Werewolf 3 Game Thread

[Rowain]

Jkaen

[Ichabod]

This game is making me go crazy...

Want to hear what I thought that happened??

Cull was a wolf. He needed to get out of the game but didn't want to leave the wolves with one less player. Getting a new player on Cull's place would be bizarre and either he would be lynched next (bad for the wolves) or he would be completely trusted (autolose for the villagers).

So Sareln chose the porr Bruindane to become the new wolf while Cull would be mod-killed as a villager. Bruindane was playing very nicely up until then, having helped lynching Selrahc. You may notive that right after that Bruindane started acting crazy, calling Novice the void-wolf for instance and being completely destroyed because of that.

But Bruindane was an honest guy. He realized that what they've done was unfair to the village. So he let himself be modkilled to even the score a bit (if you look at previous "innocent lists" you'll see that a lot ov villagers thought Bruindane to be a villager).

That's why day 1 and 2 don't make sense. Cull was a wolf that got transformed into a villager and Bruindane was a villager transformed into a wolf.

............................

What do you think?

(yeah, it's a joke... but this line of thought actually crossed my mind a few times).

[Ichabod]

When it was between Selrahc and PB, why did Selrahc not vote against PB? He was a villager in lead after all. PB votes at the time: Rowain, Lewwyn, Jkaen, Mardoc, Fire & Ice, Cull, scooter

What if the only reason was, that there were already enough wolves voting for PB, so they had to spread out votes?

Reading the thread I found this... Probably one of the few ways of explaining it that actually make sense (this and my post above, obviously :neenernee).

[Rowain]

Perhaps the simpler version
Cull was a villager and Bruindane a wolf who had played a very good game till then. Seeing the solution for cull he thought the wolf-refusal to let cull get replaced was unfair and he opted to even the field again by acting crazy first (to get lynched) and later to get modkilled.

But in this game nothing would surprise me any longer

[Ichabod]

A little list:

People I believe to be villagers: Bruindane, Ichabod, Jkaen, Serdoa

People I hope to be villagers but fear their wolfishness: novice

People I would insta-lynch(PS only here in this game): Roland

People I hope won't get eaten or lynched too soon(because I like his poems): zakalwe

People I wouldn't mind if the wolves eat them: Lewwyn

The rest: Fire & Ice, Gold ergo sum, Mardoc, Meiz, scooter

PS: I have searched the truth very long

This is from day 5.

"People I believe to be villagers: Bruindane, Ichabod, Jkaen, Serdoa"

Why did you trust JKaen back then, Rowain?

[Mardoc]

What do you think?

(yeah, it's a joke... but this line of thought actually crossed my mind a few times).

I think I trust Sareln more than that. It would completely wreck our chances as a village to not be able to trust the GM to tell us honestly what players are to be used for voting patterns, analyzing what people are saying, and so on. He saw that effect in WW2, where Selrahc was caught out due to an abrupt switch, and the confusion around MJW, and the vast majority of his ruleset was directly aimed at fixing the problems in WW2.

Plus, well, Bruindane's disappeared from the Wesmere succession game, as well, so it's not like it was just this game he's quit on. Or had real life trouble keeping him away.

I think it's simpler - the wolves are trying, and succeeding, at spreading confusion. Plus, well, villagers like me, we're a veritable storm of confusion ourselves.

[Ichabod]

It was just a joke. Sareln is doing a really, really, really good job with this game. That's why I would never truly believe that it happened.

[Rowain]

This is from day 5.

"People I believe to be villagers: Bruindane, Ichabod, Jkaen, Serdoa"

Why did you trust JKaen back then, Rowain?

Because at that time given the voting patterns I thought Jkaen and zakalwe are our masons. So obviuously I didn't name them together but I did also say that I didn't want to get zakalwe killed soon.

Your next question Why did I change my mind:

Simple a) zakalwe did not claim to be mason although he was in great danger yesterday.
and b) Jkaen complete refusal to even consider that he might be wrong given his trackrecord so far.

You will note that I tried to open Jkaen a way out of our deadlock a few hours ago. An offer he did refuse. So now it is either him or me.

[Rowain]

When it was between Selrahc and PB, why did Selrahc not vote against PB? He was a villager in lead after all. PB votes at the time: Rowain, Lewwyn, Jkaen, Mardoc, Fire & Ice, Cull, scooter

What if the only reason was, that there were already enough wolves voting for PB, so they had to spread out votes?

Reading the thread I found this... Probably one of the few ways of explaining it that actually make sense (this and my post above, obviously :neenernee).

Tell me what are you thinking about Meiz' votes on this day. He was on Selrahc. Then as Selrahc made his entrance he switches together with Selrahc on novice and later he -again in company with Selrahc- moved to vote for me.

[Mardoc]

Tell me what are you thinking about Meiz' votes on this day. He was on Selrahc. Then as Selrahc made his entrance he switches together with Selrahc on novice and later he -again in company with Selrahc- moved to vote for me.

Meiz is very good at pushing bandwagons along, getting them critical mass and going. I'm hoping he's using his powers for good.

That is, well, it could go either way. Either he's succeeding at putting pressure on a lot of people to force them to reveal their inner wolf/villager, or he's succeeding at getting a lot of villagers lynched.