Posts: 3,045
Threads: 2
Joined: Aug 2006
Rowain Wrote:If you are a wolf I do like you because then you are trying to do your job
but if you are a villager you are a walking catastophe and doing your best to lose the villagers the game and yes in that case I don't like you.
I am a villager 
Posts: 6,630
Threads: 47
Joined: Apr 2010
Meiz - if you are a villager, you are really a catastrophe, even if Rowain is a wolf 
Posts: 3,045
Threads: 2
Joined: Aug 2006
Serdoa Wrote:Meiz - if you are a villager, you are really a catastrophe, even if Rowain is a wolf
It's likely, but I'm trying my best  . I think I actually have a real case against Rowain, but feel free to disagree and point out the flaws.
Posts: 3,045
Threads: 2
Joined: Aug 2006
I just have to quote Rowain's answer against PB (sorry for spam again)
Rowain Wrote:Howl what you want.
But calling a wolf a wolf is not bad behaviour. It is what all villagers try to do here. <snip>
And you can be sure I will vote for you until one of us swings or I'm eaten.
Posts: 8,244
Threads: 30
Joined: Jun 2004
There are a few differences
a) I did offer to let me be lynched the next day if PB turned out a villager. b) Afterwards I didn't lobby hard for any lynch contrary to you who has already voted for 4 proven villagers and still do the same
c) You even refuse to let the people decide for their own before you spill your up to this day completely wrong votes.
As said before anyone makes mistakes in a game like this votes for villagers or trusts wolves. But the key is learning from the mistakes not babling stubbornly on and on.
Posts: 7,902
Threads: 13
Joined: Aug 2006
Well, I'm about to head off, so I need to make a decision. I'm having trouble reading Rowain here, but his theory accusing JKaen is quite unconvincing; he basically just bolded three names in the voting records, perhaps hoping someone else would see a significant pattern. And when he did get support for his theory he immediately wanted to move on to another unspecified suspect, which puzzles me. I almost get the feeling that Rowain could be a wolf, while JKaen is the void-wolf; Rowain thought he was doomed and voted for JKaen to provide cover, but when the vote unexpectedly tipped all the way over, he now needs to backpedal. That theory may well be a little too optimistic, though.
Anyway, there are many small pieces of evidence pointing towards Rowain, though I have to admit that nothing is very conclusive in itself. The way Bruindane emphasized that both of Pocketbeetle and Rowain were likely to be innocent is noteworthy, the mayor campaign and his general erratic behavior could be a cover, and Selrahc's voting on day 2 also implicates Rowain (but not just him). So in conclusion, I will cross my fingers and flip my vote back to Rowain, since I remain unconvinced of his innocence.
Posts: 5,157
Threads: 37
Joined: Jan 2011
Rowain Wrote:There are a few differences
a) I did offer to let me be lynched the next day if PB turned out a villager. b) Afterwards I didn't lobby hard for any lynch contrary to you who has already voted for 4 proven villagers and still do the same
c) You even refuse to let the people decide for their own before you spill your up to this day completely wrong votes.
As said before anyone makes mistakes in a game like this votes for villagers or trusts wolves. But the key is learning from the mistakes not babling stubbornly on and on.
Rowain, I assume the accusations are equally against me as well as Meiz if so:
Today Meiz votes 1st, you 5th, me 8th, so I can hardly be accused of not letting others make their own minds up
Learning from mistakes and not babbling on: Rowain 199 posts, Meiz 174 posts, Jkaen 105 posts
Posts: 7,902
Threads: 13
Joined: Aug 2006
Vote Tally:
6v: Rowain ( Meiz, Roland, Ichabod, JKaen, Mardoc, Zakalwe )
3v: JKaen ( Serdoa, Gold Ergo Sum, Lewwyn )
1v: Zakalwe ( Scooter )
1v: Scooter ( Novice )
Not voting: Rowain
History:
Posts: 3,045
Threads: 2
Joined: Aug 2006
Rowain Wrote:There are a few differences
a) I did offer to let me be lynched the next day if PB turned out a villager. b) Afterwards I didn't lobby hard for any lynch contrary to you who has already voted for 4 proven villagers and still do the same
c) You even refuse to let the people decide for their own before you spill your up to this day completely wrong votes.
a) That's the stupidest thing villager can do. b) This is my very first real crusade against someone. If I'm wrong, I promise to rethink my game strategy  . c) I'm not forcing anyone to vote, am I? People can disagree with me as much as they like, I don't mind. I'm just voting for the person I think is the most likely wolf.
Ok, enough about me now. I'll shut up mostly for the rest of the day (unless someone poses a question for me to answer). See you at the gallows! 
Posts: 8,244
Threads: 30
Joined: Jun 2004
zakalwe Wrote:So in conclusion, I will cross my fingers and flip my vote back to Rowain, since I remain unconvinced of his innocence.
What a surprise  . As if you didn't vote together with Jkaen since day 2
|
