WW26: The Masquerade [Game Thread]

[Agnes The Orphan]

sry didn't mean to post last bit, should read:

thankyou agnes for showing some brains. not bad for an orphan.

Orphans get brains too - bigger brains then tinheads at least

[Scarlet John]

liz is not even who i vote for. point is meta clearance is really really dumb and will lose game down the track

Agreed. For all we know a sample village PM could have been posted in the wolf thread. After all, it's already been well established that village has an unfair advantage if wolves don't know the format of the village PM.

[Lady Elizabeth]

Your're not understanding Bert's agurement... yay. It goes like this

1. I summarized the villager role pm. Ways I could have done this:
a) guess the villager role PM. Insanely risky in the first post.
b) be a wolf. And have brick give a wolfs a sample PM so they can fake it. This is very unlikely for reason's Bert pointed out.
c) Be a villager summarize my role pm.
I really cannot see any other ways.

2. One of the three possibilities had to have happened. And a+b are unlikely. C is likely to be true and I must be a villager.

I'll just dump my vote on Sister Mary for only making a single post that does not do anything.

[Widow Edith]

While I agree with Agnes on principle based on all that transpired I rather clear Lady Elisabeth till convincing evidence to the contrary. Can we now put the meta to rest and play the game?

Now that Percvial has shown up I have to think who to vote for. I'm bound to switch off as there are a couple of players with only 1 posts I feel that's worse than what Percvial is doing.

So far Simple Anne has not shown up at all. And we have 2 people with rather odd posts.
First Young Will with his novice/Darrell joke here and second Sister Mary with that piece of fencesitting/idle chatter. Additional Easy Sarah and her handwaving.

[Lady Elizabeth]

liz is not even who i vote for. point is meta clearance is really really dumb and will lose game down the track

Agreed. For all we know a sample village PM could have been posted in the wolf thread. After all, it's already been well established that village has an unfair advantage if wolves don't know the format of the village PM.

This is flawed. It is very unlikely that the sample villager PM was posted in the wolf thread for reason's Bert pointed out. Also it is not in Brick's style to step up a trap like this for the village. The fact that Brick edited his post in response to Bert is damning. It implies he made a mistake; and he wouldn't have made a mistake if he posted the village pm in the wolf thread.

Check out Krill's new sig (Civ>ww) to. I doubt he is playing in this game...

[Lady Elizabeth]

While I agree with Agnes on principle based on all that transpired I rather clear Lady Elisabeth till convincing evidence to the contrary. Can we now put the meta to rest and play the game?

Now that Percvial has shown up I have to think who to vote for. I'm bound to switch off as there are a couple of players with only 1 posts I feel that's worse than what Percvial is doing.

So far Simple Anne has not shown up at all. And we have 2 people with rather odd posts.
First Young Will with his novice/Darrell joke here and second Sister Mary with that piece of fencesitting/idle chatter. Additional Easy Sarah and her handwaving.

I take it this is a cross-post

[Widow Edith]

I know it is weekend etc etc. but this is a game where we really can't let lurkers go by unpunished. We don't have any baseline so we need your words to judge you. So please speak up and be active.

[Agnes The Orphan]

Check out Krill's new sig (Civ>ww) to. I doubt he is playing in this game...

I repeat, please stop doing this (also it is obviously a reference to his postcount being higher then novices and would be unrelated to a game like this).

As for the rest, I dislike the way you're arguing youre innocence by basically saying other people are right, and I disagree with the a+b+c idea (did you even read ny post???), but I agree with the widow on this, lets just drop it.

Id like to hear more (read:something) from Simple Anne

[Kate The Waif]

Sir Percival is annoying me with his posting style, and he seems to me to be acting like a melodramatic bully when his logic fell out of favor, but I actually agree with him that immediately clearing LE is risky. In addition, I find it unlikely that a wolf would be so antagonistic unless he was trying to get bussed, so while I originally starts this post with the intention to vote for him, I have changed my mind on the matter, and will instead place my vote on Know-Nothing Jon for repeatedly furthering the name-finding nonsense.

[Bert The Bard]

Sir Percival is annoying me with his posting style, and he seems to me to be acting like a melodramatic bully when his logic fell out of favor, but I actually agree with him that immediately clearing LE is risky. In addition, I find it unlikely that a wolf would be so antagonistic unless he was trying to get bussed, so while I originally starts this post with the intention to vote for him, I have changed my mind on the matter, and will instead place my vote on Know-Nothing Jon for repeatedly furthering the name-finding nonsense.

So you reckon that makes him scum? How? We're past the random voting stage.