OH wow ... at first I was going to vote Gaspar for MJW enlightened meta-reasons ... but now I am doubly sure of Sareln.
Although Sareln, if you are a villager you should use your power on Gaspar again XD ... yea right ... because its between you or Gaspar in my eyes (if Catwalk is the wolf this game, I'd say his improvements give him a 'deserve to win' award ... at least from what yall keep going on about)
So yea ... Gaspar doesn't seem to be lying (due to Gaspar's reveal), so the only reason Sareln revealed was because he wanted Gaspar to be on his side. Sure he could have placed the blame on Catwalk, but he saw Gaspar being suspicious of me for some reason because of the Day 4 vote (even though this game, assuming Cyneheard's guild, SEEMED to be decided on Day 4, not Day 3 as Gaspar assumed.) When Slowcheetah was a wolf, all was revealed. It was revealed that slowcheetah and selrahc were both wolves, otherwise why would slowcheetah defend Selrahc so recklessly? Sure I was cautious of voting for Ichabod, but I was all tin-foil-hat zakalwe might be lying business.
So here is my theory right now.
If catwalk is the wolf ... kudos, brava, let me buy you a drink.
If Gaspar is the wolf ... meh, this is just as tin-foil-hat as if Zakalwe was a wolf.
If MJW is the wolf ... very interesting set up by Uberfish, and VERY lucky guess by MJW. I see this as being less likely than Gaspar.
And I know I'm not a wolf. But I suppose for everyone's interest, If I was a wolf then I'd be "tempted" to say kudos ... but since Day 5 and Day 6 were PREORDAINED I TELLS YOU!!! then this would practically be like a day 5 for me, as far as rating my wolf play would be concerned.
Ah ... I now see why Sareln revealed. He wanted to get the Cyneheard 'free kill' out of the way.
[SIZE="7"]HE MADE CYNEHEARD TAKE THE FALL FOR HIS OWN DAMNED GOOF.[/SIZE]
Honestly? It wasn't a goof. He wanted Cyneheard to take the fall so that he could get another mislynch. Why?
[SIZE="7"]BECAUSE HE IS THE LAST WOLF![/SIZE]
The only reason he revealed now is because he thinks he can get another mislynch on me today, and then maybe, just maybe, get a mislynch on Catwalk or Gaspar the next day.
WELL LET ME TELL YOU THIS ... I AM NOT FALLING FOR IT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Selrahc and Slowcheetah threw themselves on Lewwyn's Crusading Celtic Sword on day 4, so you've been planning this (or similar) since then. Haven't you?
I think that when Catwalk and I were asking you about your power on Day 6, you slightly made a slip when you accused me of railroading you. This is my first forum game, but such an accusation during the circumstances of the time seems highly illogical for a villager. Why be defensive this late in the game? We had 4 whole tries to get it right ... and if we killed you, we would have a better idea of who blocked Gaspar's kill.
Oh wait. That was you.
And its NOT EVEN that you blocked his kill that makes you a wolf.
Its that you let Cyneheard TAKE THE FALL.
The ONLY reason he fell was because he was suspected of making the kill block ... if you were a villager you would have KNOWN THAT. So the only reason you could have let him die without revealing what you knew, was either out of some personal vendetta (which I hope people don't have too many of around here
) or because you are a wolf.
I wonder if Gaspar has any shots left ...
Oh wait. You can role block him AND Kill him in the same night. tsk tsk ...
Gaspar, I am about as sure that Sareln is the wolf at this point as you were that Cyneheard was the wolf.
If Sareln isn't the wolf I'm about ready to quit ... because everything in my mind is telling me that Sareln is the wolf.
Days 1-5: plays the perfect game
Day 6: gets a mislynch
kill Mardoc (because of the suspicion on Gaspar no doubt)
----------------------
and here we are at day 7
Day 7: go for another mislynch (probably me, due to Gaspar throwing suspicions upon me the previous day)
Night 7: kill Gaspar (leaving only MJW, Catwalk, and yourself)
Day 8: The trickiest one yet ... yet somehow you have to get one of the village to turn on the other.
If Day 8, the tricky day, succeeds for you ... then congratulations: wolf Victory.
---------------------------------
Catwalk, how does your baner power work?
If I get mislynched today ...
then I think Catwalk should 'bane' Sareln, if you get to pick one of the wolves as a method of blocking the night kill, and then Gaspar can send a vig at Sareln.
That way ... at least one of the powers will hit!
Gaspar and Tasuke have confrimed roles and so unlikely to be wolfs otherwise Cyneheard would suck. I think uberfish would rather make him the plain-villager than give him a crappy role. So the last possible wolf from the metagame viewpoint are Catwalk and Sarlen. Normally I would kill catwalk first but the wolfs can no-kill the last day so Sarlen does not have to give us anymore information.
Beyond Gaspar, I think anyone might be a wolf. MJW, I think you're giving Tasunke a pass much too easily here. Other players have marginally useful abilities, Cyneheard's doesn't stand out here.