WW16: The Outlaws and The Olives

[Catwalk]

Bigger, looks like I remember wrong. I could have sworn there was a game where the town cruised to victory, but I'm not seeing it.

Lewwyn, I was being pressured to put something up right now and I really didn't have much to offer. I decided on an approach that made some sense to myself and started on it. Rowain wanted me to post right now before conferring with "wolf buddies", so I posted the list and said what I wanted to do. I then get jumped on for not having much to show, and I decided on the "screw it" approach instead.

I agree novice is not 100% villager and should undergo more investigation later. I do think it's pointless discussing him now.

[pindicator]

Won't be around much today folks. I just got asked out for coffee. Lunch with my parents. Dinner and drinks later tonight. It's my birthday!

I'll try to read & post when I can but no promises

[Tasunke]

Catwalk, I think you were talking about Lewwyn's "There will be blood" game, in which MNG died quickly not due to a large and inexperienced wolf pack, but due to several infighting wolfpacks.

[Meiz]

I agree novice is not 100% villager and should undergo more investigation later. I do think it's pointless discussing him now.

This. Yes, bussing wolf on day 1 could be a valid strategy, but later needs explaining why wolves don't night kill him.

[Catwalk]

One thing about novice faking a posting restriction: He would have needed to be certain that Mattimeo didn't target him. If Mattimeo did target him, he would have had a very hard time explaining the posting restriction. So either they're both wolves or novice is innocent. Or he decided to roll the dice and assume he didn't get cloaked. Again, I don't think discussing novice now serves much purpose.

[Mattimeo]

moving catwalk down a notch every time he posts.

I'm actually getting more of an impression of a villager going digging every time he posts. Can't help but think a wolf would have either stopped by now, or at least been fed some better points...

[waterbat]

Could you link me to when Meiz backs up Novice's assertion?

He insisted that i was following zak and novice during that 5-hour gap that you pointed out (even though novice hadn't voted yet). In effect - he's elevating novice's clearance level. I was wondering if you found it suspicious. here is the post:

in the quoted segment, but here is a snippet

novice made similar accusation against thestick, did not vote yet. Waterbat follows with a vote, http://realmsbeyond.net/forums/showp...7&postcount=80
So basically making the third vote

@Rowain:

Either you want my dump or you don't. I'm not intentionally trying to clutter though - you'd know it if I was.

I must check out now for a good bit. Tomorrow, due to the 2100 deadline, won't be on at deadline or a few hours prior.

[waterbat]

I'm actually getting more of an impression of a villager going digging every time he posts. Can't help but think a wolf would have either stopped by now, or at least been fed some better points...

I did like the last one!

Very good point catwalk on novice faking his post restriction in light of the possibility mattimeo would protect him.

I guess we can conclude matt and nov are both wolves then (totally joking)

[Catwalk]

Catwalk, I think you were talking about Lewwyn's "There will be blood" game, in which MNG died quickly not due to a large and inexperienced wolf pack, but due to several infighting wolfpacks.

That sounds right, although MNG wasn't scum in that one.

Rowain, you're being pretty pushy. If you're just curious and trying to encourage us to contribute that's fine, but it read more like a threat to me. I don't like posting suspicions and arguments if I have little to go on. Either I will be accused of bandwagoning (if I stress that I'm following someone else's lead) or of making up accusations (if the suspicion is vague). Both me and Waterbat tried to comply and got crap for it, that's not helpful.

[Meiz]

@waterbat

I meant that you could expect novice following with a vote.

Still, it's odd how you keep bringing it up. I didn't accuse you of following zak and novice. Why would I?