HNH, that's twice now that you've said we had two villagers on the block all game long, but we still don't know Short Richard's alignment. Also, I think it's beneficial to lock the scum down to vanilla claims, if that is what they will default to. There might still be town powers left, so scum would always prefer to stay unclaimed if possible, for example in case they are seen visiting someone. That would be one instance where they'd need to change their story, but can't, if they've already claimed vanilla.
I find it slightly suspicious that you made a big deal out of all this, instead of just claiming your role and being done with it.
(August 3rd, 2013, 02:22)Fat Rose Wrote: Also, I think I explained yesterday well enough why I voted for Muriel (change in posting style together with some meta-considerations).
Muriel's post style did not change this entire game.
As for all the other stuff, whatever dude. I'm not about to frustrate myself any more this game. You can keep going on and on about me being an ill mannered kid, but I was provoked and through all of it I never dropped an f-bomb. I tried very very hard to stay as civil as possible unlike some people. I tried to remove myself from the situation. Not giving up, not running away. Did I bring up the past? No, but you did. You seem to be trying to inflame the situation once more. You are again smearing, accusing of bad behavior, trying to paint me badly. I have been attacked this entire game and I only stated my opinions this entire game.
I have not lied or misrepresented what I've thought this entire game.
I only wanted a fun easy game. But everyone seems to use anonymity as a shield for bad behavior. I have acted the same in this game as I have in every single game I have played on this site.
I'm going to stop now before I get angry. If you think I'm copping out, lynch me and end this game. I will welcome it. If not I will simply vote for those I think are wolves.
A collection just for you Rob. I find it hilarious that you claim you've played like always, because if you have I certainly haven't played with you.
(July 22nd, 2013, 11:08)Rob The Filch Wrote: Her posts were mudslinging and intentionally MISLEADING.
Oh a merrily we go! Let the wolf alive! Soner or later she'll tell us we were right! Happily to the noose she'll go! WE JUST NEED TO GIVE HER ENOUGH TIME!
(July 23rd, 2013, 08:16)Rob The Filch Wrote: He didn't say he wasn't going to do shit. He actually did shit today. More shit than you did in all your posts today. You're the one pontificating and doing jack shit.
...
People change their minds in WW. Is that a hard concept for you to understand Muriel? I know you're slow. It'll be okay.
(July 23rd, 2013, 08:19)Rob The Filch Wrote: The highlighted bit is the worst. You have a choice. But you are making it seem like we have NO choice. Your hands are tied. You wash the blood. Pontius Pilate reincarnated!
(July 23rd, 2013, 08:24)Rob The Filch Wrote: Wow this is a lie. Its just a straight up lie. Percival has been making his thoughts known he has attempted to look around at other targets today besides you. He thinks you are even scummier today. Guess what? I DO TOO! He is actively hunting you which is why you are trying to slam him. And john isn't directly and openly against the village. My God it hurts my head. He IS actively contributing. You are slandering and lying.
(July 23rd, 2013, 08:33)Rob The Filch Wrote: I can't stand it anymore. I wanted to wait until later in the day to start the wagon on you Muriel the Slow, but I can't stand your BS anymore. All game from the first post you've been writing long flowery language that goes on forever and is nauseating.
(July 23rd, 2013, 09:12)Rob The Filch Wrote: You are infuriating. Condecesnding. Patronizing. Self-righteous. My blood boils.
(July 23rd, 2013, 09:17)Rob The Filch Wrote: You can kiss my ass, kiss my ass, kiss my ass.
As for your "claim" that you want to have two wolves on the block: Care to explain why you just got that idea only AFTER Harry got more votes than Richard? If you believe Richard and I are both wolves, why did you initially vote for him stating:
(August 1st, 2013, 19:27)Rob The Filch Wrote: I was pretty sure Short Richard was a wolf and Muriel was a villager. But in the end Muriel had to be lynched because her play did not deserve to be rewarded. I also believe that the village has a better chance of winning with her dead. Not that I intend to try very hard.
1) So you don't intend to try hard but now suddenly find it important to push someone else besides the one you are sure is a wolf?
2) And you just start that when exactly that player you are sure is a wolf is losing votes?
3) On top of that, you claim you were sure Muriel was a villager yet you suspect me because I did give in on her lynch to easily?
Quite honestly, are you not even questioning your own logic at some point? Your play contradicts what you yourself claim are your believes.
Rob the Filch
Not sure if you are a wolf with Richard and just saw the possibility to push someone besides Harry up, hoping to win already today, or one together with Harry that got nervous that Harry could get lynched and your certain win goes awry in the last second. But I am by now certain that you are a wolf. You've made less and less contributions over the last days, after just pushing Muriel at the start. I guess it was easier to find someone to attack at the start but by now it just isn't as easy anymore, so better to just claim you are done with it and hope everyone accepts that and leaves you be.
I'm thinking of staying on HNH. The "we have to lynch him sooner or later" argument applies almost equally to him as to Short Richard, IMO. And I think he's been rehashing stuff that others said all game long, with little original thought. Starting with his very first post, actually. Seems like he may be trying to stay active just for the sake of it.
His "time to go with my gut" angle today is fishy.
Know-Nothing Jon - lean town
Rob the Filch - lean scum
Widow Edith - not sure Short Richard - best lynch today imo
Young Will - should be town
Fat Rose - lean town
Doctor Saul - makes no sense. lean scum but could be awful village
Half-Nose Harry - 2nd best lynch today
Sir Percival - village
pretty confident in lynching tiny dick and half face, who to lynch later up in air.
lets not get too cute and make sure consolidate by end of day on tiny dick and/or harry. they clear 2 scummiest candidate.
To those suggesting the wolves want to bus Short Richard today, why? I don't think they would bother busing him when they can just lynch a villager today and win. I'm not saying I'm ruling it out entirely, just that I think it's simpler today for them to simply be going for the win.
Rob, your suggestion of having two wolves on the block is nice and all, but in the end of the day we have to consolidate votes. If the village ends up 3-2 we lose. If 4-1 and the 1 is on a villager, we lose because the wolves can jump on. If the one is on a wolf, then depending on influence scores the wolves may be able to hop onto a villager and win a 4-4 tie.
This is how the votes stand currently.
Short Richard (4) Doctor Saul, Rob The Filch, Sir Percival, Widow Edith
Half-Nose Harry (3) Young Will, Short Richard, Know-Nothing Jon
Rob The Filch (1) Fat Rose
Fat Rose (1) Half-Nose Harry
I know I am a villager, and I'm still working on the assumption that Will is as well. That leaves three villagers left. So I can know that there is at least one wolf sitting on Richard. Given that I do not think the wolves would want to bus him when they could just win, this makes me even less likely to want to vote for him today. Apparently my Rose vote isn't going to get traction, which makes me believe in it more at this point. I will be leaving shortly on a trip, and will be traveling over deadline. I'll have access via phone so I can watch and consolidate onto someone, but as I've said I really don't like the Short Richard, and he is the only target other than myself with more then one vote, so I am leaving my vote on Rose for the time being.
I'm getting tired of you Saul. I was on Short Richard, actually the only one together with Edith before I switched to Rob because of his behaviour. It's 4 posts above yours, it shouldn't be too hard to find. I even explained that I'm just questioning if he was setting up Richard to be bussed but decided that maybe he could end it today by getting a mislynch on me or if he is wolf together with Harry. And guess what, your post certainly reads as if you know already that Richard will show up guilty. Bussing together with Rob?
Short Richard
And btw, it is Saturday, some people do have a live besides this forum. Not sure how it is with you, but I certainly have better things to do than sit in front of my computer for hours, especially when it has +30° outside...
Harry, I work under the assumption that you are a villager for this post.
(August 3rd, 2013, 10:36)Half-Nose Harry Wrote: To those suggesting the wolves want to bus Short Richard today, why? I don't think they would bother busing him when they can just lynch a villager today and win. I'm not saying I'm ruling it out entirely, just that I think it's simpler today for them to simply be going for the win.
Because when we lynched Muriel Jon and Edith both already claimed they would want to lynch him next? Maybe they just thought he would get lynched in any case, so better to bus than to appear suspicious for trying to save him?
Quote:Rob, your suggestion of having two wolves on the block is nice and all, but in the end of the day we have to consolidate votes. If the village ends up 3-2 we lose. If 4-1 and the 1 is on a villager, we lose because the wolves can jump on. If the one is on a wolf, then depending on influence scores the wolves may be able to hop onto a villager and win a 4-4 tie.
This is how the votes stand currently.
Short Richard (4) Doctor Saul, Rob The Filch, Sir Percival, Widow Edith
Half-Nose Harry (3) Young Will, Short Richard, Know-Nothing Jon
Rob The Filch (1) Fat Rose
Fat Rose (1) Half-Nose Harry
I know I am a villager, and I'm still working on the assumption that Will is as well. That leaves three villagers left. So I can know that there is at least one wolf sitting on Richard. Given that I do not think the wolves would want to bus him when they could just win, this makes me even less likely to want to vote for him today. Apparently my Rose vote isn't going to get traction, which makes me believe in it more at this point.
You realized that it had traction right? Yes that traction was lost, but pretty much because they had to move away, not because they didn't want to lynch me.
Quote:I will be leaving shortly on a trip, and will be traveling over deadline. I'll have access via phone so I can watch and consolidate onto someone, but as I've said I really don't like the Short Richard, and he is the only target other than myself with more then one vote, so I am leaving my vote on Rose for the time being.
Who else, apart from me is in the wolf-camp in your opinion Harry? There should be 4 wolves and you don't believe it is Richard, you don't believe it is Will, you don't believe it is yourself I would assume. That leaves Rob (tried to lynch me), Saul (tried to lynch me), Percival, Edith and Jon. So, your theory is that those 3 are all wolves together with me and that's why your vote on me didn't gain traction?
