WW25 - Game Thread

[uberfish]

Yeah because pushing a mislynch = scum right, and town would never do such a thing?

[Qgqqqqq]

No, because pushing a meta-based mislynch against a strong town (who, btw, was our only remaining vigilante) at a time when he's known to be unable to post and while blissfully ignoring that ones only other scum candidate is voting with, is ever so slightly a scum tell.

[uberfish]

What other scum candidate exactly... I already shot zak and lewwyn was in the clear for being roleblocked

And I didn't know he was town FFS

[Qgqqqqq]

Jkaen, who was clearly your other candidate as you are now voting him and had no suspicion on jowy.
That was a more personal read - I thought he was strongly town before that.

[uberfish]

If he was such a strong town read why didn't you oppose the lynch more vocally, or push strongly for a different lynch?

And why should Jkaen voting for brick cause me to reconsider, if I suspected jkaen less than brick?

[Lewwyn]

No, because pushing a meta-based mislynch against a strong town (who, btw, was our only remaining vigilante) at a time when he's known to be unable to post and while blissfully ignoring that ones only other scum candidate is voting with, is ever so slightly a scum tell.

Ever so slightly??? Feels like you're struggling here Q.

[Lewwyn]

I'm oddly sad about Jowy's death as he was the one player I could say 100% I believed villager. Even if he was being annoying with his posting.

[Mattimeo]

I'll give you 1 guess who I think the last scum is.

Ever so slightly??? Feels like you're struggling here Q.

That's not who I would have guessed

[Mattimeo]

I really don't like the way Jkaen attempted to set up an uber lynch as a natural follow-up to BRick flipping town. Almost like he knew how BRick was going to flip, and was looking for an easy 2-for-1 deal.

Hmm ok, I cant see you and him being vigilanties, so I think I am at the point now where I am happy to lynch any 3 of the claimed vig people (Lewwyn, uberfish, brick)

Trying to get my head round the different interactions here.

If uber is telling the truth (village) then brick pretty much has to be scum
If uber is lying (scum) then it seems a bid to tip the balance of the lynches and I would say brick is village

Hence lynch one of them we can be pretty confident of the other.

Lynch Lewwyn I dont think it tells us much, and I have myself convinced we are facing 2 wolves still, so I need to go for one of the first two I think.

I find both the claimed roles a bit unbelievable, but uberfish has been more useful in thread, so for now

Brick

feeling very twitchy at the lack of movement here and worried we should be on uberfish here not brick, but i dont think we can pull off a last minute zak swing here.

Note if brick turns up villlage my vote tomorrow is locked onto uber

darn it i knew that went to easy, just didnt have the confidence to switch with lewwyns vote sitting on me. Uberfish tomorrow no questions

[Mattimeo]

Also interesting to note that Jowy got killed the night he came out with this:

It's been almost scary how close my thinking has been with Uberfish all game. We are playing the exact same game, and I'm a villager. Do you understand why I can't lynch him? I would be a hypocrite. I would lynch someone for playing the same game I've played myself. There is a high chance that he is the wolf. He got two villagers killed who couldn't defend themselves. But I agreed with him all the way, and I'm a villager. That's why I can't and will not put a vote against Uberfish in this game. I hope you won't judge me for this.