WW16: The Outlaws and The Olives

[novice]

Thanks for answering, Rowain. Even if you don't think you can convince me you should defend, so that others don't vote for you as well.

[waterbat]

Thanks for answering, Rowain. Even if you don't think you can convince me you should defend, so that others don't vote for you as well.

Agreed. I remember being one of those people in prior games.

Although, I seemed to get more voters when I defended that game. Deadline is in 30 hours, right? Less impact if I screw that up this game.

[novice]

And it's true that the order was
1. You suspected Bigger
2. I suspected Bigger
3. You voted Bigger.

So that's not so sinister. Village cred to Ichabod for pointing it out, too, unless you're both scum.

So Rowain, you don't suspect that Thestick was distancing from Waterbat?

[novice]

Deadline is in 6.5 hours.

[Lewwyn]

watchimg this girl mix at the bar. Thers like 9 people here and she s going full throttle. Prety fucking hot. Mix music. Not barrtend. Two turnables and a mirophone. (yes its alyric) good ctach yo.

[Ichabod]

Catwalk is playing a dangerous game. He is deliberate in his actions and much of it is planned. He's extremely self-conscious of how scummy his actions will make him look and so he's always defending his actions as he makes them. He's also always falling back on the "its my style" argument whenever the "a wolf wouldn't do that" argument fails.

Very good case, Lewwyn. The bolded part is what made the whole thing click in my mind. If I remember correctly previous games, Catwalk always played in an unorthodox way. This is normal and to be expected.

But in this game he's very defensive about it. In some stretches of the game he seemed to gain confidence, but most of the time he's very defensive. This seems off. I remember Catwalk getting annoyed and defending his point of view in previous games when someone didn't agree with his reasoning or called it a bad one. Now he seems more interested in defending himself, specifically to anything and anyone that points him as suspicious.

Since the Arromir vote isn't really going anywhere, I'll change my vote to Catwalk.

[Rowain]

So Rowain, you don't suspect that Thestick was distancing from Waterbat?

Maybe but for me I have put thestick-posts as useless distraction for hunting wolves.
BTW he mentioned 6 people in his first post - not only waterbat or me- the other 4: you, zak, Injera, Gaspar(quoted twice).

[BRickAstley]

Official lynch Vote Count

Catwalk - 6 - Azza, Lewwyn, Pindicator, Qgqqqqq, Twinkletoes89, Ichabod
Merovech - 4 - uberfish, Catwalk, Waterbat, Mattimeo
Rowain - 3 - Gaspar, novice, tasunke
Selrahc - 2 - Jkaen, Rowain
Twinkletoes89 - 1 - Merovech
Injera - 1 - Meiz

Players not voting: Arromir, Injera, Molach, Selrahc

[Lewwyn]

watchimg this girl mix at the bar. Thers like 9 people here and she s going full throttle. Prety fucking hot. Mix music. Not barrtend. Two turnables and a mirophone. (yes its alyric) good ctach yo.

[Selrahc]

Catwalk

The Catwalk.arguments make sense. To an extent anyway. It's easy to overstate Catwalks eccentricity levels in ast games. I think he has basically been around the same level.I do agree that he seems a bit uncharacteristically defensive. Remember that Catwalk considers active defence a villager action so he could well try to emphasize that kind of behaviour as scum to portray a village game.