WW16: The Outlaws and The Olives

[pindicator]

pindicator, you made an anti-town vote before and it was discussed. You said I had a really good point about about giving scum more voting power that way. You do the exact same thing again, and make a comment that you were glad you didn't vote. I point out you did the same again, and you take great offense. You seem to be attacking everyone right now, smells to me like a wolf trying to fake frustration.

The shoe's on the other foot, eh catwalk? I guess it's one thing to say I will try to do it, and then another when I'm on the spot and have to choose. To be honest, my self-confidence is shot, I've made the wrong choices all game, and I'm feeling shitty about how I've done so far. I'm tempted to just piggy-back novice tomorrow while I try to get a fresh perspective.

But if you want to go after me, I'm going to refer you back to my day 1 voting (ironic, huh?). Let's pretned I'm a wolf, and we have thestick up for in the lead of a vote count. Uberfish and serdoa both express interest in Mattimeo, but neither vote. So why do I push a vote on Mattimeo and start that bandwagon? Why not go for Bigger or someone else instead of putting a second wolf up on the block?


@novice - Do you take Twinkletoes reluctance at the end of the day to be honest paranoia? I need to review a lot, but I just re-read the last hour and a half of the day (i was trying to find where I got the impression that you weren't on the first mattimeo bandwagon; it was from mis-remembering twinkletoes' post after you started the mattimeo push), and there's a lot of push back from twinkletoes. I can see that as paranoia because he had been on your case, but him & molach are the only two people who post to hold off on mattimeo at that point. I need to read earlier, on the first push in the day.

I ask because I remember how quickly TT agreed with mattimeo's claim and disregarded thestick's (back on day 1). So I need to review twinkletoes' stuff and see how his shift on mattimeo came about. Right now i'm wondering if he was playing his part in thestick's bussing.

So I guess I'm not in TT's camp after all...

[Twinkletoes89]

To be honest, my self-confidence is shot, I've made the wrong choices all game, and I'm feeling shitty about how I've done so far. I'm tempted to just piggy-back novice tomorrow while I try to get a fresh perspective.

We all make errors in the game - but piggybacking isn't going to make it any better. In fact it could be a bigger mistake.

So I guess I'm not in TT's camp after all...

but we have tasty marshmellows roasting on the fire...

[Catwalk]

I'm not saying you're my top suspect, I'm just saying that you keep voting blank. I didn't look at anything other than today's voting, and your vote stood out to me. I pointed out several other suspicious players as well, based on that vote alone. I find your reaction suspicious, are you defending already? I have little certainty on most lynches, but I go ahead and make my vote count anyway because I know I'm townie.

[pindicator]

I'm not saying you're my top suspect, I'm just saying that you keep voting blank. I didn't look at anything other than today's voting, and your vote stood out to me. I pointed out several other suspicious players as well, based on that vote alone. I find your reaction suspicious, are you defending already? I have little certainty on most lynches, but I go ahead and make my vote count anyway because I know I'm townie.

So, you list me as a top suspect, call me out as being anti-town, and then when I defend you tell me you weren't attacking me? And that you find it suspicious I was defending your non-attack?

Seriously Catwalk, make up your mind. Either I'm a suspect or I'm not.

[waterbat]

I'm a suspect

Really??

[waterbat]

I'm townie.

Damn, this game is easy.

[pindicator]

thanks waterbat, i needed that. (Having just typed up a huge rant directed at catwalk and then seeing your post, I think i'll let it sit.)

[Catwalk]

My suspects based on the vote:

You're correct, I did word that a little differently from what I intended. As stated above, what I meant is that I find those 4 players suspicious based on the vote alone. That should be cross referenced with everything else we know, which is quite a bit. It was a comment on the vote results.

[pindicator]

Fuck, I can't let it go:

Catwalk, I am going to vote for who I want, when I want, and you can make whatever reads you want based off that. Your whole mob mentality "have to vote for the group" is as dumb as saying I'm throwing my vote away on a third party candidate.

[Catwalk]

I still think it's anti-town. If you're around during the last hour or so and you vote for someone who has no chance of hanging, you're giving scum more power. No problem with trying to push someone else, even with little time left (today showed that things can change fast), but if that goes nowhere there's little point in not going for the lesser evil out of the options available.

I'm not sure what you mean about mob mentality and voting for the group.