WW16: The Outlaws and The Olives

[uberfish]

D2 wagon summary following pind's spreadsheet, hope this turns out readable

Sareln wagon #1: Injera Tas Mero Molach Serdoa Jkaen Matt (Bigger) Arromir

Uberfish wagon #1: TT Azza (Bigger) Waterbat

Apart from novice brief push against Qqqqqq no one else picks up more than 3 votes until after post 700. In retrospect, scum are probably hoping it turns into Sareln vs Uberfish vote off at this point.

in the background Ichabod, Catwalk, Selrahc are picking up suspicion, and Jkaen initiates a move away from sareln @ 771

Selrahc wagon: Novice Gaspar QQQ Jkaen
Pind wagon #1: Rowain (parked) + Sareln Novice Cat Water

at Sareln 5 / Pind 5 / Uberfish 0 I fire off a 1-liner at a bad TT post which triggers a flash wagon on me of

Uberfish wagon: TT Azza Serdoa Bigger Tas Water

My wagon stalls here with Sareln at 3, at this point people start to switch the momentum back towards sareln, meanwhile Ichabod has been gradually picking up votes all day

Sareln wagon #2: Matt Arro Mero (parked) + Tas Pind Ichabod TT

at this point I note a general feeling of dissatisfaction with a Sareln lynch, and this starts a move back to Pindicator leading up to the final VC

Sareln - 8 - Mattimeo, Arromir, tasunke, Merovech, Molach, Pindicator, Twinkletoes89, Serdoa
Pindicator - 7 - Rowain, Sareln, Ichabod, uberfish, novice, Meiz, Catwalk
Ichabod - 5 - Lewwyn, Injera, Gaspar, Qgqqqqq, Jkaen
uberfish - 3 - Azza, Bigger, Waterbat
Qgqqqqq - 1 - Selrahc

Phew. If anyone sees errors here please point them out

[Catwalk]

Nice vote analysis uberfish, and it's very readable. Are you going to do the same for D1? Cross referencing might give us something decent to go on. At first glance, there are enough suspicious voters on Sareln that I suspect either Ichabod or pindicator was being protected. I notice you've been cleared, could you go ahead and put me in cyan too?

Meiz, will the number system work?

[Meiz]

@Catwalk, Fork

[Catwalk]

Any other code you need us to cook up for you, or is that enough to go on?

[uberfish]

Unfortunately at this stage we don't yet know Pind's alignment which would clarify some things. but in general we have two groups here, the group that just wants to lynch Sareln/Uberfish/(Catwalk) and those more actively investigating other targets. I feel there's enough people in that first group that whichever scum are in there didn't necessarily need to initiate the moves towards Sareln or Myself at the end of day even if Pind was assumed to be scum. Currently I suspect the passive vote parkers a bit more (Mero, Arro, Azza). Simply because going "let's try to mislynch these villagers for saving thestick" is the path of least resistance for scum to take to salvage something out of Thestick getting lynched d1.

There might well be a scum with decent cover in the Novice/Gaspar/Injera/Lewwyn/Jkaen group that decided to mostly ignore the d1 voting controversy and push Selrahc for lurking and later Ichabod for being defensive. I'll worry about that later, as I interpret not being content to sit on Sareln or myself as overall being pro-town activity.

probably be able to extract more information from this if one of Pind/Ichabod flips scum.

[Meiz]

Ichabod

# !"=# @Meiz -> @thestick

&

# !"!¤

Ichabod =


Fork?

[novice]

day1: I did not piggyback novice because novice did not vote Bigger. And if you manage somehow to reaad the votes on day 1 you will see that I stayed on Bigger while novice voted and stayed on thestick. If that is piggybacking for you then I think everybody is piggybacking everryone here.

It's not piggybacking but that's hardly the point. I'm voting thestick and express suspicion on Bigger. You immediately seize the chance to vote Bigger. It could read like an attempt to move me off thestick.

[Lewwyn]

So we're 13 hours (I think) into Day 3 now. What's happening?

Vote Count:

(3) Rowain - Novice, Pindi, Gaspar
(3) Mero - Uberfish, catwalk, Waterbat
(3) Selrahc - Lewwyn, Jkaen, Rowain
(1.5) Ichabod - Mattimeo, Meiz?
(1) Catwalk - TT

I don't know what to make of Meiz's last post. Meiz are you saying Ichabod is good?

[Meiz]

@Lewwyn, Fork

[novice]

Ichabod

# !"=# @Meiz -> @thestick

&

# !"!¤

Ichabod =


Fork?

Translation:

Ichabod

#1203 @Meiz -> Thestick

and also

#1214

Makes Meiz think Ichabod is villager.

What happened in those posts is Ichabod first said that Meiz had voted Thestick, but then corrected himself in post 1214.