WW16: The Outlaws and The Olives

[pindicator]

The Waterbat vote was because I felt he's been cruising through this game, and playing in a way to de-escalate conflict by not engaging with it, and I thought the vote based case against him made sense.

So you think his involvement in the mattimeo lynch trumps this?

[Ichabod]

I'd be up to vote for Gaspar, but I don't feel confident on my hunches in this game. I'm a bit wary about Meiz voting for Waterbat. If I recall correctly, Meiz was not on Molach on day 6 and, while I'm more confident now that Novice's post restriction was indeed true, I'm not so sure about Meiz. If you stop to think about it, the Mafia seem to have played very conservative with their power roles (we know Molach didn't use his power and Mattimeo didn't use his on day 1 and 2). This makes the use of the PR on Meiz even weirder.

I probably should be feeling more confident about voting Gaspar, but I'm really unsure about everything.

[waterbat]

I'm a bit worried about how today is going in light of the day 6 mislynch:

tasunke - 5 - Pindicator, Selrahc, Injera, Waterbat, Catwalk, (novice then does the mayoral kill shot)

im trusting of all those people - but i must be wrong. I find it very unlikely that we ended up that way with all village votes on Tasunke. Yes - I know I am in the group.

Bringing this up does nothing to save me though im just finding it unsettling.

[waterbat]

if indeed those alignments are village - then meiz was a failed bus attempt? i can't buy that either.

[Catwalk]

I say we hang Azza and find out if it was an elaborate rescue operation.

[pindicator]

waterbat, why aren't you pushing someone in the tasunke group if that's your case?

[Selrahc]

So you think his involvement in the mattimeo lynch trumps this?

Yes. Or.. not trumps it so much as negates it a bit.

[waterbat]

waterbat, why aren't you pushing someone in the tasunke group if that's your case?

i had those people in my villager camp. its unsettling. do you think its possible we had all villagers in that scenario?

[novice]

novice, why do you find waterbat more scummy than Azza? Honest question, not a trap or accusation.

I've been having trouble explaining my Azza read all game, but I still see him as a villager playing conservatively. He has made some good contributions lately too, in his short and sweet style.

As for Waterbat I felt he started this day really badly, not addressing the suspicions being directed at him but instead calling the case fabricated and questioning the credibility of the accusers. He's pulled it together now, but then again so would a wolf. I don't really see any good alternatives to Waterbat's lynch right now.

[pindicator]

Well, remember how fast everything was going at the end of that day. I think it's likely villagers, just because I don't know if scum would want to get mixed up in all that.