Werewolf 3 Game Thread

[scooter]

Novice and Meiz, why are you voting for me? It'd be nice if you, you know, actually had reasons..?

Novice has been borderline obsesseed with me all game long and yet he's never responded to a single thing I've written defending myself. In fact, I can't think of anything meaningful you've written in quite some time. You've been mentioning me non-stop for about 6-7 RL days, and every time I've responded to you, you've ignored me.

[scooter]

Fun fact: The only time scooters vote has been part of the lynching was when we killed Selrahc. He has perfect voting record and no innocent blood in his hands. If you don't count the night killings, that is.

So you're going to lynch me because I've done well so far? Okay..?

[Meiz]

So you're going to lynch me because I've done well so far? Okay..?

Read the last part of my quote again

[scooter]

Novice and Meiz, why are you voting for me? It'd be nice if you, you know, actually had reasons..?

Novice has been borderline obsesseed with me all game long and yet he's never responded to a single thing I've written defending myself. In fact, I can't think of anything meaningful you've written in quite some time. You've been mentioning me non-stop for about 6-7 RL days, and every time I've responded to you, you've ignored me.

This is probably a bit too confrontational than I intended, but this is just frustrating... I spend a couple hours yesterday going through voting records, trying to figure out who on earth to lynch, and I write up a lengthy-ish post detailing my findings... And then I immediately get jumped on by two people who just go "LOL let's vote scooter" rather than actual taking the time to consider what I wrote... No wonder we're losing.

[novice]

Novice and Meiz, why are you voting for me? It'd be nice if you, you know, actually had reasons..?

Yup. I suspect both of being wolves. If the wolves are killing off ex-wolves, these two are either lucky and unlikely, or they're the ones doing the killing.

My feeling is that scooter has been doing this sort of thing all game long, supporting every theory that could be plausibly supported, and never called out anything as bullshit. (Although this is one theory he's bound to call bullshit.)

Novice has been borderline obsesseed with me all game long and yet he's never responded to a single thing I've written defending myself. In fact, I can't think of anything meaningful you've written in quite some time. You've been mentioning me non-stop for about 6-7 RL days, and every time I've responded to you, you've ignored me.

Really. I don't want to go down the Roland<->Lewwyn route of chest-thumping here, but I've posting pretty consistently and I've been trying to contribute. Maybe you have the cheat sheet, so nothing I say makes any sense?

[scooter]

Can't you see how I'm frustrated when I just spent a ton of time trying to determine who's a wolf and the best you can come up with for me is "the wolves from last game have been dying recently"..? I mean, seriously? Why do I even bother trying if what I write will just get ignored by you like it has all game? Just now was honestly the first time I can think of where you've actually responded to me this game, and you've been mentioning me as a suspect since early day 2. Tunnel vision much?

[novice]

This is probably a bit too confrontational than I intended, but this is just frustrating... I spend a couple hours yesterday going through voting records, trying to figure out who on earth to lynch, and I write up a lengthy-ish post detailing my findings... And then I immediately get jumped on by two people who just go "LOL let's vote scooter" rather than actual taking the time to consider what I wrote... No wonder we're losing.

I fear that the voting records may tell us very little about who to lynch. Anything can be explained by a double feint. That's why I obsess on my intuitions.

Besides, there are only so many suspects left, four of them must be wolves, and you haven't convinced me of being a villager. At this point a lynch without evidence might be a necessity.

[Roland]

Roland, does your vote not count anymore? Cause otherwise I see 3 votes on Zakalwe...

Haven't you been paying attention? My vote never counts! Once again, that's what I get for posting in a rush while at work - don't double-check my work, and end up with errors. :neenernee

My point is simply that is would be easy and natural for a wolf to seize on these thoughts and write up an appealing theory for next day's lynch. And your thoughts were not the only thoughts to be seized upon, I for example also shared my suspicions on Zakalwe.

Yeah, you're right (of course). I knew I had laid out my suspicions about zakalwe yesterday, but I suppose it really wouldn't be that hard to extrapolate and build such a case from my (and others') comments.

This is probably a bit too confrontational than I intended, but this is just frustrating... I spend a couple hours yesterday going through voting records, trying to figure out who on earth to lynch, and I write up a lengthy-ish post detailing my findings... And then I immediately get jumped on by two people who just go "LOL let's vote scooter" rather than actual taking the time to consider what I wrote... No wonder we're losing.

I'm somewhat in agreement here. Maybe I'm just being completely blind, but frankly I'm not feeling the whole "scooter is a 'Wolf" thing. Honestly, I could believe Meiz is a 'Wolf over scooter. I'm not saying he's innocent, but I'm not convinced.

[scooter]

I fear that the voting records may tell us very little about who to lynch. Anything can be explained by a double feint. That's why I obsess on my intuitions.

Besides, there are only so many suspects left, four of them must be wolves, and you haven't convinced me of being a villager. At this point a lynch without evidence might be a necessity.

I honestly have no idea how you could've read my post about Zakalwe and said that it doesn't help or that it doesn't matter. I also have no idea how Zakalwe, Ichabod, fire&ice, Rowain, Gold Ergo Sum, JKaen, and Lewwyn could possibly be more likely villagers than me. Or even you for that matter. If you want to lynch someone who's actually helped so far, fine, I'll stay out of this thread and let you guys burn another one of our villager kills. I'm hoping that others will have a little more common sense though, so I'm not gonna go all suicidal drama queen just yet. It seems clear to me that you are either a wolf trying to discredit/eliminate a villager who's suddenly doing too good of a job of drawing conclusions, or you are a villager with a severe case of tunnel vision. I'm still thinking/hoping it's the latter.

[novice]

Tunnel vision much?

I have no idea what you're talking about. Btw why are we the only ones posting in this thread?