WW48: Melllvar's Grand Competition!

[Bobchillingworth]

I don't remember doing that at all! I certainly don't think you're 100% confirmed town, though I believe the neighbor claim since I am like 90% sure sunrise is town! Half the time I forget you're even playing, and when I do recall you're the "D1 No Lynch" guy!


I went back and looked at my post (thankfully this was easy, since I don't have very many! My laziness is PAYING OFF, Jerry! I always knew it would!), and I forgot to list you alongside Meiz, Gaspar, sunrise, and novice as "lean town". My bad! Don't let it go to your head!


But also, good catch!

[Jabbz]

How should I?

It's quite a coincidence to talk about my requirement for proving my role, while me being robbed the ability.

So you think I'm scum? I mean yeah why not thats the reason I shot a very scummy player on N2 and announced it    . I have the feeling you are preemptive attacking.

BTW we have heard nothing from Gaspar and Bob concerning their roles.

I mean, this isn't exactly a good defense. Scum Tea Drinker would absolutely do that. He knows the player is scummy so people would understand why he would take the shot, and he knows the player is town. In one action he gets rid of a townie and increases his town cred, because any other town could see themselves doing the same thing.

I'm not saying this makes you scum in my eyes, but rather that it's not a clear cut as you make it seem.

[Alhambram]

I don't remember doing that at all!  I certainly don't think you're 100% confirmed town, though I believe the neighbor claim since I am like 90% sure sunrise is town!  Half the time I forget you're even playing, and when I do recall you're the "D1 No Lynch" guy!  


I went back and looked at my post (thankfully this was easy, since I don't have very many!  My laziness is PAYING OFF, Jerry!  I always knew it would!), and I forgot to list you alongside Meiz, Gaspar, sunrise, and novice as "lean town".  My bad!  Don't let it go to your head!  


But also, good catch!

If you think that Sunrise and I am clear due neighbors, then I have to warn you: we are neighbors but not friendly neighbors. So we can communicate with seperate quickthread but we don't know whether other neighbor is townie or scum.

By the way, I trust Sunrise based upon posts here and quicktopic, not because I am his neighbor.

[Bobchillingworth]

If you think that Sunrise and I am clear due neighbors, then I have to warn you: we are neighbors but not friendly neighbors. So we can communicate with seperate quickthread but we don't know whether other neighbor is townie or scum.

By the way, I trust Sunrise based upon posts here and quicktopic, not because I am his neighbor.

Fear not, George is tracking as to the nature of the neighbor role, and that you are not in fact a Mason.


Although, if you do have relevant information from your quicktopic to share, now's probably the time! Interested in sunrise's impressions from the same, as well!

[Jabbz]

Basically I don't see how scum gains advantage from stripping you. Sure you might get a good shot off, absolutely positive. But if you're wrong, you probably just lost town the game, whereas scum can come back from that. As a wolf, those are good odds in my book.

Jabbz, he said he was going to save it to the end, which is the right play for that ability. They couldn't safely kill him with me possibly protecting him. This makes a lot of sense actually.

What are your thoughts on Rowain's premise, Jabbz?

They don't have to kill him. That's my point. If he guesses wrong, town loses, if he guesses right, wolves live to fight another day. Leaving him active is a good play from a scum perspective IMO.

As to Rowain's statement before EOD about Meiz's abilities? It's risky (see above) but it makes a certain form of sense for the same reason. If he's accurate, we still have time to go after another player that day with Meiz as confirmed town. If he doesn't take the shot, and there is no reason scum or town meiz with that ability wouldn't, then the only answer is he is lying, and makes a clear wolf kill for that night. It's making the best sandwich we can out of a steaming pile of LYLO shit. I would argue it would be better to do it at midday, and set up a faux vote for who he should shoot then, gaining us more information, but it's not an unsound plan at its core, for the circumstances we would be in.

[Alhambram]

I need to reread Gaspars Posts more in weekend.
Bob post 1.072 personally interesting, also post 1107 from Lewwyn.

If you think that Sunrise and I am clear due neighbors, then I have to warn you: we are neighbors but not friendly neighbors. So we can communicate with seperate quickthread but we don't know whether other neighbor is townie or scum.

By the way, I trust Sunrise based upon posts here and quicktopic, not because I am his neighbor.

Fear not, George is tracking as to the nature of the neighbor role, and that you are not in fact a Mason.  


Although, if you do have relevant information from your quicktopic to share, now's probably the time!  Interested in sunrise's impressions from the same, as well!

Well about quicktopic: I did post my thoughts and most of them I already did post here: vote analysis at #970 and why I vote Lewwyn.
But Sunrise posts very little content in return, just 1 or 2 sentences often encouraging words. I am starting wondering now whether it is maybe better to stop posting there and have Sunrise and I post here alone and not at quicktopic anymore.
In fact I know no more about him then what you all know from reading his posts in this thread.
Only thing that Sunrise didn't state here I think is that he state that the best weapon of neighbors is mutually confirm our roles as insurance against role claims and maybe catch someone this way. But then Sunrise decides to reveal our roles at end of night 2 without asking me or it is okay to reveal it.
You can read that back at beginning of day 3.

[Meiz]

My humble view of the game:

Town unite!

Meiz
sunrise089 - Mr. PeanutButter
Gaspar - House
Gold Ergo Sum - Omar Little
Alhambram - Homer
Rowain - Uncle Iroh

Villains bevare!

Bobchillingworth - George Costanza
Jabbz - Allanon
pindicator Henchman 21 / Kaiser - Isaac

In the order of preference I see atm.

[Alhambram]

Seems that Sunrise is very cautions what to post in quicktopic, probably justified because we don't know each aligement.
Based at his day 1 posts I got good vibe from him, so at day 2 I became more active and sharing my thoughts.

[Alhambram]

But the problem is that we don't know extact neighbor setup. It might be townie-scum, but it might also be townie-townie setup. Brick is messing around with us.

[Alhambram]

But the problem is that we don't know extact neighbor setup. It might be townie-scum, but it might also be townie-townie setup. Brick is messing around with us.

That is essence why I did mention post 1107 from Lewwyn, there he comments about me that in case of town-scum setup, Sunrise is more likely townie and I more scum.

I did post because I was afraid that in case that wolves decided to nightkill Sunrise and he flips town. In that case wolves might use Lewwyn's post 1107 and Sunrise's flip to rally votes against me combined with Lewwyn declaration that we should lynch Gaspar and Alhambram in his last post.