WW27 Game Thread: Once there were 12

[Qgqqqqq]

I did not think it would be good play to target the people who just lynched a scum. Would you not agree? If right after MJW got lynched, I would tell you that it had to all be a scum sacrifice for sure and we should let the non-MJW voters off the hook, you would have called me a crazy man. I do agree that it makes me scummy that I would immediately go after the ones who didn't vote MJW, in hindsight now that we know they were all villagers, but it is the natural line of thought. And I do not think it makes me scummier than Zak and Novice, because both of them actually agreed with me about my thoughts on that day and echoed my sentiments.

While I don't think it would be good play to lynch people based off that, I didn't think it cleared them either - my instinctive reaction was that there was one scum on there. However what I find scummy is nit just that you did this, but how quick you were to do so, in a manner that seems a lot like trying to gain credit for it- or at least make sure your part wasn't forgotten, and that you were focussing on Azarius/Gazglum/Azza feels like a way of setting up the future ones rather then looking at who you actually suspected.

[novice]

Zak, Q, currently we win (or don't lose today) with the Jays as scum and with Zak/Jowy as scum. Q, do you think Zak is scum with Jowy? Otherwise, should we all move our votes to JKaen as insurance against Zak/Jkaen as scum?

[Jowy]

I did not think it would be good play to target the people who just lynched a scum. Would you not agree? If right after MJW got lynched, I would tell you that it had to all be a scum sacrifice for sure and we should let the non-MJW voters off the hook, you would have called me a crazy man. I do agree that it makes me scummy that I would immediately go after the ones who didn't vote MJW, in hindsight now that we know they were all villagers, but it is the natural line of thought. And I do not think it makes me scummier than Zak and Novice, because both of them actually agreed with me about my thoughts on that day and echoed my sentiments.

While I don't think it would be good play to lynch people based off that, I didn't think it cleared them either - my instinctive reaction was that there was one scum on there. However what I find scummy is nit just that you did this, but how quick you were to do so, in a manner that seems a lot like trying to gain credit for it- or at least make sure your part wasn't forgotten, and that you were focussing on Azarius/Gazglum/Azza feels like a way of setting up the future ones rather then looking at who you actually suspected.

We had the same reaction, then. It was actually me who first, in my first post after the MJW lynch, mentioned the possibility of a MJW sacrifice. And like I said, even though I looked closely at the people who didn't vote MJW, and ignored the rest for a day, I did not set up lynches or simply follow a formula to lynch all those villagers. I voted for Gaz. I said I didn't feel strongly about Azza, I would not have auto-lynched him next. I went for novice instead of Matt or Azarius. But I will admit that I wanted credit for the MJW lynch. I had to choose between two who I had villager leans on. I feared both options are wrong, and I would be lynched next for it. I picked the right one, but people were discrediting my vote, saying that it didn't matter, even though it was the deciding vote. I was annoyed. But I do not get the scum tell on me from all that jazz, because we know it was a clear sacrifice by the scum. If I was a scum setting up my scum buddy for villager credit, I would have played the whole situation entirely different, the fallout as well.

[zakalwe]

Zak, Q, currently we win (or don't lose today) with the Jays as scum and with Zak/Jowy as scum. Q, do you think Zak is scum with Jowy? Otherwise, should we all move our votes to JKaen as insurance against Zak/Jkaen as scum?

Ideally I would lynch Jowy first, since I haven't entirely dismissed Jowy/Q. But I guess I'm willing to go with Jkaen, too. Not that I really have a choice, if you and Q switch.

[Jowy]

Q, will you vote with us?

[Qgqqqqq]

I don't think zak/jkaen is likely because of how aggressively Jkaen pushed zak. I think JJ is significantly more likely then JoZ, and that JoZ is more likely then JkZ . I also might not be online to switch, depending on when you do it.
And independently I find Jowy more scummy anyway, so I'd rather not.

[Jowy]

So you are not going to vote with us?

[Jkaen]

ok, I think I have done all I can to state how scummy Novice is, if you are not even slightly convinced at this point Q I give up, well played scum

[Jkaen]

Q, if you are not scum or possessed, I hope you feel suitable shame for carrying both yesterdays and todays lynch in favour of the scum

[Jowy]

Yup it seems this is the end.

However, I'm still going to take a low chance of win rather than a no chance of win. So, I'm going to vote with Zak/Novice. Or whoever the fuck ends up being the majority.