WW8: Madness in Outer Space (game thread - players only)

[novice]

You are quite right. Usually novice doesn't care who gets lynched on day1 as long as its not him.

Actually I'd say I have a history of defending people I read as innocent. It's the next best thing IMO, if you don't have any wolf hunches. That said, I don't read Catwalk as innocent as such. It's just that...

Why then the vote for Lewwyn instead for Catwalk?

Hm crosspost so again:
Why don't you want to pressure Catwalk?

...he already has 4 votes on him and I find him awfully mislynchable.

[Rowain]

...he already has 4 votes on him and I find him awfully mislynchable.

Hm. And you think Lewwyn is better?

[novice]

Hm. And you think Lewwyn is better?

Maybe. I think Lewwyn has proved to be a strong player, and I think pressuring the strong players early makes more sense. (No offense Catwalk, you just have a shorter resumé.)

This sounds like a typical Catwalk plot - hare-brained but sincere. It's a pity he's joking.

Trying to buddy up already?

Not rhetorical - is it odd that Catwalk read my post as buddying up?

[zakalwe]

Official Tally - Day 1 - 11 alive - 6 to lynch

4: Lewwyn (Injera, Winston Hughes, Novice, Rowain)
3: Catwalk (Uberfish, Serdoa, Lewwyn)
1: Novice (Catwalk)
1: Erebus (Sareln)
1: Rowain (Bobchillingworth)

Not voting (1): Erebus

[Rowain]

Not rhetorical - is it odd that Catwalk read my post as buddying up?

It is odd in conjunction of:

My first game I was accused of my first posts being non-joking, now I'm being accused of my first posts being joking

First he thinks your defending him as budding up and then he claims he gets accused for joking posts when in real he gor defended.

[Lewwyn]

Winston, Winston, Winston, you've got a long way to go. Or at least to the end of this day.

Pretty sure that sticking to anyone way of voting is a bad idea. Just because I suspect people for their one vote away from the group, like your initial vote, like Rowain said, it doesn't work if you suspect everyone who votes for a single person. Thus you don't vote that way, right away. You wait and see what simmers. See what scummy vegetables pop to the surface.

[Lewwyn]

Oh and Catwalk is innocent because Novice defended him, and Novice is SCUM with Winston.

[novice]

Why is Winston SCUM, Lewwyn?

[Rowain]

@Lewwyn
Why did you not vote for novice who had already a vote if you think him SCUM?

[Lewwyn]

Why is Winston SCUM, Lewwyn?

Vibes, Yo.