WW16: The Outlaws and The Olives

[Tasunke]

Selrahc-21

Azza-34

Molach-35

of those left alive, Selrahc is the only person posting less than Azza; Molach isn't doing much better.

By this point into the game, I could see any of these three to be a safe policy lynch.

[Molach]

Phone. Bus.

Tasunke plz Injera is follower not tracker.

And 'only Injera to benefit from Matt lynch'...I benefited from that lynch, didn't you?

Did you read that Injera has given results for 3 players still alive now, all did nothing. Are they all wolves or did Injera guess, knowing that wrong guess =lynch?

And by vote result it was pretty obvious that qgqqqqq was village, so of course they had him killed. Tracker with unlimited shots - kill asap. Just like they will hit Injera next night.

Gonna make a vote when I hit pc at work, and then mabye work a bit

[Tasunke]

Well, with Qgqqqq flipping innocent, we have one confirmed thing: Injera has a power role and he used it on Catwalk on day 3.

How can we be sure of this? I must have missed it ... did Qqqq say that he followed Injera onto Catwalk?

And as for you Injera (yay ethiopian bread!), since you seem to be online at this time, what sort of power did u use on catwalk, or namely what did u see him do?

(yes you posted it elsewhere, but I feel if you post it here again in answer, then at least it will be more present in the thread, exactly the status that proper evidence needs to be)

[Tasunke]

And by vote result it was pretty obvious that qgqqqqq was village, so of course they had him killed. Tracker with unlimited shots - kill asap. Just like they will hit Injera next night.

right. and so if Injera keeps surviving nights ....

[Tasunke]

Phone. Bus.

Tasunke plz Injera is follower not tracker.

And 'only Injera to benefit from Matt lynch'...I benefited from that lynch, didn't you?

Did you read that Injera has given results for 3 players still alive now, all did nothing. Are they all wolves or did Injera guess, knowing that wrong guess =lynch?

And by vote result it was pretty obvious that qgqqqqq was village, so of course they had him killed. Tracker with unlimited shots - kill asap. Just like they will hit Injera next night.

Gonna make a vote when I hit pc at work, and then mabye work a bit

Hmm, so at post 36 you start to wake up for Day 5? I certainly hope you will contribute more than you have been

[Injera]

Obvious x-post up above.

If someone else could determine whom of the two was the most lynchable, we may be able to determine Injera's alignment right here and now.

You can make your own determination, but I'd suggest rereading last night. Of course, for someone conspiracy-minded like yourself I'd imagine you'd be smart enough to imagine wolves not acting completely deterministically.

Preview edit: I used "tinkerer" ability to "bug" Catwalk to see his night action. There was no result, like all of my reads. And yes Qg verified that he had tracked me visiting him.

[Tasunke]

Also, do you really think the wolves would get a follower, a watcher, and a "cloaker" and the village gets a tracker?

Hmm, Molach mentioned this as well ... what is the difference between a Follower and a Tracker? The later knows who they visited while the former does not?

[Injera]

Hmm, Molach mentioned this as well ... what is the difference between a Follower and a Tracker? The later knows who they visited while the former does not?

This is what I screwed up too, which unfortunately led to Qg's claim. From what I can tell a tracker watches who someone visits, while a follower watches what action they do. And a watcher watches who visits someone. Dunno if there's an analogous role for someone who watches what happens to someone.

[Tasunke]

Preview edit: I used "tinkerer" ability to "bug" Catwalk to see his night action. There was no result, like all of my reads. And yes Qg verified that he had tracked me visiting him.

Hmm, alright.

If we assumed that this was some power madness game where everyone had a power, then perhaps guessing that Catwalk did nothing at night would be highly risky, and a tell that perhaps either you are village or both of you are wolves. However, this is a light power game, and many of the powers have already died. Still, you *did* do so as early as night 3, so that DOES seem to be somewhat ... ReDEEMing.

If we can assume that Injera is innocent (which will be harder ... ... as time goes on without a nightkill), then perhaps we can look elsewhere for the wolves.

Ichabod: it is true, his defense of Mattimeo is a bit too obvious, especially if they had wanted to bus him. But WAIT. If neither Injera/Qqqq are wolves, then it WASNT a bus. Which means that Ichabod's defesne may very well have been a desperate wolf maneuver to save the cloaker.

Rowain: sure, he is just being rowain ... or IS he?

Novice/Gaspar/Jkaen: any sufficiently skilled player is indistinguishable by alignment

Lewwyn: not exactly been crusading a lot lately, has he?

Of the above, I think that Ichabod would be the safest lynch ... but on the other hand, there are always the Selrahc/Azza/Molach lurkers. Perhaps we should start by lynching all the lurkers? I still think Ichabod is a bit safer for now though.

[Tasunke]

Hmm, how did you screw up your own claim? Did you only switch from Tracker to Follower once it became evident there was already a Tracker? :P