(February 5th, 2015, 07:13)zakalwe Wrote: TT, how did you know Ichabod is a SK?
I didn't til he confessed, I just saw him visit AdrienIer and likely kill him.
"You want to take my city of Troll%ng? Go ahead and try."
|
WW35: Not Another TPS Report [Game Thread]
|
|
I didn't til he confessed, I just saw him visit AdrienIer and likely kill him. (February 5th, 2015, 07:35)Meiz Wrote: I also think Jkaen's more on the town side due to his more recent posts. Not too sure on Molach. His posts are ok, his activity levels are scummy compared to the town game I remember from him. Yeah, maybe I'm cutting him too much slack. He did discard a town card which probably also works in his favor since he's had several traumatic games as scum. (February 5th, 2015, 07:37)Twinkletoes89 Wrote:(February 5th, 2015, 07:13)zakalwe Wrote: TT, how did you know Ichabod is a SK? Likely kill him? What else would he be doing? He was the only visitor, wasn't he? Why don't you tell us the real answer, instead? Go out with style, like Ichabod.
If you know what I mean.
Phone.
I havent been in the line of fire yet, so no call for the rabid-rodent-Im -town defense you might remember. This game will apparently be decided on meta and good night-actions so not that important about reads on people...except on the dtay-bob-tt day, where I just went with 'feel' based on other's cases because busy. Looks like I might have got it right, still. But case on jabbz very wrong. I think Azarius, TT, Ichabod is a good kill order. And if one more scum it will be me, jkaen, fenn and Zak on the line in the end. Got time still to figure out that mess. The above is most likely scenario to me, I do realize that there is risk and that we might be near lylo if we somehow messed up terribly. But if azarius really is town with a genuine read unable to post he should have been replaced, as it will be devastating for village. Okay with a loss due to that.
Played: FFH PBEM XXVI (Rhoanna) FFH PBEM XXV (Shekinah) FFH PBEM XXX (Flauros) Pitboss 11 (Kublai Rome)
Playing:Pitboss 18 (Ghengis Portugal) PBEM 60 - AI start (Napoleon Inca)
Battery failing, probably not able to post more.
Vote locked. Have fun
Played: FFH PBEM XXVI (Rhoanna) FFH PBEM XXV (Shekinah) FFH PBEM XXX (Flauros) Pitboss 11 (Kublai Rome)
Playing:Pitboss 18 (Ghengis Portugal) PBEM 60 - AI start (Napoleon Inca)
Okay, awake and reread the thread partially.
zakalwe I think is town, he has been active and scumhunting since Day 1, his points have been good too. I don't associate that level of activity with scum. Jkaen didn't make much of an impression early on aside from pushing Jowy, but has improved as the game went on and his posts this day feel towny. I still don't like his post about me being SK, (don't see how I'm more likely than TT or even Qg at this point) but overall leaning town. Molach has flown under the radar most of the game, hasn't contributed much even today - on balance I think he is most likely to be scum out of these three (I of course am obvtown!) If Qg is telling the truth (and he probably is), then the Mafia doesn't have a 1-Shot Dayvig. I say this because we know almost certainly of the presence of a Strongman, and Q being blocked last night suggests a Mafia Roleblocker. I doubt there are three Mafia remaining in addition to possible 2 SKs so mafia won't be able to autowin on a 3/4 person endgame. Given that I think our best option now is to lynch Ichabod and hope our tracker roles catch one of us four in the act, then lynch TT tomorrow. Ichabod you played well but I think this is the end for you. 
I think it's worth noting, that there are only 3 votes not on Ichabod. I trust me, and I think most of town trust me. Molach and Fenn are on Azarius. Everyone else is on Ichabod.
Everyone else is on Ichabod. Since Ichabod's reveal there has been very limited opposition to his death. That means scum is very happy with our choice. Azarius is an easy target, there has been almost no defense of him by anyone. To me this implies scum is ok with him being lynched. TT on the other hand god a good amount of defense. A lot of justification went into why he shouldn't be lynched. I love Ichabod's play. I think not killing him gives us a chance to get more information than we would if we kill him, and information, over the next day or two, is what is going to allow us to snatch victory after that horrible 4 death night we just suffered. I'm going to continue to vote TT. He has been looking like scum since early day 2. His boisterous defense all day today looks scummy as hell. His claim, when he had no other choice, was poorly presented. When opposed by Jowy, he dug in, rather than listen to logic of any kind. His arguments were bad. The guy looks like about 15 kinds of scum. I reiterate my argument that we kill TT. We can take a risk with Ich. I think he is being honest about helping us, worst case scenario he dies tomorrow, and we have a lot more information. Locking in my vote here, see you guys in 40 minutes.
Jailkeeper was alive for both nights Qg was blocked. Normally I wouldn't expect a jailkeeper to target town cop, it neutralizes a strong role, but if Q had actually requested a jailkeeper to protect one of the cops then it's possible that Bob followed that idea.
Good point. Although the idea of there being a Mafia Strongman was out there on Day 2 iiirc.
Still though Bob's jailing would go through even if he is killed, so it doesn't prove that we have a Mafia roleblocker after all. In that case Mafia could have a Dayvig waiting in the wings. Might be better to lynch TT and take our chances with Ichabod after all... |
