WW 44: Battlestar Galactica

[Dp101]

So Dp101, where would your vote gone had you felt safe to move it?

Maybe you. Actually, it could have gone on anyone. You and Lew have seemed kinda weird/mildly suspicious, Novice I am bad at reading and thus don't trust my own town read on, and the dirt cast on Gaz by Lew makes him look slightly less clear. Really the only one I probably wouldn't have voted would have been Winston.

Anyone else think that this was scum Jabbz looking for who they should/shouldn't NK? I did at the time, and thought I would try as an experiment to deliberately only name one person as solid town to see if they would get NK'd. Originally I was going to vote Jabbz afterwards, but now I think that's a stupid idea and any mafia reading the thread might have decided based on this. Am I being paranoid, or does this sequence between us implicate Jabbz as part of the NK? I've thought myself in circles at this point and cannot decide.

This question was in direct response to :

Well, sorry about that. As I said, I was having second thoughts at the end, but at that stage switching off might have meant my death, so I had no option other than to continue voting you. Hopefully the doctor pulls through, otherwise we are looking at a D2 lylo.

I think it's fair to ask who you would have voted for, when you are using self preservation to justify lynching a townie. Not asking that question would have allowed you to slide through without having to justify your vote, or put you on record for us to examine today. Further, if you were night killed, we needed information to work with, something Winston provided us with. Moving on to that next.

What Jabbz said, and this is obvious. I really disliked Dp's post there, it feels like a bridge too far in terms of outlandish theories. I got the sudden feeling that Dp is just emulating his own town style.

You are probably right as to it being obvious, I was kinda panicked when I made the post at the prospect of lylo and was just looking for anything that might help lynch mafia. I disagree that it is just emulation, you yourself said earlier that I often jump at minor things and call people mafia over them, so I don't think this is out of character.

[Gazglum]

We should mass claim today, right? Time to get going?
Lewwyn - Dp - Jabbz - Gazglum - Novice is my suggested claim order.

It almost seems too cruel, i suspect this would be gg, partly because of bad luck on scum kills. But i am happy with that order.

[Jabbz]

We should mass claim today, right? Time to get going?
Lewwyn - Dp - Jabbz - Gazglum - Novice is my suggested claim order.

I'm down with that.

[Dp101]

I kinda want to wait with claiming unless we have nothing else to go on, given that if we do reveal we lose the cop 100% of the time the next day, and I think getting 2 scans out of them should be the goal ideally. If everyone else wants to though, I will do it.

[Gazglum]

Lol

[Jabbz]

I kinda want to wait with claiming unless we have nothing else to go on, given that if we do reveal we lose the cop 100% of the time the next day, and I think getting 2 scans out of them should be the goal ideally. If everyone else wants to though, I will do it.

A: If we don't lynch scum tonight we lose, so there will be no second scan.
B: We still have a Doctor as well as a Cop to deal with. We're going to lose someone tonight almost no matter what, assuming we make it there. Then it just becomes a question of whether or Dr. can outguess the surviving scum.
C: This post comes across really bad man.

[Dp101]

I understand that there is no second scan if we don't lynch mafia. What I was saying was that I would prefer we lynch mafia without having to claim, so that we are in a better position to win tomorrow. However, given the strength of your reaction towards me, there will probably be little support for my ideas, so I will fall in line.

[Jabbz]

Claiming increases the likelihood of snagging scum. We know from Qg there is only one doctor, one cop, 2 scum (including 1 roleblocker) and the rest (3) were vt. Since we've lost 2vt, there is only one left. That means if two people claim any role, one of them is lying. That helps us narrow the field quite well IMO, something your posts seem to be disinterested in.

[Gazglum]

I'm going to bed. I'm actually kind of against claiming, now. I feel scum got really bad luck in flipping two vanilla towns, and claiming is too harsh on them. But if we want it, I will certainly participate.

[Jabbz]

So you're against claiming, because scum might lose?? Even if we manage to catch scum tonight, you know we are still lylo again tomorrow right?