Posts: 6,457
Threads: 134
Joined: Aug 2004
Cyneheard Wrote:I think it's a voteblocker ability? Tasunke can't vote today, and Selrahc said that's what he was doing. I assume that "read" was past tense, as in that's how he originally perceived it. Rowain commented on the ability earlier, so he's seen the claim. It puzzled me too, so I looked it up.
Posts: 3,140
Threads: 26
Joined: Feb 2009
Wow. Near consensus on Scooter? I'd been reading him as suspicious, but I was partially attributing it to natural resentment at his hounding me.
If you all are willing, I can definitely back a Scooter lynch. But I am worried about this broad consensus. Are the wolves hanging him out to dry to gain credibility, or are they laughing at a dogpile on a villager?
Rowain's ability is now much more useful. Abilities are a much more interesting thing than starting techs. I'm still not sure if anything incriminating will come up, and it could definitely be a wolf ability. But his play now makes sense to me, and I think he has played things pretty well all in all.
Posts: 6,457
Threads: 134
Joined: Aug 2004
Mardoc Wrote:Huh, I thought that Tasunke was the obvious target and scooter was standing right behind him but would be the one hard to persuade the village about. If you guys would rather jump straight to scooter, instead of using Tasunke to gather that last bit of evidence on him, I'm fine with that.
Frankly I think they're both wolves, they both tried to defend Ichabod (with, admittedly, different levels of finesse), and they've both defended each other. And they've both been suspicious all game.
My mind had jumped to wolf #4, but I'm afraid I see at least three people who it could be. Tasunke is so befuddled that I find it hard to figure out if he's a bad villager or a bad wolf. He's been precious little use to the town, and has attracted way too much attention and suspicion. Even if he's a newbie, I think he'd have received better advice from the wolf team about how to post in general. Then again, they may have told him to knock himself out with the newbie act. He should definitely be looked into, but I don't think he's an auto lynch yet.
Selrahc, notice that the initial posts after day change were in other directions. MJW suggested that today would be a two horse race between Tasunke and yourself. The suspicions against scooter are fronted by mostly cleared villagers. I do think we should keep discussing him during the day, and I still wish to know what scooter's ability is.
Posts: 3,140
Threads: 26
Joined: Feb 2009
Quote:The suspicions against scooter are fronted by mostly cleared villagers
Yes. And I think Novice's argument is a really solid one. Particularly since I'd bet Ichabod thought he could kill novice if he ever needed to before the "archives" were opened to scrutiny.
Consensus just always makes me a little leery in Werewolf games.
Posts: 8,244
Threads: 30
Joined: Jun 2004
Tally
9v: scooter ( Gaspar Catwalk Lewwyn novice slowcheetah Rowain Mardoc Cyneheard Selrahc )
1v: Gaspar ( MJW )
Not voted: 3 ( Sareln, scooter, Tasunke(can't vote))
History
Posts: 8,244
Threads: 30
Joined: Jun 2004
@catwlk & Cyneheard
yes pasttense was meant
@Selrahc sometimes such consensual votes do hit a wolf
Posts: 4,471
Threads: 65
Joined: Feb 2006
Rowain Wrote:9v: scooter ( Gaspar Catwalk Lewwyn novice slowcheetah Rowain Mardoc Cyneheard Selrahc )
1v: Gaspar ( MJW )
Not voted: 3 ( Sareln, scooter, Tasunke(can't vote))
Confirmed as correct
Posts: 6,457
Threads: 134
Joined: Aug 2004
A landslide lynch makes sense when a wolf has been abandoned. I think it's likely that the wolves consider the evidence strong enough to not warrant any rescue attempts. On the other hand, the wolves would also step on each other's tails in eagerness to hang villager scooter.
I do think we should re-examine the evidence during the day to make absolutely certain that scooter is the best option. Specifically, I think we should focus on evidence coming from scooter rather than evidence coming from Ichabod. While unlikely, Ichabod may have set up scooter to hang. We will probably discover additional connections when reviewing the evidence.
Posts: 15,387
Threads: 112
Joined: Apr 2007
Holy crap you guys are morons. Today's a busy day and I don't really have time to defend myself so knock yourself out and lynch me. Maybe I'll have time tomorrow.
FYI - theres no way on earth I would've drawn that much attention to myself as a werewolf if I saw Ichabod going down like that. Give me some credit. I may suck at villager but I know how to play werewolf and play it well.
Posts: 4,421
Threads: 53
Joined: Sep 2011
Cyneheard Wrote:I think it's a voteblocker ability? Tasunke can't vote today, and Selrahc said that's what he was doing.
Well my power had to do with having an extra vote, and if Selrahc is a role blocker wolf, since he knows my power it would 'look' like it was just a vote-blocking ability.
(at least I think thats how it would work, even though I already used my power)
If it was just a vote-blocker ability however, I suppose he assumed that it was going to be a two horse race between Selrahc and myself. An assumption that Mardoc also made early into the day ...
I do think its possible that Selrahc is a role blocker (whichever alignment) due to the nature of my power and what Rowain read about him.
And I still think its possible that Selrahc is a wolf.
|
