WW16: The Outlaws and The Olives

[waterbat]

apparently i am bipolar and a correct lynch has made me flip to manic.

Anyway.... updated the tracker at http://www.cassidyweb.com/ww16 to include all posts up to 2130 and removed Arromir and Mattimeo from future updates. Lets keep the next 2 phases under 500 posts, k?

[Catwalk]

I just noticed Injera voted for me, so I decided to read back to see when he cast that vote. .... Hint:

post 1706, 3 hours after day start. He didn't change his mind even once, only vote he cast today even though he's been around for all the major discussions.

*douses waterbat with a garden hose to cool him down*

[Catwalk]

This had to be a frustrating day for Mattimeo, being rightly accused for all the wrong reasons. To be fair, we got lucky here. Two of the main arguments against him were his role name and his ability, both of which were accurate.

[waterbat]

This had to be a frustrating day for Mattimeo, being rightly accused for all the wrong reasons. To be fair, we got lucky here. Two of the main arguments against him were his role name and his ability, both of which were accurate.

You know - I wasnt moved at all by those arguments. I was moved by what i posted in the first vote on him. If we had 2 wolves up on the block on day 1, a lot of things fall into place. Why the push on a third innocent wagon (Bigger)? why thestick gave up the way he did. I just got a lot better feeling about day 1 if his alignment was mafia.

Without the push on him though, i just sigh and let it go. Yet another time one of my theories gets no traction, so great job seizing that opening guys!

I enjoy a good meta discussion fracas as much as anyone, but all the stuff about roll name and ability was mostly lost on me. Of course, re-reading mattimeo's posts didn't help me either - i truly was getting cold feet there.

[Catwalk]

D1 making a lot more sense with Mattimeo as scum motivated me too, but I was probably mostly on the meta arguments. I think Mattimeo played it quite well, but not using his charges was suspicious.

[pindicator]

You know - I wasnt moved at all by those arguments. I was moved by what i posted in the first vote on him. If we had 2 wolves up on the block on day 1, a lot of things fall into place. Why the push on a third innocent wagon (Bigger)? why thestick gave up the way he did. I just got a lot better feeling about day 1 if his alignment was mafia.

Without the push on him though, i just sigh and let it go. Yet another time one of my theories gets no traction, so great job seizing that opening guys!

I enjoy a good meta discussion fracas as much as anyone, but all the stuff about roll name and ability was mostly lost on me. Of course, re-reading mattimeo's posts didn't help me either - i truly was getting cold feet there.

Yeah, I wish I would have put the pieces together before that. I was certainly asked the question time and time again, but you put it together :D So kudos waterbat. Maybe I can take you down off my suspect list now,
But you're right, Mattimeo did a great job of acting the part - I was reading posts 751 & 752 by him at the end of the day and it was a great job acting by him.

If you would have made me choose at the end of the day, I would have said Mattimeo felt the most villager to me of all 3 of our claimers. I'm glad I kept my mouth shut at the end.

[Tasunke]

This had to be a frustrating day for Mattimeo, being rightly accused for all the wrong reasons. To be fair, we got lucky here. Two of the main arguments against him were his role name and his ability, both of which were accurate.

I'll have to go back and look at Matt's claim, but I think he claimed "His ability + Baner" or at least implied that his ability would also work like a baner (being a sort of 'super' baner)

which was perhaps one of the best reasons I saw today for not lynching him.

[novice]

Btw, now that I've calmed down enough to actually read this - this writeup is hilarious.

"Well, voting for people who didn't vote for the mafia Stickman day one didn't work, so what now?"
"Well the people who aren't talking are suspicious, shouldn't we try to scare them into talking by threatening to kill them?"
"We should!"
"Okay people who aren't talking, you're up to die, what's your defense?"
*Crickets*
"Hmm... well that didn't work, what shall we do now?"
"I have an idea, we should go after the man who claims he throws cloaks over people to hide them, that sounds suspicious no?"
"Well I object to that, why would you think he's suspicious?"
"I'm glad you asked; I've been following him and other people at night, and haven't had ANY results so far on what they do! Therefore he needs to explain himself."
"Well not only does that not prove anything, but I have been following YOU and know that you went to visit someone last night, so YOU'RE suspicious?"
"Oh yeah, well you can't do the same thing I do cause I already do it, so you're wrong!"
"No, you pretended to do what I do before you know I did it so you're wrong!"
"Wait, are you two actually claiming to be able to do the same thing?"
"Yeah we are! Oh, wait a minute......"
"Oops."
"Well let's kill one of them anyways!"
"Which one?"
"How about the one that the other two have been following the last few days?"
*Shrugs* "Why not?"

And so they did.

Mattimeo was lynched. He was a Cloaker for the Mafia

Now to try and sleep without dreaming of role claims...

[Gaspar]

Nice.

Not sure I would have had the balls to do that, or even if I think it was the best play, but I'm glad it worked out. Wasn't quite able to squeeze away from work long enough to play a part, but I probably would have picked between Qgqqqqq and Injera. Anyway, I superskimmed so going to reread before I add anything concrete.

[Lewwyn]

Posting between classes and my students are reading over my shoulder, but I wante dto quickly chime in:

WOW

also

I have to go to bed soon I have early morning classes and I simply can't stay up any longer to see what happens. I don't know what I should do with my vote because I feel that Catwalk simply doesn't have enough support to lynched, I've already stated my opinion on Mattimeo and Injera and I don't want it to simply be a landside on Qg. In a few hours everything is going to fucking change and my vote is going to end up being a waste again.

Called it.