WW 34--The Slugfest!

[zakalwe]

If he's gonna fake a role, why do it after the night? If anyone visited him last night, he would be instantly caught and lynched.

Yes, but that's also the only risk of being caught in a lie. Apart from that, his role is completely unconfirmable, as far as I can see. His faction could also somehow be sitting on the knowledge that nobody visited him.

I also don't agree that the role is weird or out of place in this game.

I agree that it's a plausible role (although many details remain to be filled out). But I don't think the way he played it is plausible for a townie.

Bob

[Gazglum]

BaII, are you around yet? What are your thoughts on the night?

Do you still think Jowy looks the scummiest?

[Jkaen]

If he's gonna fake a role, why do it after the night? If anyone visited him last night, he would be instantly caught and lynched. I also don't agree that the role is weird or out of place in this game.
It's worth pointing out that he could still be scum even if the role is real.

Note he claimed after brick posted he was informed he was visited in the night, that infers you get told if you were visited, hence bob knows he wasn't

[Jowy]

If he's gonna fake a role, why do it after the night? If anyone visited him last night, he would be instantly caught and lynched. I also don't agree that the role is weird or out of place in this game.
It's worth pointing out that he could still be scum even if the role is real.

Note he claimed after brick posted he was informed he was visited in the night, that infers you get told if you were visited, hence bob knows he wasn't

Good point. Bob

[Jowy]

Bob should full claim.

[Gazglum]

So the Goreripper votes are just against his style of playing.
Rowain is the standard style Rowain
Lewwyn is up there party due to my joke vote so that doesn't count
Brick and Q i have no big feelings on right now.
I will switch my vote to Qgqqqqq as the best of a short bunch
(basically i still have no idea hence how little i have spoken)

This was a pretty weak way to go out yesterday, Jkaen. Can you give any more reasoning for why you went with Q?

[Jowy]

We can probably win by mass claiming Day 3 or Day 4. Keep that in mind when we get there.

[novice]

If he's gonna fake a role, why do it after the night? If anyone visited him last night, he would be instantly caught and lynched. I also don't agree that the role is weird or out of place in this game.
It's worth pointing out that he could still be scum even if the role is real.

Note he claimed after brick posted he was informed he was visited in the night, that infers you get told if you were visited, hence bob knows he wasn't

Well, I don't know about this, just because one player was informed about one particular visit I wouldn't extrapolate that to a general rule. I don't think Bob would feel certain about not being visited on that basis alone.

@Gaz: Jkaen wasn't guiding me but by the time I had decided to vote Bob he had already summed up the reasoning nicely.

[Jkaen]

So the Goreripper votes are just against his style of playing.
Rowain is the standard style Rowain
Lewwyn is up there party due to my joke vote so that doesn't count
Brick and Q i have no big feelings on right now.
I will switch my vote to Qgqqqqq as the best of a short bunch
(basically i still have no idea hence how little i have spoken)

This was a pretty weak way to go out yesterday, Jkaen. Can you give any more reasoning for why you went with Q?

Nope.

Had no strong reads, at the time Qg seemed as good a vote as anybody else who seemed possible to lynch. Wasn't around for the last minute bob surge of votes and as I said I thought Rowain was just being the same old cantankerous Rowain

[zakalwe]

Agree w/novice. On the other hand, if Bob is scum then the kind of visit he feared most was probably from an investigator (or a vig), anyway. So even if he didn't know for sure, it could simply be a calculated risk, feeling there is little to lose. If anybody had visited him, the game might be up, anyway.