Werewolf 3 Game Thread

[Meiz]

Three wolves remaining: Rowain, Scooter, Mardoc.

[Ichabod]

YEAH!

Thank you, Baner!

I'm back in the game now. My real life issues are gone (even though the result of it probably won't be what I wanted...) and I can use this game to forget about it.

It's good to be alive!

[Roland]

Three wolves remaining: Rowain, Scooter, Mardoc.

While I don't agree 100% with your list, Rowain is as good a place to start as any.

[scooter]

Alright, so my theory about Ichabod being a werewolf is obviously wrong, and I am very happy to be wrong in this case .

I'd like to touch back on something I said early on in the night phase. It was a question I asked... I didn't necessarily expect an answer on this one, but it was a strong thought that occurred to me:

Rowain + Novice: Why do we have this crazy suspect triangle between the three of us? Novice suspects Rowain and I. Rowain suspects Novice and I. I wasn't heavily suspecting either of you until your recent strange behavior. Don't either of you find it unsettling that the people you highly suspect agree with you on the other person you highly suspect? I tend to think that this behavior is so bizarre, that one of the three of us (and probably no more than that) is a wolf, and I know it's not me.... So...

I've become convinced of this. scooter, Rowain, novice: one of us three are wolves. I know it's not me, and I tend to doubt that it is novice, so logically, I believe it is probably Rowain. Add onto that thet quotes Meiz dug up from Bruinane defending him (in a somewhat odd manner too), and Rowain looks like a good target to me honestly. Zakalwe is still way up near/at the top of my list as well, so I will be happy if either one of those two are lynched. I wish I could put 1/2 vote down on each of them, but for now I will wait on my vote. Just know that unless something drastic changes, one of those two will likely get my vote.

[Mardoc]

Excellent! We finally know somebody to be innocent! And all that chaos yesterday means that we're making good progress, even if we couldn't vote on a wolf.

Three wolves remaining: Rowain, Scooter, Mardoc.

Now, hang on here! I'm a villager. Admittedly, my voting has been unlucky, and my seeing of wolves faulty, but that doesn't mean you should lynch me!

I've got no firm beliefs on Rowain and Scooter, pro or con. Rowain's Pocketbeetle crusade still seems suspicious, but I haven't seen enough yet to vote him. Frankly, 1800 posts is starting to get too much for me to keep rereading.

[novice]

@scooter: Why exactly is it odd, and why is one of us a wolf?

[Gold Ergo Sum]

Best baner ever.

No kidding.

Glad to have Ichabod on Team Village. He seems to have a good mind for this game when he has time to play.

So who does that leave us for major suspects today? Rowain, Zakalwe, and scooter?

[scooter]

@scooter: Why exactly is it odd, and why is one of us a wolf?

I guess it's simple. If I really suspected two people, I would naturally be skeptical of things that they say. If the two people that I suspected the most also suspected each other... How do I make sense of that? If I strongly believe that they are both wolves, then it doesn't make that much sense if they are suspecting each other. That would then cause me to think one was probably innocent and caught up in the whole thing.

That's the same scenario we have here. Don't you think it's odd that you suspect Rowain and I, and Rowain and I suspect each other? Obviously if you are a wolf then you are probably just laughing about this whole thing, but this whole triangle doesn't make much sense if 2/3 of us are wolves, and it would be equally surprising if all of us are innocent. Do you disagree?

[novice]

@scooter: That makes sense thanks for spelling it out. Except you don't really suspect me, do you?

[Meiz]

@scooter. Yep, a wolf would never suspect another wolf in the public thread

(sorry for jumping in, please continue)