WW 31 Game Thread PARANOIA

[Mattimeo]

Hang on, fairly sure I recall novice updating his script to be more inclusive of typographical errors in the hex codes.
Are you using an old version, BRick?

Bobchillingworth

[Catwalk]

Alright, I missed those entirely Old Harry. I'll accept that you did at least post an explanation, rather than dodge it. My bad on that part. I still find your early posts suspicious, but that suspicion will wane if you post more actual contributions and less fluff. I do think that your posts were more fluffy than the rest, yes. In particular, your post where you first promised to give us something to go on and then pointed out that you didn't. I'm not married to a vote on you, but I'm very surprised at how much suspicion I got for voicing those suspicions.

[BRickAstley]

Tally as of post 191:

3 votes: catwalk (Ichabod, novice, Qgqqqqq)
2.23 votes: Bobchillingworth (Serdoa, Mattimeo)
2 votes: Azza (Bobchillingworth, MJW (ya that one))
2 votes: Azarius (Imana-665-C, Old Harry)
2 votes: MJW (sunrise089, Azza)
2 votes: Old Harry (Catwalk, Lewwyn)
1 votes: sunrise089 (Merovech)
1 votes: Merovech (zakalwe)
1 votes: Gazglum (Azarius)
1 votes: [Unvote] (Ryan)
1 votes: Zakalwe (Gazglum)
1 votes: Qgqqqqq (Rowain)

Voting history:

Mattimeo

spacetyrantxenu

[MJW]

BrickAstley

Rowain

sunrise089

novice

Azza

Merovech

Catwalk

Azza

Azarius

Mattimeo

Azarius

MJW

unvote

Gazglum

Azarius

Old Harry

novice

Old Harry

unvote

Ol' Harry

catwalk

unvote

MJW

[Unvote]

Catwalk

No Lynch

Old Harry

MJW

Zakalwe

Catwalk

Gazglum

Azza

Azza

Bobchillingworth

OldHarry

Qgqqqqq

Bobchillingworth

Apparently I was.

[Jowy]

I think zakalwe has abandoned his tryhard town days and gone back to being a lazy scum

I know this is spacetyrantxenu's first ww game, but he seems to be playing up the noob thing a bit, he's devoting a good chunk of page space pitching up questions, rhetorical and otherwise. It could certainly be genuine, it just seems a bit much.

I got the same vibe from him. Kinda wish you waited a bit longer to call him out on it so we'd have more posts to look at. Anyway I think there's a high chance that he is scum and he's laying low by playing the noob card.

[novice]

Awesome song, Catwalk.

I'll stand by my suspicion of Old Harry. I didn't know he's a newbie, but he doesn't seem the sort to be put off by a bit of pressure.

I don't think Bob's proposed strategy is pure nonsense. It has the advantage that we will start lynching at a time where we will have more information from night actions. I don't think that the night kill will be particularly convincing of innocence (nor will it help us a lot to have one maybe somewhat confirmed townie), but other night actions might give us useful clues.

Still, I consider talking to be far more useful to town than to scum, and talking without lynching is essentially useless. For that reason, I'm going to vote against my proposed plan and stick with Old Harry. You haven't even tried to explain your vote on Azarius which was placed with zero justification. It reads to me like scum trying to figure out how to stay active without incriminating himself, and failing at it due to inexperience.

Whose plan is it, yours or Bob's?

And prior to learning that Old Harry was a newbie, how did you read him? Like scum trying to figure out how to stay active without incriminating himself, and failing at it despite being experienced?

For the record, I don't think this is Old Harry's first game, IIRC he played in the anonymous game.

[Ichabod]

Alright, I missed those entirely Old Harry. I'll accept that you did at least post an explanation, rather than dodge it. My bad on that part. I still find your early posts suspicious, but that suspicion will wane if you post more actual contributions and less fluff. I do think that your posts were more fluffy than the rest, yes. In particular, your post where you first promised to give us something to go on and then pointed out that you didn't. I'm not married to a vote on you, but I'm very surprised at how much suspicion I got for voicing those suspicions.

I don't like the bolded part...

[novice]

Brick, can you edit away the apostrophe in this vote? I think it's messing with Mafia Helper.

Ol' Harry

If Jowy starts making sense and contributing in a significant way, he's scum. So don't worry about it Catwalk.

Which part of it did you not understand, Lewwyn?
I could take a go at dumbing it down for you two.

Zing! I'd like to think the post below should be addressed not only to Catwalk for his song but also to Jowy.

Well Played.

I think this is a good point by Azarius, I'd like to see Gazglum's response.

I noticed this post from Gazglum.

Lacking any obvious tells like hammers and sickles being found in people's personnell lockers, I'll vote Zakalwe for making lots of 'maybe X could be scummy' musings without following up with the big red pencil.

Zak, you haven't shifted your first vote yet. Does that mean you think Merovech is genuinely most suspect still?

Lots of x could be scummy musings without backing it up with a vote. In general I would agree that zak does tend to this when he is scum. However, I don't think he has been doing it this game. He has seven posts so far. He only really mentions any type of suspicion in three of them, and of those one is his first post with his joke vote. He questions a bit in the other two, but I think it's a huge stretch to say he's been throwing around lots of suspicion without backing it up.

[MJW (ya that one)]

Azza if you are a villager you are messing up because your baseline about my crazyliness is way off. I've been far worse. For example check out ww2. You don't recall any of those incidents because you weren't in those games.

[MJW (ya that one)]

Novice, no-one called old-harry played in that werewolf game.

[MJW (ya that one)]

Okay, I see how your words don't have to contradict bob. Seroda's higher-level attack against you might be good though...