WW8: Madness in Outer Space (game thread - players only)

[zakalwe]

Official Tally - Day 3 - 7 alive - 4 to lynch

1: Rowain (Novice)
1: Sareln (Lewwyn)

Ineligible: Erebus

Not voting: Rowain, Catwalk, Uberfish, Sareln, [strike]Erebus[/strike]

[Catwalk]

I'm uncertain about Erebus, he's back in grey camp for me. We have no idea what kind of powers the scum have. His power is very similar to those of both Injera (reveal himself as innocent to a single player) and Bob (can't vote or post, can be lynched, revealed as innocent the next day). Could be that zakalwe has created another trio of abilities, or could be that he's blending scum abilities with those of villagers. All speculation, we need to see a scum to get a better idea.

Rowain is very possibly guilty, but I still don't see him as a good target. I would like Lewwyn to reveal his role if it helps shed light on our predicament, he's my prime target at this time.

[novice]

Zak, we still need 4 votes to lynch someone, right?

[Rowain]

I thought a bit more about it. Perhaps it is worth it:

So start: look what abbilities have been claimed till now:

A) novice can hide hurts himself

B) catwalk can protect hurts protected

C) Serdoa can guard hurts himself

That are already 3 different ways to hurt a villager. Do you really believe that the healing ability is given to SCUM who know exactly that it isn't one of their own getting wounded?

[zakalwe]

Zak, we still need 4 votes to lynch someone, right?

Correct.

[Catwalk]

Are you sure I should?
It might give those that have not claimed a power a hint what they can say.

Rowain, I don't think it proves you innocent. Nor do I think it makes you likely to be guilty, so I still won't be voting for you today. Depending on what powers the scum and the remaining villagers have, you might very well be guilty based on your power. At least, I don't see it as impossible.

[novice]

I thought a bit more about it. Perhaps it is worth it:

So start: look what abbilities have been claimed till now:

A) novice can hide hurts himself

B) catwalk can protect hurts protected

C) Serdoa can guard hurts himself

That are already 3 different ways to hurt a villager. Do you really believe that the healing ability is given to SCUM who know exactly that it isn't one of their own getting wounded?

Winston could hurt scum.

But yeah, I think I'd like to hear everyone roleclaim, actually.

[novice]

no vote.

[Rowain]

Winston could hurt scum.

Yes he could hurt SCUM if he finds one. Butas far as we know. This wound would mean nothing for them because no other way of hurting SCUM has been told till now. So why should SCUM have healing again?

[Catwalk]

It doesn't make sense to have a punch ability if there's no other way to hurt scum. It logically follows that there has to be another way to hurt scum hidden among the unrevealed abilities. I don't think zakalwe would leave a logical gap like that. Given that scum can be vig killed (per the above assumption), it's possible that you're a scum who can heal scum AND use your power to establish innocence. I still don't think it's likely at all (and I don't see where novice is coming from on this), but it's certainly possible zakalwe threw us a curveball this way.

My suspicion list, subject to change:
Catwalk (my PM revealed no mention of me being scum, so I think I'm safe)
novice (pretty much can't be scum, sucks that he'll likely die tomorrow)
Rowain (unlikely to be scum based on ability)
uberfish (very pro-town, but could be a cunning wolf)
Lewwyn (very anti-town, could just be crazy)
Sareln (low activity)
Erebus (ninja ability, sounds like scum to me)

As mentioned earlier, I suggest that Lewwyn and Sareln reveal their powers. uberfish should probably wait, unless his power adds a missing piece to the puzzle.