Posts: 13,563
Threads: 49
Joined: Oct 2009
Some thoughts in case I kick the bucket:
I really don't think Zakalwe is the best lynch on day 3. Jabbz, for the record I had the exact same holes in my knowledge of the Greek Mythos. To assume that Zak cannot possibly have such holes, and use that as an argument for his guilt, is an error. (Remember the pantheon controversy? Jabbz vs. Rowain vs. Mattimeo, all villagers.)
If not because of, then at least Zak can be scum in spite of his lack of knowledge. But rereading day 1 it's difficult to believe, he bussed BRick really hard in that case.
Likewise MJW's not-meta-after-all read on AdrienIer is questionable, but just like Zak he must have bussed BRick really hard as scum. I did say I believe AdrienIer's vanilla claim though, it fits very well. But his actions in this game have benefitted scum and not town. So AdrienIer is suspect number one.
Oh by the way MJW made it 3.1 torture votes for BRick and Zak made it 4(.1), so as fas as they knew they both hammered BRick for torture.
Suspect number two is Marcus Aurelius. We'll see if his actions on N2 help town. He jumped right into the game with a suspiciously good instinct to lynch BRick, without much elaboration though, in what must have been a confusing game situation. Since then his ability to scumhunt has been unconvincing - why?
Maybe he just makes a good job of acting the hapless conspiracy theorist. He provided a reason for his BRick vote which was demonstrably a fabrication.
Jabbz is not on my suspect list, because Serdoa told me that Jabbz is a hero and not that he was a hero. But OK, I suppose he could be a godfather who was stripped of his powers? Seems very far-fetched. To be clear, Serdoa didn't tell me anything about any side effects from the torture.
I looked at the game thread again, and everytime I read AdrienIer he just feels like town. So I guess Marcus Aurelius is my preferred lynch. But of course we've never seen AdrienIer as scum, and he fooled me when he was a Serial Killer.
I have to run.
Trading Rowain for Lewwyn seems like a good deal for town, maybe less so for the remaining scum who lost his scum buddy.
