As a French person I feel like it's my duty to explain strikes to you. - AdrienIer

Create an account  

 
RB Pitboss #2 [SPOILERS] - Speaker and Sullla

Yes, I saw it.

"There is no wealth like knowledge. No poverty like ignorance."
Reply

Speaker Wrote:Yes, I saw it.

lol

Darrell
Reply

So - Speaker saw what athlete posted accidentally in the Email thread earlier today. (I was teaching at the time, had no idea what was going on until it was over. Good thing, because it avoids any possible conflict between my role in this game and role as a moderator on these forums.) Naturally we can and will make use of this information, which had some very interesting tidbits:

athlete Wrote:Well, so here I am with an update. Warning this is just a wall of text.

So I ignored my intuition and convinced myself that India wasn't going to take Greece out (I was thinking this around T148 or so). Along with the Inca getting Feudalism, Rome and my attack on the Inca was particularly foolish. Especially mine. I completely failed to make any progress, when I should have atleast taken 2 cities.

Now, Greece is gone and India is on my very weak border, refusing to renew our NAP. Now if I represent some reasonable strength, I don't think they'll attack, they'll just be content I've whipped my cities. But I'm also at war with the Inca. Or am I [Image: shhh.gif]!!!

I had a long chat with Slaze last night and we're going to try and take India back down a notch. We'll remain at war in game and but not march against each other. This free's up my units to defend my western border (and his to attack Rome [Image: frown.gif]). Then he'll supposedly help me to attack India a bit later. There are definitely some details to be cleared up but if I was to stand any chance I needed my current army available to clear India out of my lands, or atleast keep them at bay.

I'll try and post some more later (answer any questions as needed) but that's the basics of it for now.

Athlete

Well, well, well. I definitely enjoy that first paragraph, cataloging the litany of mistakes made by the Ottomans over the past dozen turns. Indeed, it wasn't exactly the greatest series of events from Kathlete's perspective. And the second paragraph gives us insight into what they are thinking with regards to our team, neat.

But it's that third paragraph that of course has the most useful stuff. Seems like slaze is trying to maneuver on both sides of the current alliance structure, eh? I see three different possibilities here:

- slaze is playing us, and actually working with Kathlete.
- slaze is playing Kathlete, and actually working with us.
- slaze is playing both sides against each other, and will do whatever favors him the most.

#3 seems like the real story to me. Can't really blame him too much for it either, although it's definitely irritating to us after the emails asking for help he sent our way. Even if slaze would turn on us, he couldn't do too much - at least not immediately. Given enough time, it could be a problem.

In the meantime, Speaker had the clever idea to send out a group email to our alliance with a cut-and-paste of the accidental message:

Quote:Dear plako and Broker of Korea, Dantski of Romali, and slaze of IKZ,

Hey, you may have seen that Kathlete accidentally posted in the email thread today. Speaker saw the message before it was deleted, and we are forwarding it to all of you:

[paste text]

slaze, care to explain what's going on to the rest of us?

Sullla
The Killer Angels

It will be "interesting" to see how slaze responds to that. He'll probably want to strangle Kathlete even more! lol

There's very little we can do on the current turn until the 12-hour window rolls through, so we'll just have to wait until tomorrow to play the turn for real. Speaker thought about going ahead and moving regardless (just ignoring the clearly-finished Jowy) but we decided that would be more trouble than it was worth. No desire to create any more e-drama or controversy.

PS I'm just going to try and head off any moralizing/finger shaking before it gets started. Are we bad people for taking advantage of Kathlete's accidental posting? I'm sure at least one person will make that argument. Obviously we disagree: you don't cheat or do anything against the rules when competing, but if someone else screws up and lets something slip, of course you make use of it! Part of playing the game, just like sending an email to the wrong address or typing a message to "All" instead of "Allies" in-game. Besides, it's pretty much impossible to pretend you haven't seen something once you have... not sure how we could be expected to do that.

This just goes to show why I always double-check to make sure I'm in the right thread before posting! [Image: biggrin.gif]
Follow Sullla: Website | YouTube | Livestream | Twitter | Discord
Reply

I find it's a lot harder to "unlearn" something or act like you didn't know it. Just a lot of second guessing. It's going to skew your actions one way or the other, or other people will at least have the perception. Might as well just roll with it and be open about it.
Suffer Game Sicko
Dodo Tier Player
Reply

Are you sure that athlete isn't trying to sow deception in the alliance with this message?
Reply

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9gEGIT9anJ0

Perhaps you could spin the conversation with Dracula into a taunting message at some point? I just wanted to see that.
Civilization IV sure runs like a dream on my new computer.
Reply

Sulla Wrote:PS I'm just going to try and head off any moralizing/finger shaking before it gets started. Are we bad people for taking advantage of Kathlete's accidental posting? I'm sure at least one person will make that argument. Obviously we disagree: you don't cheat or do anything against the rules when competing, but if someone else screws up and lets something slip, of course you make use of it! Part of playing the game, just like sending an email to the wrong address or typing a message to "All" instead of "Allies" in-game. Besides, it's pretty much impossible to pretend you haven't seen something once you have... not sure how we could be expected to do that.

Athlete made a mistake and you picked up on it. I don't hink it is that difficult to post in the correct forum? I don't see why you shouldn't use this information.

What are you going to do otherwise? There isn't an alternative! lol
Reply

You let Whosit fail, I don't see how this is any different.
Reply

Sullla I moved our units and left the cities and workers to you. Lots of diplo to do today.

"There is no wealth like knowledge. No poverty like ignorance."
Reply

His email in white, my response in red.

Slaze Wrote:The Zimmerman note didn't make it either. You didn't tell me about the NAP. We mentioned T170 several times. I'm not sure if we ever explicitly said we had a NAP with Kathlete until then?It was turn 163 or so, and your telling me to put on the brakes. I get only about a half day, but I get this in my head rolling, and I'm thinking up some ideas. Although later that day I finally became aware of your NAP, and now I gotta wait around 7 turns, in this wrecked economy? Is it our fault he planted 13 cities with no units and then had to slave himself into oblivion to protect them? He told us he was in EXPANSION MODE While india's over there, putting in seven more turns on me? I knew then that was always gonna be something. If it was misinformation or tying yourself up in these arrangements Tying ourselves up? We gave ourselves a 10-turn window to attack Jowy without Kathlete's interference. Did we know Greece would fold in 3 turns? We signed this NAP a month ago, the *only* agreement we have going, and must I remind IKZ that they were the ones who signed an original NAP with KAthlete that included a ridiculous 25 turn cooldown period? Talk about tying themselves up., I knew you were more into your own interests than mine (understandible but not my favorite arrangment). i thought you'd keep going with athlete, I thought that was the whole purpose of the thing. Jowy's land makes you a runaway if your going to stop and reconsolidate. Well, we did earn the land. It's not like we got it free. We were strong enough to take it. We shouldn't feel bad about that. No way I can compete with that, your getting like 20-25 modern age turns ahead of me with how we add up now. I needed you to fight athlete, and you failed me. He needed us to fight Athlete so we could help him catch up? That makes no sense. Why is that our responsibility? You lead me to believe things would be otherwise from a jowy-snatching war. So it's my responsibility to keep you from being a run-away civ. I could keep going but I best wanna sum it up like this: It's like oyzar said: I play to win. You made that very clear that you didn't give a damn about anything but yourself when you refused to open borders with us during our 1v5 gangbang, and wrote in all caps that you weren't going to do jack shit because you were in EXPANSION MODE. We have at least forced Kathlete to be concerned with protecting a huge western border, have him expecting us to declare war on him on T170, which is the earliest our units could be ready to attack anyways, having made their way over from Greece.

I was gonna write you my first "lie" email tonight, and this is the stuff I come home to see. It's too bad, cause I was gonna put one hell of a surprise on you. Backstabbing is disgusting. But you seem to be quite proud of it. Within a day of demanding that we come over and attack Kathlete for you, you are plotting with him against us. I'm sure a grueling war between us and Kathlete would be extremely beneficial to you. Well a NAP with Kathlete until T200 would be extremely beneficial to us, but we turned that down multiple times.

KAthlete Wrote:Hello KA,

So obviously because of my gaff, you've been privy to information that
you really shouldn't have been. Sometimes I seriously believe you guys
have some well placed horseshoes. Anyways I guess that's neither here
nor there though I am disappointed you guys didn't fess up that you
had been fortunate enough to be spoiled. Maybe I don't understand
forum etiquette all the way, and I suppose I can't say for sure if I
would have come clean (at least not immediately) so moving along now.

Where does that leave us? Are you still sure you want to have a
potential war on your hands come the early T170's? I believe we have
an agreement where we wouldn't share each other's e-mails and what not
between 3rd parties. I think that should be ammended to include my
mishappened post. I don't feel you need to share that with anybody
else beyond Slaze and if you have I feel you should tell me who.

Athlete
The Rebel Alliance
This whole email reeks of him trying to make us feel guilty. My response can be summarized in two words: Piss off.

"There is no wealth like knowledge. No poverty like ignorance."
Reply



Forum Jump: