WW16: Lurker Thread [SPOILERS]

[uberfish]

oh wtf is this.

No way scum have both a watcher and a tracker. Therefore of Injera and QQQ is scum.

Scum have watcher and post restrictor. Thats already enough for active power roles in a low power game.

Don't see why scum injera would target catwalk. Catwalk didn't get post restricted either. Think Qqqqq is lying and just trying to take someone down with him because he hasn't been able to shake the generally cloud of suspicion that has been following him around.

[Sareln]

Either Meiz is holding a gigantic idiot-ball or he's wolf.

[Bigger]

oh wtf is this.

No way scum have both a watcher and a tracker. Therefore of Injera and QQQ is scum.

Scum have watcher and post restrictor. Thats already enough for active power roles in a low power game.

Don't see why scum injera would target catwalk. Catwalk didn't get post restricted either. Think Qqqqq is lying and just trying to take someone down with him because he hasn't been able to shake the generally cloud of suspicion that has been following him around.

even assuming we know there is a post-assigning role, how do we know its scum?

lynching Q does seem to be the simplest solution, and novice is being a little too obvious with his efforts to resist it.

[BRickAstley]

Isn't it nice to have a relaxed mafia game based on deduction and reading people, without all the metagaming?

That was the intention. People have really been making things a lot worse than they really are.

[Sareln]

That was the intention. People have really been making things a lot worse than they really are.

If Qgqqqqq and Injera are both villagers, you can't really be blamed for the fact that they've made pretty much the most godawful villager claims I've ever seen.

[zakalwe]

On the other hand, it really makes no sense that Mattimeo would be able to self-target. And why only 3 shots?

There's certainly a suspicious amount of unresolved claims in a game where the number of power roles is supposed to be limited.

(Individual power roles could still be powerful, though. Many seem to overlook this.)

[Sareln]

Most Hilarious Result: Arromir is village and is also a protective role.

[Bigger]

yeah I think its possible Q and matt are both guilty, there are a few things that don't make sense about it.

And Injera too, but they can't all 3 be guilty, haha, and he is certainly the most plausible.

[uberfish]

That was the intention. People have really been making things a lot worse than they really are.

re. metagaming - I have gradually come to the conclusion that metagaming is impossible to avoid when you have a history of quite a few games, and scum being occasionally torpedoed by a town PR is not a bad thing.

[Sareln]

re. metagaming - I have gradually come to the conclusion that metagaming is impossible to avoid when you have a history of quite a few games, and scum being occasionally torpedoed by a town PR is not a bad thing.

Next game the GM just needs to say "Trust me"