WW15 - Chiron is a harsh mistress

[Meiz]

Well I wished you would have waited about 5 more hours to see who all would switch because I was planning on voting for novice today without that reveal. I'm certain you could have lynched him without that reveal. I'm also sad that we don't get to see true machinations for the rest of the day.

Seconded, and novice

[BRickAstley]

Now, looking at that vote count, there is practically everything open still. But the runners up are

zakalwe
Molach
Selrahc
Pindicator
novice
BrickAstley

I am certain there are wolves in that pack, the question is who. Clearly I put my money on novice. I laid out how I feel about all of them, but please villagers, make up your mind. We need to get some consensus otherwise the wolves will pull the vote in their favor. It is too easy to influence it right now.

I appear confident because I am. And I believe my points against novice are at least more valid than those against BrickAstley, aren't they?

I also find your statements a bit odd Serdoa, because the sort of zeal with which you're absolutely sure novice is a wolf TM is quite sure for a game like this where we all are really grasping for straws.

So my thoughts on who you mentioned.

• zakalwe- most of the claims against him seem to have the basis of "his playing style is different than last game and therefore we's a wolf." I don't know since I haven't played in previous games, but I would personally think that just because someone played one way last game doesn't mean that if they differ at all the next game they're obviously the other side, when there could be all sorts of other reasons why, in game or out of game. Verdict: If he really is that different then yeah be suspicious and make him respond to his accusations, but I don't think he has enough damning evidence at this point.
  
  
• Molach- The center of a LOT of discussion both days so far. It is worth noting that this is who Catwalk DID have a vendetta against, so maybe that's a good reason to suspect him since Catwalk is suddenly not with us anymore? Also he's really concerned about the possibility of a third party and trying to shift attention that way. Verdict: I don't like the feel of pretty much anything he posts. I suspect him highly.
  
  
• Selrahc- Has been focusing on the Lewwyn Alien Crusade for the most part. Not a whole lot of other commentary on everything else that's been happening. Verdict: Unsure until further conversation.
  
  
• Pindicator- Relatively inactive, but the whole different acting in different games again isn't a huge stumbling block for me. Otherwise I don't feel very comfortable with his posting style just considering this game. Verdict: doesn't seem dangerous but on the watch list.
  
  
  
• novice- just saw Serdoa's claim. Verdict: Well at this point he's probably going to be lynched, which isn't bad, cause either he's a wolf or we know that Serdoa is lying, and that's a 50/50 trade which is not bad since there are more villagers than wolves.
  
  
• BRickAstley- Has been absent from posting a lot due to fear over misspeaking more and life business. Verdict: He's starting to post more now so he's fine.
  

[BRickAstley]

Well now I understand why you were so sure about novice so I retract my comment at you Serdoa. I suppose in these games it's common to just go with what the seer claims? Since everyone is suddenly voting for novice I suppose it's not suspicious that a large amount of votes are being changed but as long as Serdoa's right then it's not a problem.

[novice]

Serdoa, clearly you were redirected, or an evil spirit - ah screw it.

Bigger

[BRickAstley]

novice (7): Serdoa, Qgqqqqq, slowcheetah, Lewwyn, Selrahc, Meiz, BRickAstley
Molach (3): Jkaen, bobchillingsworth, Sareln
zakalwe (3): waterbat, novice. mattimeo
Selrahc (2): Pindicator, Maniac,
pindicator (2): molach, zakalwe
BrickAstley (1) - Injera

Not voting: thestick

That jumped up fast.

[pindicator]

Dang novice, you just can't catch a village roll can you?

[Lewwyn]

Dang novice, you just can't catch a village roll can you?

He's a thief...

[Injera]

Morning folks, I'm not caught up but I read back to the claim.

Novice

[waterbat]

I was hoping to glean some wolf-hunting skills from watching Serdoa's work play out (or not play out). it's no fun if you already know, Serdoa!

Novice

[Molach]

novice

Brick, I am not concerned with finding 3rd faction. I know Pindicator said so but read MY posts instead. I talk about them as a vague possibility but conclude otherwise. Selrahc is the Xenophobe.

Feel free to disagree with anything I say, but also think about whether that makes me misguided villager or NAP. Difference there. I see some stupid posting but some of that makes me think villager.

So you should give more explucit reasons.

And thank you Serdoa for the undisturbed night drinking