Heh, there's more people posting in the lurker thread than here. Probably talking about how doomed we are
Vote tally:
Maniac: Molach, Bobchillingworth
Selrahc: Meiz, Waterbat
Not voting: Maniac, Selrahc, Brick
My thoughts on Selrahc:
He could be a wolf, but he doesn't seem as likely a suspect as Brick, Meiz or Maniac. About as likely as Molach, although I still think that diary thing is weird. Why would a wolf fake-claim baner to stay alive, when the other person up was also a wolf? It could be that Selrahc's power was much more powerful than Injera's, and keeping himself alive was a priority- this might make sense if he is roleblocker, since that seems like a much better wolf role than delayed-lyncher, but surely the pack could have done more to prevent two wolves being up at the same time, like throwing more votes on Lewwyn- they wouldn't even have needed too many to lynch him, since Zak could double-vote.
Third faction / SK makes some more sense, although I'm seeing a lot more conjecture than evidence (albeit that's describes the cases against every suspect now). I'm eager to get any more use out of my power that I can, so I could scan Selrahc tonight to find out what his deal is.
Caveats:
* If he dies in the night it's a waste, although we'll find out whether he's village or not that way too
* If I die in the night it's a wash obviously, although that may be a sign that I was on to something.
* If Selrahc is a wolf I won't detect anything, unless he's hiding behind an alter ego for some weird reason (doctors aren't particularly suspicious).
* It's also possible that Selrahc is indeed 3rd party, but is using his real role, although I think this is unlikely as well. Surely a mindworm or something similarly nasty would have a cover ID.
The other person I was thinking of scanning is Waterbat- no offense Waterbat, I think you're not NAP, but your ability does make sense as being part of a larger messenger role which allows for these weird anon messages. Anyway, I think that's all a diversion and not worth actually voting on, at least not now.
Btw, something which came to me while writing this post- during the Injera night lynch, Zak did try to start getting votes on Maniac- would a wolf do that if Maniac is one of them? It never went anywhere, so maybe so. Hard to say, I could see the case for either possibility. Hoping Waterbat can share with us tomorrow what the deal with Maniac is. Based on what he said his ability is named I think I can guess anyway, but I'm less interested in exactly what he can do and more about whether he has a legit reason for keeping so much to himself, and what read Waterbat has got on his village status.
