Werewolf 2 Lurker Thread: Spoilers!

[MJW (ya that one)]

I sent him the message immediatly after he did his edit so while it may have been long ago but that was 72 hours previously and i did give him a chance to change his plan in tread.

Right when the night phase turned into the day phase

Expand...

[MJW (ya that one)]

I'm happy that I was right about the godfather role. But are there 7 bad guys?! Wow! The village is going down. I'm happy that I died "early" so I don't have to see the village get ripped apart.

[MJW (ya that one)]

I was seeing several of his posts with all the content they contained was

.

Only having a period and knowing that he was editing it bacause the post mentioned it.

Next post will contain at least one of his "period posts"

All but one was on the first 3 pages and I did not get any warnings...

[fire&ice]

The right when day started i sent you an pm telling you the i was roleblocking you for !1! night that game you 48 hours to plan how you would spin it to the wolves during the day and 24 hours after that to beg for mercy its been expanded.

[MJW (ya that one)]

The right when day started i sent you an pm telling you the i was roleblocking you for !1! night that game you 48 hours to plan how you would spin it to the wolves during the day and 24 hours after that to beg for mercy its been expanded.

If you mod another game I will confront you directly in the thread. Pretty much everyone in this lurker thread thinks your wrong about roleblocking me; over that one post. You had much time to warn me. Those first to blocks where simple cross-posts and other people have edited their posts.

Edit:
I have to agree with t-hawk. The game mecanics show that the village and wolfs really do not care about eachother. For this reason if this game reflects real-life at all no one should care if your team won but you died. For this reason the best idea is to never say anything ever. The second that you care about how your team does it becomes more of a weird voting game where you want to get night-killed if you're a villager to spare a powerrole.

[luddite]

I'm offically spoiler. F&I would have to find a replacement if he changes his mind.

Luddite: I said to post it in the thread.

Sorry MJW. I did post here asking F&I if he was really going to do this, but he didn't respond so I thought that meant it wasn't going to happen (or had already happened on night 2 when I died). If I'd thought he was actually going to role-block you over this I would have argued against it earlier.

Basically it comes down to this: regardless of what MJW did, this is just punishing everyone else for his mistake. If you wanted to punish him, this is a weird way to do it. And his mistake really wasn't that bad.

Anyway it's too late now, since we can't bring MJW back from the dead, so we'll just have to live with it. I guess it sort of balances out with not telling selrahc until late about his devil role . But then you also denied Sunrise from scrying so.... I don't know. And if Selrahc hadn't run for mayor, I wouldn't have trusted him so much and gotten myself killed.

[MJW (ya that one)]

1. 6 ww was way to much. I knew that there had to be more serect roles. I wanted to roleclaim so I could put the serect roles together. I should have came up with that mason trick that luddite said above. I thought that Kyan was a ww and did that trick given above. I trusted luddite because he seemed honest and what ww would want mayor anyway? I did not trust Selrec . I hate that fur tax... I tried everything to get sandover lyched because I knew that their was no fool role. 6 wws are an awful lot! My role-pm play was just made to make Sandover flinch and that worked. A typical unsound attack in a beginers game. I proteced myself because mayor is not a power-role with odd number of players.

2. I thought Meiz was stronger than Gasper because I think Gasper got very mad at me. He posted a fast and emotinal response to my un-reval. I like how Roland was not flamed when he dropped the owl role in a post that took a long time to make. I protected Kyan because I guessed I would not be attacked and I did not want him to be killed randomlly.

3. I did not think I would stay roleblocked. The plan was to kill a ww and make the ww think that the seer did not contact us. Very plasible because Sunrise is the kind of person to drop a scry. (Not scry someone and so have no-one to back him up with his claims. This would leave him cut-off from the baner) The wws would try and take the free seer I which I would block. Then Roland gave the wws a "gift". I pretened to go afk to make the wolves think I was nervious and was sticking to the obvious first plan. I knew that they would hit me because the ban-ner maintains a lot of tension and beginers in all games try and get rid of the tension as fast as possible. Plus uberfish acted like he had a chance to live the next day and that is only possible if the wws think sunrise won't die. I'm the only other major target. Kyan in his last PM to me suggested... Sunrise! I spent around 45 minutes chosening who to protect. So I guessed hours were not wasted decideing who to choose...

4. My guess for the last wws are Uberfish, Sedro, Scooter and Rowain. Sedro and Scooter are on that list because they did not act sad at my death at all. They don't post much at all and never fast responed to anything. Rowain is on that list because he trys to gain my trust (which makes me feel nervious) and has the same posting issue. He also said that the owl might be a ww in a PM and also suggested Gasper was a ww. I am pretty sure about the first 3 but lets see how wrong I am. But there are 7 werewolfs???

Kyan last PM to me.

I would tell sunrise your scry choice to avoid wasting scrys. It seems obvious but after Roland outed you and sunrise . I liked how Gasper flamed me and Roland was not flamed.

If you have no idea who to scry I would chose Gasper. He will likely get lyched if he does not get scryed. Sedro is another good idea to!

Hey MJW,

We're going to scry Irgy and Dantski. Irgy has been way too quiet and i suspect Dantski of being a wolf. We'll see what happens.

I'd reccomend protecting Sunrise tonight. I thought about it a lot and he's too obvious a kill target since he got revealed today.


-Kyan

[Sullla]

You killed the baner even though he protected himself? For some sort of minor out-of-game transgression? Really?! That seems ridiculously over the top and unfair to me, and I'm barely even watching this thing.

Anyway... hopefully everyone can learn from some of the mistakes in this game so that they don't happen again if there are future werewolf/mafia games. I think most everyone would agree that there have been some real problems in how this was organized, administered, and played.

[luddite]

1. 6 ww was way to much. I knew that there had to be more serect roles.

There's actually 7 ww... you were right about there being a godfather (possessed). I think the only reason we were lucky enough to hang a ww on day one was that there were so many wolves, we had good odds of guessing one at random.

[MJW (ya that one)]

There's actually 7 ww... you were right about there being a godfather (possessed). I think the only reason we were lucky enough to hang a ww on day one was that there were so many wolves, we had good odds of guessing one at random.

I would guess Dantski being possessed. He acts very cocky. To bad he got scryed. So that's why Kyan was sad! Roland & company might take out all the wws and then when they are dead and can not back up Dantski who would be finshed off for generally strange actions.

We see how wrong I was when the town loses and F&I posts the role spoilers.