I'd call it weak. It doesn't specifically mention city gifting, and since it's buried in the thread (as opposed to part of the main rule post) it's not terribly reasonable to expect everyone to be intimately familiar with it.
It was indeed used in Serdoa's post, and at the time it worried me that it was the strongest argument available. Indeed, the more I think about it, the more I agree with Spullla that the harshness of the ruling was grossly out of line.
It was indeed used in Serdoa's post, and at the time it worried me that it was the strongest argument available. Indeed, the more I think about it, the more I agree with Spullla that the harshness of the ruling was grossly out of line.