WW14 - The Edge of Reason

[pindicator]

I think zak may be on to something with his waterbat questioning. We never did push waterbat for the way we voted day 2 to save injera, and day 3 voting doesn't look any better. I haven't kept my notes up to speed, so i'm trying to get day 4 together right now.

the bolded 'we' should be 'he'

[pindicator]

How could I forget about this from day 4

Obviously, no kill is a great result for the village! *Is someone going to claim responsibility today? Whoever protected should be able to clear the protectee, no?

Bigger, *I think pointing out the fact that people never voted for others known dead wolves is silly. *It's more likely at some point that wolves would have voted for other wolves for cover. *Not deciding votes, ofc.*

I've been restricted to iPhone posts since Sunday. *You could add that as a third post restriction as it was quite hard to respond. I lost a few posts too

This makes me uneasy waterbat. Why did you call for the person to reveal? Also, how did you know that Mattimeo targeted the wolf target and not the wolf doing the attack? Is this me wearing a tinfoil hat or was that a wolf slip?

No, I didn't call for the person to reveal. Was simply curious as to if someone was going to come forward. Also was curious who would be first to correct me that I only considered the doctor side and not the role-blocker side. Anyway - Matt's claim preempted that however. Seems like I can't win anything this game.

Actually, I went through and read the sequence later and you were not the first person to make the doctor-side assumption. So even with my tin foil hat, I have to go another direction.

Did I let you off too easy?

[Rowain]

Rowain, how long have you been a member of the illuminati?

[Twinkletoes89]

Thought:

Rowain = high suspect

Mattimeo try to jail someone - didn't jail him - as I get post restriction

Rowain could kill?

[novice]

Unless you find some amazing evidence out of nowhere, Rowain must be lynched.

I don't necessarily disagree, but I'd like to hear why you think that.

Novice - I think he is trying to set up mislynches. Hopping on lots of people then back off quickly

Ok - I didn't mean "why is he scummy", rather why MUST we lynch him today, like we're at LYLO or as if lynching another wolf is impossible. Sounded like you knew more than you let on. Was Rowain not being jailed tonight that extra bit of info?

Anyway, I don't like Waterbat's justification for voting Molach.

[Twinkletoes89]

Rowain clearly not jailed - he's restricted me. Not extra info.

Rowain = slippery = more dangerous than Waterbat to be kept alive!

[zakalwe]

What do you make of the way Rowain claimed his role, TT? I guess you disagree with my previous characterization that it was a selfless, pro-town act?

[Twinkletoes89]

Easy to dress up an act as pro-town. Doesn't mean it truly is.

He's a mislyncher, I don't trust him

[Rowain]

@TT My mistakes happen during the day yes. And I might have played a huge part in the Bigger mislynch but at least I didn't kill someone at night. Especially not someone who has just delivered a wolf. The same wolf you absolutly didn't want to vote for even if that could have meant your lynch. Isn't that a bit double standard what you do?

@novice what happened to: postrestrictions are a villager-sign ?

@waterbat, Sareln, JKaen (and zakalwe): What are your roles? And how did you use them?

[zakalwe]

Here's my logic for lynching Waterbat.

Nine players remain, and I assume two of those are wolves.

Pindicator, Novice and I have worked closely together to lynch three wolves (one vegetarian ). I think it's safe to assume we are all innocent.

Molach voted early for Injera on day 2, and explicitly said that he was leaving and his vote was locked. Would be a tricky vote to back out of.

Jkaen was Injera's target on day 2. Also, in Injera's defense post, there is a striking contrast between how he describes Jkaen and Slowcheetah, which makes me think Jkaen is innocent. Also read what he says about Molach while you're at it.

Twinkletoes was another apparent mislynch target on day 2, and was tied 5-5 with Injera at one point. Also accused by Slowcheetah on day 1.

That only leaves Sareln, Rowain, and Waterbat. Sareln and Rowain have been attacking each other on several occasions, so it seems unlikely that they are both wolves. Therefore, Waterbat must be a wolf.