Assassin in the Palace 3 - The Return of the (ashamedly few) Dead Guys

[zakalwe]

way to cover your basis zak. so everyone alive could be the assassin?

Yeah. I gave a couple of innocent leans in that post, but it could be anyone. Except it's not me, and not you-know-who.

[Gazglum]

Sorry for ignoring you Brick. The die was cast and I didn't want to give you anything in case you were the assassin.

I like that Bigger, Ichabod, and Rowain have actual lynch preferences. I would like Rowain to stop dodging questions, though. And I wonder why he hasn't revenge voted for me at any point. Tasunke is lurking too much, but he has made a couple of tie-breaking votes that would be risky for the assassin. Conversely, I think Lewwyn has been sitting on the fence too much. Gazglum also seemed kind of noncommittal yesterday.

I'll go with Lewwyn, although Rowain remains a close second preference.

Wow, I head off last night with Brick doing just fine, and this morning his head was off. Things move fast in the palace.

My noncommittal-ness is largely a reflection of my time zone/sleeping pattern. I get up about half an hour after the lynch, which means that I'm sleeping through the all-important last eight hours - and yesterday I didn't feel that there was enough discussion before then for me to have much useful to add.

Looking at the somewhat reduced palace guard at the moment, I tend to agree with much of this analysis. I think Lewwyn and Tasunke have been flying under the radar up until now, and I'd like to hear more from them today. On the other hand, I was on slowcheetah Day 2 for a similar reason and now I have innocent blood on my hands, so I'll hold off voting for them yet.

I understand that loose lips sink ships, but I don’t like how Rowain is not even acknowledging that questions are coming his way.

Ichabod and Bigger I lean innocent towards – I’m not sure if it’s good play to publically discuss why, but if others want me to I can go into some more detail.

Zak, I really hope you’re one of the good guys, but I thought Bigger raised some good points. Right now you are my second suspect and I’m feeling open-minded today, but for now I think I’m going to stay on Rowain

[Lewwyn]

I thought Brick was innocent. I think Rowain is innocent. I think Ichabod is the assassin. I think Ichabod agreed with Rowain about Brick too quickly when he was on the block. He wanted to save himself. I think Zak is innocent. I think Bigger is innocent. I think Zak's comment that I am fence post sitting is ridonkulous.

[zakalwe]

Good post, Lewwyn. Ichabod, what's your retort?

[Rowain]

I think Ichabod agreed with Rowain about Brick too quickly when he was on the block. He wanted to save himself.

I think I agree with you here. Ichabod

[zakalwe]

Why were you so quick to vote for Q on day 1, Rowain?

[zakalwe]

Also, dead players are apparently posting about this game in the AITP2 lurker thread, so let's stay out of that one.

(I clicked on new posts in that thread, saw Brick saying something like "taking over this thread", and left.)

[Rowain]

Why were you so quick to vote for Q on day 1, Rowain?

Before my vote the standing was:

qgqqq (4) - gazglum, tasunke, Brick, Bigger
bigger - (2) Q, zak
Gazglum - slowcheetah
Rowain - Ichabod,
slowcheetah -- Rowain
zak - lewwyn

introducing a new candidate = useless. pushing Bigger to 3= stupid. To prevent somebody else doing that: Kill Qg and end the day.

[Gazglum]

Thanks for responding Rowain.

I was hoping to hear from Tasunke before reposting, but I have to log off now so I'll put my thoughts down. I hadn't been too suspicious of Ichabod before, but your post was interesting Lewwyn. Rereading yesterday, I do agree that the Brick wagon was unexpected, as I thought Brick didn't come across as guilty. The problem was that 4 other players clearly disagreed with me there, but I guess Ichabod was the one who benefitted the most.

Anyway, Zak and Rowain don't be seeming to get much traction and I'm willing to join the Ichabod wagon today.

[Bigger]

I would like to hear Ichabod respond, at least. Its too early to fall on your sword Ichabod.