[Lurkers]WW 38: Judging a Player by his Cover

[novice]

I would expect all incoming actions to fail with no result.

[Qgqqqqq]

Now I'm not sure he should have responded since he's basically confirming I was jailed. How does that usually work with X-off abilities and jailing? Are they usually considered used up even if the person using them is jailed / role blocked?

An interesting quandry, which I've faced in the past. I chose to tell them, because even though it gave confirmation of misuse it's better than cheating them out of. It could be complicated by having shot-boosters around, though.

[zakalwe]

I'd say the ability should be spent if you attempted to use it. It's a "shot" as in an "attempt".

[Lewwyn]

No lynch... This is terrible. Has anyone considered Rowain could be SK and his ability might be bullshit so he's just going to confirm whatever someone else says? I don't thikk he's SK, but that same logic could be applied to any of the people claiming to have roles confirming other people... Lynch people you guys!

No wonder I got killed.

[Lewwyn]

Honestly, I don't even think there's an SK. There's just a fourth schemer.

[zakalwe]

Sounds plausible to me, too. We're a little spoiled by Jowy's posts in here, though.

If we're just looking for a fourth schemer, then it's probably not Bob due to Molach's killblock on N2. So maybe Pindicator or Meiz, then. Meiz gets some town points for day 1, and for strongly defending me when I was one of the few possible mislynches. Could be Shadeun or Krill too, I guess. Just feels too obvious.

Still think the most straightforward theory is that something interfered my N1 watch on Pindicator. Jowy was mafia roleblocker who claimed to have blocked Zakalwe. If they woudl have blocked me instead, there's no reason not to claim that.

... other than making sure I hang before Novice?

Prior to Jowy's claim, I doubt the schemers were confident that I would hang before Novice, with both of us on the block. And they couldn't know about Mattimeo's intentions.

Pindicator for being jailed on the night of the missing kill.

[Lewwyn]

I could get behind a pindicator lynch for sure.

[BRickAstley]

Between people posting in thread, telling me in PMs, and on QT, consensus seems that people playing aren't really having fun anymore. That combined with some technical/resolution mistakes on my part makes me want to just cal the game here before people have to drudge longer through a game that they aren't enjoying.

[Jowy]

Cmon townies, winning is supposed to be fun
Was the resolution mistake just the jailkeeper thing? That can go either way depending on the mod.

[zakalwe]

That's odd. I don't understand what killed the momentum here. Possibly because I'm not spoiled enough?

Your call, but I wouldn't end the game unless I was confident that everybody is OK with it.