WW16: The Outlaws and The Olives

[Jkaen]

ok, i am ok with the game. However if we want to do something then why not say from the next day onwards the top 2 voted people get lynched and the wolves make 2 kills a night?

[novice]

If wolves assume he was telling the truth, wouldn't they want to lynch him? Night killing him would then take one of their own with him, if he had been honest.

no it wouldn't, he didn't claim silverblood, he claimed to prevent the killing wolf from killing again for two days, which is a nonissue with five wolves left alive.

[pindicator]

no it wouldn't, he didn't claim silverblood, he claimed to prevent the killing wolf from killing again for two days, which is a nonissue with five wolves left alive.

Ah, thanks novice. Laziness reared its ugly head again

[novice]

Novice, you make another really confusing statement when you say that a protector should protect uberfish tonight.

I'm not going to elaborate on this, I don't think that would benefit the village.

[novice]

I don't see what we can do about playability except policy lynch some players until the number of players left is more manageable.

Unless the GM intervenes somehow.

[Tasunke]

ok, i am ok with the game. However if we want to do something then why not say from the next day onwards the top 2 voted people get lynched and the wolves make 2 kills a night?

If we do this, then everyone should have 2 votes instead of 1.

(at least while the double-kill rules are in effect)

[Jkaen]

dont see two votes as needed but would not object to it

[uberfish]

Also, if catwalk ever turns out to be scum, you are so buddy buddy with him this seems over the top. To say you are "now" leaning innocent on him? You've been defending him all game! Actually, why does deciding the mafia chose not to save thestick give catwalk a village lean?

... wtf. Saying I've been defending catwalk all game is factually wrong. My read's in fact shifted around on him.

And the reason catwalk gets a village lean and you don't is because scum would try to avoid being in the suspicious spots on bigger's wagon if they decided they weren't actually going to try to save thestick.

[pindicator]

And the reason catwalk gets a village lean and you don't is because scum would try to avoid being in the suspicious spots on bigger's wagon if they decided they weren't actually going to try to save thestick.

once again, it's like you read my post, disregarded the conclusion, and STATED THE EXACT SAME THING I DID with the addition that I'm somehow scum and catwalk isn't. Did you even read it? Let me link it for you. Notice anything familiar?

You're right about Catwalk, though. I double checked after posting and you only started defending him

[pindicator]

only been defending him since beginning of day 3