novice Wrote:I find the "unit gifting to bypass NAP" thing pretty horrendous, but it's not up to the lurkers to interpret the rules and deals made by the players.
While we could argue if gifting units to war against someone you have a NAP is breaking it or not [imho, in RB1, some people were specifically 'writting' it in their NAP with also things like no giving OB to a 3rd party at war, etc ], I see no breaking of a NAP if you exchange your military units for workers (which is what is more or less the 'official' deal afair), settlers, settling rights, or anything else.
Of course, they can't really pretend they had no idea what Jowy will do with it, but should Spulla realise and question the gifting, imho ottoman could/should defend their gifting by saying it was a FAIR exchange for workers (of course we probably should NOT give this idea to Ottoman if they don't think about it themselves)