WW38: The Story of the Stories

[Bobchillingworth]

If you don't even think I'm scum, why would you want me to reveal my first power? Just on principle?

[Shadeun]

If you don't even think I'm scum, why would you want me to reveal my first power? Just on principle?

I'm still not sure. What possible ability would you have that you'd hold back now? Probably, with a captain-like name maybe you can change lynch votes at the last minute? Why keep hiding something if you so annoyed with how this is the "worst town ever".

I want to get something out there we can discuss. Maybe you guys just happy to sit on me all day?

Lets get everyone to vote, then we can all make some decisions.

Molach: your response to role name comments is weak... "My role-name stands out too and will get me lynched before too long - once the sensibles who understand that Sk-Molach might have called himself "Innocent Preserver of Life" are killed off"

[pindicator]

I want to say that Ichabod claimed after Jowy made his statements but I really need to look. And i'm settling down to homework. (Side note: Best part about group assignments? Group partners that never show up!)

I don't see how Goreripper gets a pass for nailing novice when that could just be a SK move to gain village cred. Novice was clearly going down that day, most of us were on him and some were on zak.

I would be very careful about making cases based on roles. This is Brick's design, and what's Brick best known for? It's getting village to lynch all 3 night-kill immune drones because "there's no way village could have 3 identical roles". Clearly there isn't anything going on like that with identical roles, but I do wonder if he's tried to throw some meta traps out there. Or in other words, I'd much rather prefer to lynch people based on their actions and posts than try to guess Brick's set up designs.

[pindicator]

And Goreripper didn't fire until after zak had been shot by Mattimeo. So I think almost everyone had switched to novice then; point being, he probably seemed like a sure thing at that point.

[Mattimeo]

Also: Your rebuttals which often include personal attacks serve no purpose but to make others less want to play the game and like you in general. Maybe take that on board?

"That was stupid thing you did" != "You are stupid"

Maybe stop deliberately fabricating outrage in order to justify your votes against those people? You did it to me last game, and you're doing it to Rowain now.

On Lurkers & too many town killers. Thats a good point. I think its just ridiculour that Gringr + me + Matt (someone else??) all have kills (and 2 insta kills amongst that) and are all town. Seems very strange and unlikely that scum would be that weak against 13 town + SK as only 3 members. Maybe it was balanced with more scan roles around. Although town has a lot of jailing/switching/chaos so perhaps Brick anticipated that kills would be poorly executed. But goreripper gets a pass because he nailed novice.

To my above post: Goreripper gets huge town points because it is unlikely for him to have a day kill AND then night kill as SK and certainly wouldnt kill teammate 2 of 3 if he was scum.

From that perspective, me agreeing there is too much villager killing power and then clearing/agreeing matt and goreripper are town probably ties my own noose - but whatever. You'll see your mistake in the end and at least I'm publicly trying to figure this out - even if im doing a poor job of it (I will get better in the future!)

You're also basing all of that on an incredibly flawed premise.

Goreripper claimed single use scan + role copy.
He only had a kill because he scanned me.

why would you want me to reveal my first power? Just on principle?

Yes.

Bobchillingworth

[Rowain]

Maybe stop deliberately fabricating outrage in order to justify your votes against those people? You did it to me last game, and you're doing it to Rowain now.

That is a clear scum-thing todo.

More:

I think Rowain fails to say anything, suggested the no lynch and comes up with no result for his abilities time and time again.

That is an complete lie. I have provided 2 results out of 3 attempts. So people please see that Shadeun is lying and making wrong accusations and please lynch him.

And that

The problem is Gordian. The solution is obvious! Shadeun! Slice at the Krill or Meiz ends of the knot!

Might be one killer talking to the 2nd whom to target.

[Molach]

Still 2 hours before beer/whiskey...

About role-names, mine does stand out. Everyone else has claimed to have the word "innocent" written out before role.
One of these claims are false, one of you lied and added the word to role. I do not think it was one of the 2 first (who was that btw..they should be cleared).
I claimed late enough that the pattern was starting to show. So yes, I would definately have done like the scum did and claim something in line with the norm.
---
I do not believe that Fenn would see the 'innocent' bit of the role, so Fenn getting killed probably means that the killer has lied about his power too, not just the innocent bit.

[Shadeun]

What results have you contributed Rowain? Explain the 2/3?

Molach: good point about the first 2 people claiming innocent at the front. However, Zak and Lew were both killed before anyone claimed. The closest was Gringr (after zak before lew) with "I am nothing but an innocent barbarian"

Anyway: Brick, please mod kill me. I am enjoying your game and you have set it up exceptionally well but I think that these guys can't get past me and I wont live to see the end game. Lets speed things up!

[AdrienIer]

Bob having a 1-shot governor power would make sense. Shadeun don't die just yet...

[AdrienIer]

I do not believe that Fenn would see the 'innocent' bit of the role, so Fenn getting killed probably means that the killer has lied about his power too, not just the innocent bit.

I switched Fenn and myself last night, and according to Pindicator he made sure it worked, so I was the intended target