Posts: 13,563
Threads: 49
Joined: Oct 2009
Selrahc: The obvious compromise for you to offer would be to lynch Cyneheard who everybody suspects anyway. If he's villager, your Gaspar theory gets strengthened. If Cyneheard's a wolf with unlimited roleblocks, the Gaspar theory is weakened.
I find it telling that you haven't suggested this even after I encouraged you to.
I have to run.
Posts: 3,140
Threads: 26
Joined: Feb 2009
novice Wrote:Selrahc: The obvious compromise for you to offer would be to lynch Cyneheard who everybody suspects anyway. If he's villager, your Gaspar theory gets strengthened. If Cyneheard's a wolf with unlimited roleblocks, the Gaspar theory is weakened.
I find it telling that you haven't suggested this even after I encouraged you to.
Are you saying that you're willing to lynch Cyneheard to test the theory?
Because it doesn't really sound like you are. I have very little hope that I will survive the day. I want my suspicions to be as crystal clear as possible.
However from my perspective, a Cyneheard lynch would be preferable to lynching me. If I thought it was plausible, I might go for it.
Posts: 12,510
Threads: 61
Joined: Oct 2010
Cyneheard
EitB 25 - Perpentach
Occasional mapmaker
Posts: 8,022
Threads: 37
Joined: Jan 2006
Catwalk Wrote:Last time you were this certain, we wasted a day hanging scooter. If you're a villager and Selrahc is villager, this looks pretty bad for the town.
Just for fun, what's the full case against Selrahc? And what's the full case against Cyneheard? Asking everybody, not just Gaspar.
I'm dead certain that I'm not a NAP member. I never implied certainty over Selrahc or Cyneheard. And it would appear that those are the only 3 theories currently on the table.
Honestly, if those two aren't NAP my next bet would be you simply because its absurd to me that you aren't dead yet. If the NAP had a roleblocker and you made your baner case as obvious to everyone as you did (both novice and I picked up on it, at least) any smart wolfpack roleblocks you and then kills you. The Lewwyn kill in particular made no sense given current village suspicion levels.
Right now I'm simply wagering on the NAP being stupid. But that they've ignored you and novice this long makes absolutely no logical sense. Ichabod's role confirms novice, but you're still hanging in there on your word.
(Seriously, NAPers, if you have a roleblocker - wtf are you doing?)
I've got some dirt on my shoulder, can you brush it off for me?
Posts: 3,140
Threads: 26
Joined: Feb 2009
Posts: 5,641
Threads: 30
Joined: Apr 2009
Gaspar Wrote:(Seriously, NAPers, if you have a roleblocker - wtf are you doing?)
And now there's a bandwagon forming on the roleblocker??? Give me some credit here.
Posts: 5,641
Threads: 30
Joined: Apr 2009
Ok, ok, two votes isn't a bandwagon, but Mardoc isn't even explaining why he's switching. Selrahc, sure, whatever, he doesn't want to die (even though he wanted the day to end early???).
Posts: 6,457
Threads: 134
Joined: Aug 2004
I think it'd make sense for the wolves to keep me alive and simply block me every night as long as they have shots. If Cyneheard has unlimited shots, that'd make plenty sense.
Why is Selrahc a better lynch than Cyneheard? Going to switch my vote as well to keep the discussion going, I don't think it's wise to effectively end the day early.
Posts: 6,457
Threads: 134
Joined: Aug 2004
Gaspar Wrote:I'm dead certain that I'm not a NAP member. I never implied certainty over Selrahc or Cyneheard. And it would appear that those are the only 3 theories currently on the table.
Honestly, if those two aren't NAP my next bet would be you simply because its absurd to me that you aren't dead yet. If the NAP had a roleblocker and you made your baner case as obvious to everyone as you did (both novice and I picked up on it, at least) any smart wolfpack roleblocks you and then kills you. The Lewwyn kill in particular made no sense given current village suspicion levels.
Right now I'm simply wagering on the NAP being stupid. But that they've ignored you and novice this long makes absolutely no logical sense. Ichabod's role confirms novice, but you're still hanging in there on your word.
(Seriously, NAPers, if you have a roleblocker - wtf are you doing?) While this is an excellent conspiracy theory (I knew you had it in you  ), I think the Lewwyn kill only makes some sense if the NAP believed there's a baner. Lewwyn was not completely in the clear, it would have been possible to arrange a mislynch on him. Moreover, we have reason to believe that the NAP did a roleblock tonight (most likely Cyneheard). I'm guessing they wanted to save the roleblocker for someone with a potentially dangerous ability (guessing correctly, if you're telling the truth which I believe you are). In deciding not to block me, they may have decided to go for a target that was unlikely to be protected. And it's pretty safe to assume I wouldn't protect Lewwyn
With me as NAP, it's unlikely I'd claim baner in the event that someone else could call me out on it. And there'd be no good reason to target Lewwyn. You're not a very likely stealth wolf, only reason I'd consider you is the whole blocking issue. That's why I'm inching closer to lynching Cyneheard, to resolve the vig issue.
Posts: 5,641
Threads: 30
Joined: Apr 2009
Catwalk Wrote:While this is an excellent conspiracy theory (I knew you had it in you ), I think the Lewwyn kill only makes some sense if the NAP believed there's a baner. Lewwyn was not completely in the clear, it would have been possible to arrange a mislynch on him. Moreover, we have reason to believe that the NAP did a roleblock tonight (most likely Cyneheard). I'm guessing they wanted to save the roleblocker for someone with a potentially dangerous ability (guessing correctly, if you're telling the truth which I believe you are). In deciding not to block me, they may have decided to go for a target that was unlikely to be protected. And it's pretty safe to assume I wouldn't protect Lewwyn
With me as NAP, it's unlikely I'd claim baner in the event that someone else could call me out on it. And there'd be no good reason to target Lewwyn. You're not a very likely stealth wolf, only reason I'd consider you is the whole blocking issue. That's why I'm inching closer to lynching Cyneheard, to resolve the vig issue.
Why the hell would I have claimed when I did? Since I'd spent my ability, I didn't see much harm in revealing it, there was no pressure on me to reveal, and roleblocking was in discussion there, so I thought the extra data would be helpful. If I was NAP and still had shots left, why would I broadcast that as my ability? A roleblocking NAP would be too valuable to risk exposing needlessly. My reveal only makes sense if it was a low-cost reveal.
|
