Okay, actually, Fenn makes some good points in this post here, although he remains pretty non-committal about all of it aside from jumping on my wagon.
A lot of hedging from Fenn here, but I agree with the gist of his assessment of novice. Definitely skating by. He never explained why he felt that MAYBE (hedging) I was sending out WW42 "too scum to be scum" vibes. Please elucidate, my friend, and you can help me avoid an un-earned lynch! And then re: Lewwyn, novice said,
OK, help me out. How am I misreading his alignment and post contents? Plz hlp.
I agree with this Fenn observation here:
Yes, I seem to recall Zak (if my memory is correct) hounding Winston last game over a very similar thing: failing to be telepathic and specifically deny playing SK before anyone had even asked...as if, any time someone mentions an SK role, you have to immediately make the sign of the cross and mutter "may the devil take the SKs" under your breath to avoid suspicion of being an SK.
Fenn makes a good point against Dp101. I must have missed that on my first pass-through. First of all, it doesn't make sense to order your choices as town-mafia-town because town/mafia is clearly the most important consideration and town-town-mafia makes much more sense (I've been over this with regards to another player already). Second, it's a good point that hider at least gives you the option of using a night power, whereas the odds of mafia lover being able to do anything are low (and in the case that you do have a lover pair, it gets very tricky). I could see mafia lover being the lesser discarded mafia role that Dp101 didn't want (where he wanted to make sure to at least get some sort of mafia role).
I know that earlier I said that Dp101 had town leanings for me, but now Dp101 is officially on my suspicion list.
Quote:Dunno about novice. Feels like he's been skating by since the Psilly wagon picked up speed. Perhaps that's uncharitable.
A lot of hedging from Fenn here, but I agree with the gist of his assessment of novice. Definitely skating by. He never explained why he felt that MAYBE (hedging) I was sending out WW42 "too scum to be scum" vibes. Please elucidate, my friend, and you can help me avoid an un-earned lynch! And then re: Lewwyn, novice said,
Quote:Misreading not only his alignment but the contents of his posts in general. My comment was meant to encourage you to take a second look at your interactions with Lewwyn, and I felt that as town you should be able to see where you're misreading him. Instead you're just trying to whip up more support for lynching him, without looking back.
OK, help me out. How am I misreading his alignment and post contents? Plz hlp.
I agree with this Fenn observation here:
Quote:This comment from Adrien about Meiz I don't like. It's as if he's basing his suspicion of Meiz off of him not specifically denying wanting to play SK. That's a flimsy meta argument if I ever saw one.
Yes, I seem to recall Zak (if my memory is correct) hounding Winston last game over a very similar thing: failing to be telepathic and specifically deny playing SK before anyone had even asked...as if, any time someone mentions an SK role, you have to immediately make the sign of the cross and mutter "may the devil take the SKs" under your breath to avoid suspicion of being an SK.
Fenn makes a good point against Dp101. I must have missed that on my first pass-through. First of all, it doesn't make sense to order your choices as town-mafia-town because town/mafia is clearly the most important consideration and town-town-mafia makes much more sense (I've been over this with regards to another player already). Second, it's a good point that hider at least gives you the option of using a night power, whereas the odds of mafia lover being able to do anything are low (and in the case that you do have a lover pair, it gets very tricky). I could see mafia lover being the lesser discarded mafia role that Dp101 didn't want (where he wanted to make sure to at least get some sort of mafia role).
I know that earlier I said that Dp101 had town leanings for me, but now Dp101 is officially on my suspicion list.
