you leave off the list, as town will wifom wisdom that into too obvious.

[MJW (ya that one)]

Uhh, not voting at night isn't a rule. That was me phoneposting trying to get them to not post between EoD and the flip.

As scum, where do you nominate yourself? I think you leave off the list, as town will wifom wisdom that into too obvious.

Oh. I'd guess I would delete that then. Sorry for misunderstanding your phone talk.

Not nominating someone who wouldn't be lynched to give the town no information and reverse psychology are both legit strats. I just think if I'm right about psilly his position is so weak that he has to go for broke and earn as many town points as possible. Being on the chomping block would actually help with that.

If it's actually gaz I know I would be able to kill psilly on last day. Because you still only need only one wrong-headed villager on the second to last day (due to tie-breaks) it would be best for him not to die on the second to last day. So I would leave psilly off the chomping block and push like crazy to mislynch Adrien 'cause "I know I'm innocent".

If it's Rowain or Adrien I wouldn't rock the boat and pick Rowain and hope to just cruise through.

[MJW (ya that one)]

Reverse psychology.  Doing what scum wouldn't do.  You've been doing that all game, and you are about to do some more of it here on Day 4 with the nominations.

Psilly, you admit that I have been 'doing what scum wouldn't do'. This is only a scum-ploy if you predecide I am already scum. Otherwise, not playing like scum is in fact, not a scum tell.
Meanwhile Rowain also stayed off DP Day 1, and flirted with swinging off him again Day 3.
Apart from his magical tone, can you explain again why I am 100% scum and Rowain is 100% town?

Not really.  I can't really follow this game anymore.  It's too confusing.  Maybe Rowain is scum after all.  You make some good points there.

I'm now 70% sure, let's look at this empty post:
1. Not answering questions due to "confusing". This is even lamer than "lack of time".
2. Trying to artificially increase the suspects. This is what made me not like zak in my final ww game here.
3. Being nice while being on chomping block and after Rowain drama. "good points"
If Rowain is scum then he's my new god now.

[RifleAvenger]

RifleAvenger, you interested in playing the next one?

At some point I should give it a try, but at the moment I'm juggling quite a bit.  I'll need a pretty calm period, since my skill at werewolf is rather poor, and even more so in a longer timeframe, no body language environment (most of my experience is actually face to face games).

I'm happy enough just following along for now.

Also, if Psi is scum, then the scum team seems like it burned out, day 1 craziness with Jabbz aside.