WW 19 Game Thread - Mobster Mayhem - GAME OVER

[pindicator]

not only is passing the gun on dangerous because it could slip into scum hands, but the chance of hitting villager is very high.

ok I think I would prefer the vig not even use it. It only has 3 shots (spread over 3 people) so the danger of "running out of time" before the end of game is not very high at all. even if you saved it until night 3 before using it.

Hey Bigger, plan on doing some scum hunting this game?

[novice]

Frankly it's very unlikely that scum start with the gun, so I would consider it a natural assumption that the gun belongs to a villager vigilante. I wouldn't consider "if it belongs to a villager" qualifiers scum tells either, since people tend to add those qualifiers just to avoid people latching on to it later, convinced they've found a scumtell. In general I would consider tells associated with phrasing worth little. We need to go one level higher and look at interactions, contradictions, etc.

[Bigger]

not only is passing the gun on dangerous because it could slip into scum hands, but the chance of hitting villager is very high.

ok I think I would prefer the vig not even use it. It only has 3 shots (spread over 3 people) so the danger of "running out of time" before the end of game is not very high at all. even if you saved it until night 3 before using it.

Hey Bigger, plan on doing some scum hunting this game?

not during the night phase, no.

we've only had 1 day, what do you want from me?

[pindicator]

not only is passing the gun on dangerous because it could slip into scum hands, but the chance of hitting villager is very high.

ok I think I would prefer the vig not even use it. It only has 3 shots (spread over 3 people) so the danger of "running out of time" before the end of game is not very high at all. even if you saved it until night 3 before using it.

Hey Bigger, plan on doing some scum hunting this game?

not during the night phase, no.

we've only had 1 day, what do you want from me?

Day phase didn't seem to work so well for you either.

[Serdoa]

Why is Serdoa the first person to question if the gun is in villager hands?
Why did nobody else do this earlier?

I have no idea whether that means we may have had a wolf slip earlier or if Serdoa is being extra-careful with his words here, I just thought that interesting.

Nah, we are told that only the board is definitely with us at the start, so obviously no other item can be considered certainly in villager hands. I actually assume that BRick simply randomized who got what and did not care if scum or village. So yeah, maybe you found a wolf slip by Selrahc. Another one...

A wolf slip by Selrahc? You realize he's quoting you?

If you read all posts as carefully as that of pindicator I certainly understand now your ridiculous stance about Rowain.

[Qgqqqqq]

...

Azza: General lurkiness plus piggybacking on a wagon without getting involved in the discussion (of course I could also include Bigger and Merovech in this group )

Why don't you include them then? And btw, Azza got involved in the discussion. Please go and reread his posts. He delivered easily as much as uberfish did (not that that would be such a great feat, uberfish did nothing for the village on D1).
...

Now that I've had a look at the tracker, I'll say this: bullshit.
Uberfish didn't contribute masses to the village, but he contributed WAY more then Azza.

Just because you happened to disagree with the points he raised (Guilty read is still accurate with fool card in wolf hands, fool card isn't reason enough for lynch, etc.) doesn't mean they don't exist.
Look over Azza's posts (up to p495) there is exactly ONE post with more then one lines, said post has two lines.
Now Im not saying no. of words/lines equates to useful discussion, but I think its VERY clear that uberfish contributed more.

As to your latest post, I think novice has responded to that adequately.

[Qgqqqqq]

Stop trolling, serdoa.

Clarification: there are in fact two posts with more then one line, but one of them is just lynch/mayor vote.

[Bigger]

not only is passing the gun on dangerous because it could slip into scum hands, but the chance of hitting villager is very high.

ok I think I would prefer the vig not even use it. It only has 3 shots (spread over 3 people) so the danger of "running out of time" before the end of game is not very high at all. even if you saved it until night 3 before using it.

Hey Bigger, plan on doing some scum hunting this game?

not during the night phase, no.

we've only had 1 day, what do you want from me?

Day phase didn't seem to work so well for you either.

And your day 1 was better? Or anyone's day 1, for that matter.

[Qgqqqqq]

At least he contributed

[waterbat]

@zak, novice: novice answered just as I would have, but i had the knowledge that tasunke was possible and also had the days result. Someone pointed out that tasunke was down to 2 votes at the time of bigger's post. If true, that explains a lot - the outstanding question would be 'why didn't bigger log back in and switch back to tasunke. Knowing that bigger's been keeping closer to lewwyn's sleep schedule than that of a normal CST resident, I wouldn't be surprised if he was sleeping then.

But obviously, someone stating 'I prefer X over Y, but I'm going to vote Y' is going to raise eyebrows when Y ends up beating X by 1 vote.

Dont have much to add, so haven't been posting much. Those that i have played with should see that is an obvious tell on my alignment.


Re: scraper: remember to check the last updated date on the main page and refresh the data if needed.

Re: qgqqqq telling Ryan his posts are making heads spin. That's some serious irony.