WW16: The Outlaws and The Olives

[Tasunke]

And after a lot of chatter he says he reuses the nighttime chatter and the fact that I can't see a reason why a villager would fake a PR to vote me here
Today he votes without any further comment.

sigh ... I didn't use the- for clarity, let me just say that I was saying I no longer suspected Novice(or Meiz) of being a wolf. had nothing to do with you.

Later, in the same post, I voted for you because your attitude was pissing me off.

Then most recently, I voted for you because I was suspecting Rowain/Ichabod, and I didn't say anything because I was practically half asleep.

[Catwalk]

I'd like to throw out a semi-crazy idea, please don't hang me for it. Mattimeo has an unusual role, and a pretty strong one at that. If noone else has a role similar to that (in terms of strength and uniqueness), it'd be pretty easy to call him out on it. So I suggest that anyone who can vouch for his role being believable says so. If noone speaks up, chances are that means his role stands out for good reason. Namely, it doesn't fit in with the rest of the roles because he faked it.

I know that we risk giving wolves PR information by doing so, as the only reason anyone can vouch for Mattimeo's role being plausible is if they have a PR themselves. Still, noone will have to reveal what their role is. For that matter, some kind of silver blood or bullet proof vouching for Mattimeo and drawing attention to themselves wouldn't be a bad thing.

I'm suggesting this because I don't believe Mattimeo's role claim. I don't have much of a read on him otherwise, but I think the claim is very weak. The fact that he's missed 3 nights in a row since then strengthens that suspicion a little bit (I remember missing a lot as a baner a few games ago, not saying that's a smoking gun by any means). Again, I'm putting it out for consideration first rather than shoving it down everybody's throats right away.

I really like the graphs Jkaen, great for getting an overview in a time efficient manner.

[Tasunke]

quote box error annoyed me, so I edited to fix it. Forgive me. (I added a "[" in front of /Quote] so that it would work instead of looking retarded)

[Jkaen]

I'd like to throw out a semi-crazy idea, please don't hang me for it. Mattimeo has an unusual role, and a pretty strong one at that. If noone else has a role similar to that (in terms of strength and uniqueness), it'd be pretty easy to call him out on it. So I suggest that anyone who can vouch for his role being believable says so. If noone speaks up, chances are that means his role stands out for good reason. Namely, it doesn't fit in with the rest of the roles because he faked it.

I know that we risk giving wolves PR information by doing so, as the only reason anyone can vouch for Mattimeo's role being plausible is if they have a PR themselves. Still, noone will have to reveal what their role is. For that matter, some kind of silver blood or bullet proof vouching for Mattimeo and drawing attention to themselves wouldn't be a bad thing.

I'm suggesting this because I don't believe Mattimeo's role claim. I don't have much of a read on him otherwise, but I think the claim is very weak. The fact that he's missed 3 nights in a row since then strengthens that suspicion a little bit (I remember missing a lot as a baner a few games ago, not saying that's a smoking gun by any means). Again, I'm putting it out for consideration first rather than shoving it down everybody's throats right away.

I really like the graphs Jkaen, great for getting an overview in a time efficient manner.

I really dont like this idea. While I agree he is suspicious we really dont need what few power roles we have declaring at this point

[Meiz]

@Catwalk, you're still seriously asking village PR's to reveal themselves.

[Tasunke]

Not purposely following Novice around or anything, but Rowain's last post sounded less "drunkard" and more 'innocent townie' ... and yes, I realize that he was probably just roleplaying his role as the town drunk

Nevertheless, it is true that now not only am I now the only one voting for Rowain, but also he is giving a decent contribution to the game, at least recently. Or, I guess you could say "defended well." Regardless, for these factors I do not feel like voting for Rowain anymore, but instead would wish to switch to Ichabod.

Therefore Ichabod.

[Mattimeo]

To be entirely honest, I'd prefer to be lynched than have several power roles come out and vouch for me like that. We'd at least have a higher chance of winning, even if I've got no input into it any more...

[Tasunke]

I second (or third) the notion that if catwalk keeps pushing a role reveal it will only get him lynched.

I overlooked the post at first, because I have also begun to suspect that Mattimeo's claim may have been fake.

However, even if it is fake, there is no reason to get ppl to claim there powers just so we can lynch good ole Matty

[Tasunke]

To be entirely honest, I'd prefer to be lynched than have several power roles come out and vouch for me like that. We'd at least have a higher chance of winning, even if I've got no input into it any more...

Regardless of alignment, this is a pretty pro-village post.

[Jkaen]

TT, I would be very interesed in your thoughts on Pindicator right now if you could humour me