[No Players] WW 36 Lurkers In The Gallery Of Peanuts

[Qgqqqqq]

Rash of scum to go for Sunrise (unless he is scum), I was expecting a protection role based on the other role reveals.

I think I'd probably lynch Dtay, here. Regardless though, he's played an incredible game as town or scum

[pindicator]

Actually dtay we're tied in post count. In content well... I helped take down Gaspar by adding additional content, which is a lot better than your record.

Will someone call AdrienIer on this? He didn't vote for Gaspar until Gaspar gave up, right?

[Lewwyn]

Actually dtay we're tied in post count. In content well... I helped take down Gaspar by adding additional content, which is a lot better than your record.

Will someone call AdrienIer on this? He didn't vote for Gaspar until Gaspar gave up, right?

Actually Adrien was the third vote onto Gaspar I believe. After him came the rest of the votes and Gaspar's giving up. He legit helped. NOt sure how much content he added, more that he just helped push the wagon by voting.

[Lewwyn]

This is/was the first real WW game since a long time
Many thanks and to Commodore.

Agree, was fun.

[zakalwe]

Admittedly, Dtay still has a point that the gambit makes more sense, strictly speaking, with a scum buddy as the other scan target. Although, that might be trying to fit a rational explanation to something that was ultimately just an irrational play. And AdrienIer still reads townish to me. He outshone Brick yesterday and I think he'll outshine Dtay today.

It also seemed like AdrienIer and Brick were both earnestly trying to survive their face-off. Not sure what exactly to expect if they were both scum, but Brick wasn't able to mount much of a case. That should have been easier to do if AdrienIer was actually his scum buddy.

[Rowain]

That has to be Jabbz' best post all game. If it is dtay, and I can definitely agree with the reasoning, then bravo.

Yes it might have altered the nightkill.


Adrien pushed Gaspar from 2:2 to 3:1 anfd also pushed Mattimeo from 4:4 to 5:4 on day 1. That's rather reason to be suspicious of him but all in all I think I would go with dtay today.

[pling]

Dunno if anyone left in the game is non-North American, so this might not be relevant. Clocks changed for the US (& Canada?) today, but won't change for UK & Europe till the end of the month. So deadline might not happen when people think it might on Monday.

[Gazglum]

Admittedly, Dtay still has a point that the gambit makes more sense, strictly speaking, with a scum buddy as the other scan target. Although, that might be trying to fit a rational explanation to something that was ultimately just an irrational play. And AdrienIer still reads townish to me. He outshone Brick yesterday and I think he'll outshine Dtay today.

Dtay came out firing on all cylinders this day, and actually made me uncertain. His logic on the Brick gambit is impeccable, except that we're dealing with Brick, so 'for the Lulz' has to be taken into account as a motive. But looking over the game as a whole, I don't think you can vote anybody but Dtay today.

It would be such a great Scum play to hide your power role to the end, no-kill, then say that you were targetted like Sunrise has. Except that nothing else points to him being scum, but I would be delighted if that was his genius master plan.

[Lewwyn]

I would argue that Brick's gambit with Adrien as scum just puts way too much attention on too many scum. As a scum gambit it really only makes sense to target another scum if that scum were novice since he was already so under fire that you'd want to try and get some town cred by claiming and then getting novice as scum lynched. But that doesn't work with Adrien as scum because it draws too much attention to someone previously not drawing scummy attention.

dtay has to be lynched, and I think the village will win.

[pindicator]

I suppose it's too late to say I had a dtay=scum post written up the day we lynched novice but I was so tunneled in on novice I disregarded it when I saw him defending novice so openly.