WW48: Melllvar's Grand Competition!

[Rowain]

Rowain - my biggest crime this game is not quoting pindicator’s post but rather just @‘ing since I’m on mobile. I am sorry this is costing us so much time over nothing. In general I don’t find your ‘figure out complete groupings’ of scum style intuitive or helpful. I am glad it works for you. I get sometimes if X is scum then Y is unlikely to be or whatever, but otherwise I don’t view them as package deals.

ok .

[sunrise089]

Pindicator, 1613 right above - no dude, again you were defending Meiz here, saying Rowain wouldn’t make any sense. Just go re-read. What I’d expect town-pind to say is you misspoke and meant you probablistically from scum perspective COULD have been on Meiz and you corrected yourself in 1415.

[Meiz]

So.. I'm guessing your 1413 referred to an earlier protection on me? I can't recall if you've done that or not.

   


Night 2.  You don't read anything I write, do you?

I'm taking a shower.  If Meiz is pulling this as scum, I'll give that ultimatum now and say I won't play with him again.

I do read your posts but at this point I think my brain has stopped working.

[Gold Ergo Sum]

What is it with GES? Not thinking for himself but just voting along Rowain because he thinks that he is town. Lazy!

Lazy or not, Old Tea Man the only player Omar feels near certain is village, so I feel I can trust his reads are at least honest, even when wrong.  No one here is going to be right all the time.  I would prefer to double up a village voting bloc to try and reduce villain's options if we split up.

[Rowain]

Pindicator, 1613 right above - no dude, again you were defending Meiz here, saying Rowain wouldn’t make any sense. Just go re-read. What I’d expect town-pind to say is you misspoke and meant you probablistically from scum perspective COULD have been on Meiz and you corrected yourself in 1415.

@sunrise: HE does say scum knows I protected you  which is correct because pindi claimed he protected Meiz on night 2. He  doesn't say he protected Meiz during the last night.

[Kaiser]

So final town case word on Kaiser night ability lie is he was hoping wolves would think he was out of charges, not expecting they’d actually target Meiz. And that somehow he just confused himself that it would do some sort of partial protection when by timing that part was impossible. That where we are?

And case for town Meiz in that exchange is scum Meiz wouldn’t have risked the claim since town-Kaiser could say no one visited him?

And case against then both as scum is if both scum they’d never not coordinate and have Kaiser not breadcrumb? Unless as Gaspar says they just didn’t coordinate?

My only real problem with this is why Kaiser would subtly breadcrumb. If you want wolves to think you used up your ability why not make that really direct?

The wolves would have had all day to check my post and I assumed they do check EoD posts for breadcrumbing. Regarding this assumption, I believe bolding Meiz was not so subtle.

[Meiz]

Pindicator, 1613 right above - no dude, again you were defending Meiz here, saying Rowain wouldn’t make any sense. Just go re-read. What I’d expect town-pind to say is you misspoke and meant you probablistically from scum perspective COULD have been on Meiz and you corrected yourself in 1415.

@sunrise: HE does say scum knows I protected you  which is correct because pindi claimed he protected Meiz on night 2. He  doesn't say he protected Meiz during the last night.

Yes, this is what I now assume as well.

[Rowain]

What is it with GES? Not thinking for himself but just voting along Rowain because he thinks that he is town. Lazy!

Lazy or not, Old Tea Man the only player Omar feels near certain is village, so I feel I can trust his reads are at least honest, even when wrong.  No one here is going to be right all the time.  I would prefer to double up a village voting bloc to try and reduce villain's options if we split up.

Would you vote for yourself if I vote Omar?

[sunrise089]

I know I’m not Lewwyn the case driver, but right before deadline and crickets. I want to push Jabbz over his role, I think it’s a big slip, no interest. I want to push pind over his game-long errors and misstatements, crickets (or worse, blanket acceptance with no re-reads...maybe I’M the one wrong here but could someone bother going back to look lol). I want to hang Gaspar over these targets, several people said they’d be on Gaspar today, crickets.

I think you’re lynching the afk townie. And no I’m not going to move to high-contribution Meiz who I’ve liked all game to try to save Bob. If Meiz is a wolf then GG.

[Kaiser]

I dislike Omar's move here greatly hiding behind Rowain at this stage of the game is extremly bad as there will be only one further opportunity to act if we should not hit a wolf tonight.