After a little bit of rereading, I see no way pindicator is wolf. He went for Lewwyn all day, and when he was at risk of hanging he stuck with Lewwyn. Considering that it seems he's also less inclined to hang me, I'm putting my mayor vote there.
|
WW16: The Outlaws and The Olives
|
|
Here are my reads based on yesterday, in order of least to most suspicious:
pindicator + Went straight for Lewwyn + Fought hard for his innocence and for the lynch of Lewwyn in spite of an annoying post restriction Meiz + I find it unlikely two wolves would be on the block + Contributed actively, much analysis of earlier days Gaspar + Helped hang Lewwyn + Could have hung Meiz instead ? Wanted to hang pindicator TT - Didn't really talk much most of the day - First says pindicator feels villager but then spends several posts nitpicking about his post restriction - Suspects pindicator on basis of post #3555 - Voted Meiz early and never changed it, arguing that one wolf has to be post restricted and Meiz is the most scummy of them Waterbat - Was novice's #1 suspect - Voted for Meiz Jkaen - Looks like he's trying to blend in, contributed little - Voted for pindicator very early and stayed on him after the momentum fell away Suspecting them in pretty much that order. Had waterbat below Jkaen on grounds of novice suspecting him, but I actually find Jkaen voting blank to be much more damning than waterbat voting Meiz. I'd hang Gaspar over TT, I can see Gaspar hanging Lewwyn in order to get cover before it's too late. I think our chances are best with waterbat or Jkaen.
I appreciate the faith Catwalk, but if we can't narrow a mayor target soon then I'm going to vote for TT just because everybody is sure he is village.
Suffer Game Sicko
Dodo Tier Player (October 19th, 2012, 10:20)Twinkletoes89 Wrote: Sigh Look TT, despite what everyone around here seems to think there is functionally no difference between awarding mayor to a villager with poor judgement and scum. You've had some good moments this game but if it were up to you novice would have been dead on day 3 and we'd probably already be looking at a scum win. And this is a constant theme for you - your level of paranoia is healthy contribution for the village but it doesn't bode well for a mayor role which could be the difference between victory and defeat. I was on Pindicator as much as anyone but it is pretty darned difficult to believe after yesterday that he's scum without some damning new information. If he is scum, well then I'm really going to be kicking myself black and blue in the post-game thread. And if nothing else I trust him to build consensus and not abuse his power. Do I think I'm a better choice? Yes. But I can live with Pin. I'm not sure what to say right now - I think we have 3 possible candidates today and I feel pretty strongly that Jkaen and Waterbat are better options than Catwalk. But I'm open to be convinced if someone has something convincing to say.
Well, odds are good this won't be the last mayor vote of the game... :-/
Anyway, I like that we're coming to agreement on who looks scummiest. Jkaen & Waterbat are my top two, and if any of those is wrong then we have to look at Meiz / Catwalk next I think. But both Meiz & Catwalk have had a lot of strong village moments. Waterbat & Jkaen just have so few village moments and so many scum moments that I'm feeling really good about them being our last two scum. I'm really hoping it is and we can wrap this up, because if it isn't then we'll have a tougher decision to make. But that doesn't mean we need to get ahead of ourselves either. So I am feeling very good about getting a village win here, probably for the first time all game.
Suffer Game Sicko
Dodo Tier Player (October 19th, 2012, 11:20)pindicator Wrote: Well, odds are good this won't be the last mayor vote of the game... :-/ you best get the last one right. Unless you die as you indicated. Then it won't be up to you. If your reasoning is correct on jkaen and you follow through on killing me as suggested, then gaspar likely to be night killed as well. so it will come down to : TT Catwalk Meiz still feeling good about a village win when you arent sure if its Catwalk or Meiz??? At this point TT makes the decision. Perhaps TT should self-vote and take his vig shot upon lynch. This might be a good reason to make TT mayor, although if its Catwalk voting Meiz and Meiz voting Catwalk, it won't matter much.
--
Best dating advice on RB: When you can't hide your unit, go in fast and hard. -- Sullla
October 19th, 2012, 12:40
(This post was last modified: October 19th, 2012, 12:41 by BRickAstley.)
Official Lynch Vote Count
Jkaen - 4 - Pindicator, Gaspar, Waterbat, Catwalk Waterbat - 1 - Twinkletoes89 Players not voting: Jkaen, Meiz Official Mayor Vote Count Pindicator - 3 - Pindicator, Catwalk, Gaspar Twinkletoes89 - 1 - Twinkletoes89 Players not voting: Jkaen, Meiz, Waterbat 27 Hours Remaining Also, I will very likely be unavailable at Day end tomorrow for the lynch results, so Commodore will be posting the official end-of-day results. EDIT: Also since the lighter background makes light colored text hard to see, you can post mayor votes in regular blue instead of Cyan and that's fine. Just so you know. |
