Posts: 1,650
Threads: 2
Joined: Jul 2011
Also, just in case you do make the mistake of lynching me, putting it out there that the whole "repeat abilities are NAP mirrors" argument seems pretty bad. Both from a game construction sense - it's effectively the same as a mass claim of unique roles with wolf fake claims, which usually quickly resolves itself into a town win - and from the context of the role in question itself. Commuting is really not a typical wolf ability.
Posts: 3,251
Threads: 18
Joined: Nov 2010
Matt in the event you get lynched who are your biggest suspects next?
Apart from thestick, who are you wary of?
Posts: 5,294
Threads: 59
Joined: Dec 2004
... truth apparently is no help in Werewolf. I know this but it's still frustrating.
----
On Being Quiet and drawing Night-kills
Think about it from my perspective. I don't get night-killed anymore without a power role. So in order to draw the nightkill, I have to act like a power-role. Based on previous plays of power roles, that means I go more quiet than usual. Honestly I don't see what's so hard to grok about that. 
On Preferring Mattimeo over BRickAstley to hang
I expect Mattimeo to have another ability that he's not telling us about. He gets a name and I just get a specialist slot, so I doubt we're perfectly mirrored. I expect it to deal only with drones, given his annoyance at what he perceives as a negative incentive to announce if you're a drone. Whatever it is, I don't want my game to revolve about it, so all other things being equal, I'd choose Mattimeo over BRickAstley.
On the Role Itself
I don't think I'd ever give a wolf charged night-kill immune as a GM. I think the role itself implies town (disagreement w/ Molach), but with the duplicates complicating things, I think the possibility is wide open if it is one of several Mattimeo powers, or there are knock-on effects from rioting which we haven't been told about.
On overall Lynch Preferences
TheStick is pretty scummy with his attempting to get the "is it charged" / "what are the number of charges" answers out of Mattimeo, these aren't things a villager needs to know IMO. His neighbor thread does seem pretty village, but those questions are throwing red flags for me. Frankly though, I'm terrified of what Mattimeo's other abilities might be with regards to drones, so I'd rather lynch him first.
Blog | EitB | PF2 | PBEM 37 | PBEM 45G | RBDG1
Posts: 3,251
Threads: 18
Joined: Nov 2010
slowcheetah Wrote:Why do we have to narrow to two at this point, there is still several hours before the lynch?
Quote is from when Mattimeo had 3 votes, lewwyn made it 4 later.
It was mabye a bit early, but see what little has happened in 2.5 hours since.
It was not down to two really, there is the Sareln vs Mattimeo axis, and thestick as a contender for separate reasons. I think if either sareln or mattimeo is a NAP, the other will be pretty much cleared villager in my book afterwards. Thestick independent of that case. So while I'm preferring Sareln over Mattimeo atm, thestick could also be a correct choice. So please if someone could point out why his case was so obvious a day ago.
Quote:(Mattimeo)
the whole "repeat abilities are NAP mirrors" argument seems pretty bad"
Well, could be, in general, but if the drones are village, what does that make the dronebuster(BRickAstley)? Why claim his power like that if he were NAP, the talk was about atrocities, he could just have named the power and not told full effect.
Posts: 3,251
Threads: 18
Joined: Nov 2010
Crosspost with Sareln.
Okay that is room for thought right there, will consider.
What about yesterday? Did you read my defense against your vote day 2
Quote:He seems too certain, and a lot of his assumptions are implied rather than explicit. Are they buried because he isn't assuming, but rather knows, and so forgets to include them? That's my thought for now.
"for now". That vote was there right until novice got scanned. So how do you feel about this now? Admittedly seems several people are having problems following my trains of thought. I saw this as an easy vote to lay in place, it took me to "a fair number of votes" (4 I think) and was just left on with no more comment.
Posts: 12,335
Threads: 46
Joined: Jan 2011
Molach why did you change your name description to no name? Why was it necessary?
“The wind went mute and the trees in the forest stood still. It was time for the last tale.”
Posts: 3,251
Threads: 18
Joined: Nov 2010
I changed it day 2, around the time everyone's nameclaim was on the list. I was kind of hoping it would catch on because the writeups are given with game-name rather than forum names.
Just that.
Bigger has changed his to 'mind worm', but I'm not too concerned with that either.
Posts: 3,251
Threads: 18
Joined: Nov 2010
I did change it to 'rorschach' during that game too.
Posts: 821
Threads: 4
Joined: Aug 2011
Getting caught up.
Meiz Wrote:@Injera, in my PM from Bigger, I had info that I don't know Tasunke's alignment, but also that he is unsure of mine. I believed it to be an oversight from Bigger and a hint of Tasunke's innocence.
Yes, Bigger told me that thestick didn't know my alignment. I didn't really think anything of it at the time.
Posts: 3,045
Threads: 2
Joined: Aug 2006
Out of curiosity, from what name did you change away from? 
|
