WW48: Melllvar's Grand Competition!

[Gaspar]

Anyone want to join on Gaspar who had been as AFK as me and who had been posting listicles?

Convenient.

[pindicator]

@pindicator, 1413 - what do you mean there about protecting Meiz? Didn’t you protect Rowain?

@pindicator - you talked today about one reason you wanted to die before Lewwyn. I asked you about this late day 3 and you said you’d say the full reason post-game. I know there’s no vote pressure on you now but I don’t love you withholding part of that reason.

1413 i had to go and reread because that didn't make sense. I think I just mixed up my subjects when typing that out.

For your second question, I don't love it either. Best answer i can give you without upsetting Brick is that I don't want to upset Brick.

I don't know if I catch up in reading before deadline. I'm supposed to leave right at deadline and have a lot to do to get ready. Will post as I go

Wait a sec. Look at 1415. Here you don’t mess up - you soften and say you scum had to consider MAY have been protecting Meiz. So in 1413 you weren’t messing up your subjects...the whole point there was Meiz was unlikely to be making up his role-removal claim since they’d fear protection. If you meant Rowain there and not Meiz your defense of Meiz makes no sense.

1415 fits. Of course scum had to think I might protect Meiz, he was whom I had protected the previous night.

Sunrise, I could still be persuaded to go back to Meiz. I'm really afraid that I'm being clouded regarding him but I could definitely go back.

[pindicator]

Anyone want to join on Gaspar who had been as AFK as me and who had been posting listicles?

Oh now he wants to vote Gaspar!

[Meiz]

@pindicator, 1413 - what do you mean there about protecting Meiz? Didn’t you protect Rowain?

@pindicator - you talked today about one reason you wanted to die before Lewwyn. I asked you about this late day 3 and you said you’d say the full reason post-game. I know there’s no vote pressure on you now but I don’t love you withholding part of that reason.

1413 i had to go and reread because that didn't make sense. I think I just mixed up my subjects when typing that out.

For your second question, I don't love it either. Best answer i can give you without upsetting Brick is that I don't want to upset Brick.

I don't know if I catch up in reading before deadline. I'm supposed to leave right at deadline and have a lot to do to get ready. Will post as I go

Wait a sec. Look at 1415. Here you don’t mess up - you soften and say you scum had to consider MAY have been protecting Meiz. So in 1413 you weren’t messing up your subjects...the whole point there was Meiz was unlikely to be making up his role-removal claim since they’d fear protection. If you meant Rowain there and not Meiz your defense of Meiz makes no sense.

1415 fits.  Of course scum had to think I might protect Meiz, he was whom I had protected the previous night.

Sunrise, I could still be persuaded to go back to Meiz.  I'm really afraid that I'm being clouded regarding him but I could definitely go back.

So.. I'm guessing your 1413 referred to an earlier protection on me? I can't recall if you've done that or not.

[Rowain]

@pindicator - I mean, yeah, you, Jabbz, Gold isn’t exactly unbelievable.

@Meiz - the bob train seems super sudden and semi-random. The case is just ‘onto posts lists and never voted near deadline so his vote can never swing things’?

Yes it seems but do you say those 5 voters are scum? Who of them?

Well in that scenario, in response to pind, it would be pind and Gold, kinda obviously I’d have thought...

So you say pindi and GES are scum voting Bob but then you turn around and vote Gaspar? Or do I miss something there?

[sunrise089]

@pindicator - I mean, yeah, you, Jabbz, Gold isn’t exactly unbelievable.

@Meiz - the bob train seems super sudden and semi-random. The case is just ‘onto posts lists and never voted near deadline so his vote can never swing things’?

Yes it seems but do you say those 5 voters are scum? Who of them?

Well in that scenario, in response to pind, it would be pind and Gold, kinda obviously I’d have thought...

Who would be your 3rd wolf?

Jabbz. Rowain this isn’t like by big case here, this is directly in response to pind saying “well then the wolves would be me [pind], gold, and Jabbz” and me agreeing that they sure could be :     I’m just trying to push back on pind acting like that’s a wild pairing.

[Alhambram]

What is it with GES? Not thinking for himself but just voting along Rowain because he thinks that he is town. Lazy!

[pindicator]

@pindicator - I mean, yeah, you, Jabbz, Gold isn’t exactly unbelievable.

@Meiz - the bob train seems super sudden and semi-random. The case is just ‘onto posts lists and never voted near deadline so his vote can never swing things’?

Yes it seems but do you say those 5 voters are scum? Who of them?

Well in that scenario, in response to pind, it would be pind and Gold, kinda obviously I’d have thought...

Who would be your 3rd wolf?

It would have to be Jabbz, no?  He confirmed the reading GES gave.  Except i am pretty sure Jabbz is town.  I shouldn't be so sure but I am


@Meiz, I'm pretty sure I just mixed up subjects and wrote 'you' where I should have written Rowain. It's not like this is unusual for me. I've been mixing up Novice with Noble half the game.

[sunrise089]

Rowain - my biggest crime this game is not quoting pindicator’s post but rather just @‘ing since I’m on mobile. I am sorry this is costing us so much time over nothing. In general I don’t find your ‘figure out complete groupings’ of scum style intuitive or helpful. I am glad it works for you. I get sometimes if X is scum then Y is unlikely to be or whatever, but otherwise I don’t view them as package deals.

[pindicator]

So.. I'm guessing your 1413 referred to an earlier protection on me? I can't recall if you've done that or not.

Night 2. You don't read anything I write, do you?

I'm taking a shower. If Meiz is pulling this as scum, I'll give that ultimatum now and say I won't play with him again.